Long as they don’t claim him stupidly like they did with Ha-Seong Kim.
Kim is batting .327 for them currently, and he is an established major leaguer. You don’t have a clue
Except you’re forgetting the part where he has an opt-out at the end of the season, the Braves aren’t in the race and they are not allowed to QO him.
@Duran – You keep bringing up that point, but he’s barely played this year (will have played in ~50 games/season with possibly ~0.6 bWAR, if he continues at a similar rate) and they have a head start (better than anyone in free agency) to give him a taste of what it’d be like playing for the team, and he’s been a hit in the clubhouse with friend (and former SD teammate) Profar, something that he said he didn’t have in TB. ATL could make a good, short-term high-AAV offer that would guarantee him a starting SS spot on a competitive team for more guaranteed dollars than the 16M he’s due in 2026 (if he opts-in). No one is giving him 70M+ guaranteed or more.
Had they not picked him up on waivers they would have saved the 2M he was due in ’25…and would have Nick Allen trotting out there (possibly winning GG with Winn out…) with MLB’s worst bat…and they’d still need an upgrade in ’26 – like they would if Kim opts out — so it’d be the same situation minus 2M they’re paying for a headstart on courting him.
What’s the big deal?
@RunDMC The fact that they claimed him at all says that him declining the player option in favor of free agency isn’t unrealistic at all, regardless of any stats you throw out about his time with the Padres and Rays. And his performance since coming over to ATL makes it more likely, rather than less.
Getting a “head start of giving him a taste of what it is like playing for the team” has no value at all.
If they don’t claim Kim and have Nick Allen play out the string at SS in 2025 they miss the playoffs. So same outcome as in our timeline. And then they can either sign Kim as a FA if he opts out or get the Rays to eat $2-3m or attach a prospect in exchange for them taking him if he doesn’t opt out.
I’ll say it again. Whatever you (yes YOU specifically) want Kim to do with the player option is the opposite of what he will actually do.
No value at all…? LOL. If there was a team that was going to plop down nine figures, then sure, you’re right — ATL’s cup of coffee don’t matter. But, do you really think that’s happening? If he gets a sizable offer from NYY that wants to move on from Volpe, but doesn’t want Bichette – sure, that could be an option.
I (me, specifically) don’t care what he does. They’re in a better place than if they sat on their hands and we haven’t had to watch Nick Allen continue being a Grand Canyon in the 8-9 spot for Snit to plug in every night. If this is a bridge to Boras, then I’m fine with the 2M of not my money they spent, even if it’s for a month-long tenure. I haven’t put in my Kim Braves jersey order just yet.
Nick Allen is a urinal cake replacement.
@Smacky Well there’s a good chance he’s the Braves’ shortstop next year.
@RuDMC It’s not going to be the difference between him signing with the Braves and signing with someone else, all other things equal.
@Duran — Big what IF — they included a premium Edible Arrangement for both Ha-seong AND Boras?? None of that honeydew stuff either. Throw in an extra cream cheese dipper. Good has done.
Coupon code: BIGDIPPER for 5% savings through 9/21 on purchases of $30 or more 🍈
Yeah, the Kim pick-up was solid. Bad take.
How so? He has an opt-out at the end of the season, the Braves aren’t in the race and they are not allowed to QO him.
@Jarren: you said that, twice.
@bhambrave Because it was relevant, twice.
No, it was wrong twice. He doesn’t have an opt out. He has a player option. There’s a decent chance he exercises it. If he doesn’t, the Braves haven’t lost anything. They are back where they started.
@bhambrave Same thing
The good old “Asian player? He sucks!” sentiment on MLBTR comment sections… What is it with people like you?
yeah the worst is that othtani guy, totally overrated
Steinbrenner – Stop with the racial crap.
Yeah, that’s totally the problem here lmfao.
Contributes nothing to the conversation & encourages those who are cultist raciest maggots to jump in.
@Steinbrenner: Do you always like your own posts?
They have chosen…Wisely
Grasshopper approves.
Braves Wisely Claim Brett. There, I fixed it.
A bargain a day keeps last place away.
AA setting up for next season while most MLB GM’s are busy planning their post season island getaways.
Best GM in the game.
I think all GM’s should claim players wisely.
So this is now the first cost of prematurely elevating Eldridge to the 40.
What has he delivered so far? NOTHING !!
Additional cost will come either in terms of another organizational player that will have to be let go after the World Series or after the end of Spring Training 2026 or a free agent player who cannot be signed in the off season due to a lack of 40 man roster space. Foolish Roster Management..
Eldridge is getting valuable time in the majors at the very low cost of a great guy (Wisely) that is a AAAA player who was taking up a 40man spot on the Giants. This call-up does not effect Eldridge’s eligibility and is a great move even if he does produce much. You’re upset about losing a guy that in 3 yrs w/ the Giants (420 AB) is batting 217 with 7 bombs. and is behind Schmidt & Koss in INF and 6th OF behind Gilbert & McCray.. Additional costs should be Meckler.
I concur with the “Foolish Roster Management” assessment on Smith.
I interpret the move as a white flag on the season & shortsighted $$$
Wisely is a baseball brat who anyone would want to root for. He had his moments with Sf and I wish him well wherever he lands.
A FAR BETTER ALTERNATIVE TO CLAIMING BRETT FOOLISHLY
Never heard of Wisely but he is already an improvement over no hitting Luke Williams.
Loading ...
Wisely is a nice utility player who should do well in Atlanta.
Giants should’ve put Dom Smith on the 60 day IL instead of DFA Wisely.
I think the 60-day DL was full with three others
Incorrect sir
mlb.com/glossary/injuries/60-day-injured-list
This isn’t a fantasy league
Long as they don’t claim him stupidly like they did with Ha-Seong Kim.
Kim is batting .327 for them currently, and he is an established major leaguer. You don’t have a clue
Except you’re forgetting the part where he has an opt-out at the end of the season, the Braves aren’t in the race and they are not allowed to QO him.
@Duran – You keep bringing up that point, but he’s barely played this year (will have played in ~50 games/season with possibly ~0.6 bWAR, if he continues at a similar rate) and they have a head start (better than anyone in free agency) to give him a taste of what it’d be like playing for the team, and he’s been a hit in the clubhouse with friend (and former SD teammate) Profar, something that he said he didn’t have in TB. ATL could make a good, short-term high-AAV offer that would guarantee him a starting SS spot on a competitive team for more guaranteed dollars than the 16M he’s due in 2026 (if he opts-in). No one is giving him 70M+ guaranteed or more.
Had they not picked him up on waivers they would have saved the 2M he was due in ’25…and would have Nick Allen trotting out there (possibly winning GG with Winn out…) with MLB’s worst bat…and they’d still need an upgrade in ’26 – like they would if Kim opts out — so it’d be the same situation minus 2M they’re paying for a headstart on courting him.
What’s the big deal?
@RunDMC The fact that they claimed him at all says that him declining the player option in favor of free agency isn’t unrealistic at all, regardless of any stats you throw out about his time with the Padres and Rays. And his performance since coming over to ATL makes it more likely, rather than less.
Getting a “head start of giving him a taste of what it is like playing for the team” has no value at all.
If they don’t claim Kim and have Nick Allen play out the string at SS in 2025 they miss the playoffs. So same outcome as in our timeline. And then they can either sign Kim as a FA if he opts out or get the Rays to eat $2-3m or attach a prospect in exchange for them taking him if he doesn’t opt out.
I’ll say it again. Whatever you (yes YOU specifically) want Kim to do with the player option is the opposite of what he will actually do.
No value at all…? LOL. If there was a team that was going to plop down nine figures, then sure, you’re right — ATL’s cup of coffee don’t matter. But, do you really think that’s happening? If he gets a sizable offer from NYY that wants to move on from Volpe, but doesn’t want Bichette – sure, that could be an option.
I (me, specifically) don’t care what he does. They’re in a better place than if they sat on their hands and we haven’t had to watch Nick Allen continue being a Grand Canyon in the 8-9 spot for Snit to plug in every night. If this is a bridge to Boras, then I’m fine with the 2M of not my money they spent, even if it’s for a month-long tenure. I haven’t put in my Kim Braves jersey order just yet.
Nick Allen is a urinal cake replacement.
@Smacky Well there’s a good chance he’s the Braves’ shortstop next year.
@RuDMC It’s not going to be the difference between him signing with the Braves and signing with someone else, all other things equal.
@Duran — Big what IF — they included a premium Edible Arrangement for both Ha-seong AND Boras?? None of that honeydew stuff either. Throw in an extra cream cheese dipper. Good has done.
Coupon code: BIGDIPPER for 5% savings through 9/21 on purchases of $30 or more 🍈
Yeah, the Kim pick-up was solid. Bad take.
How so? He has an opt-out at the end of the season, the Braves aren’t in the race and they are not allowed to QO him.
@Jarren: you said that, twice.
@bhambrave Because it was relevant, twice.
No, it was wrong twice. He doesn’t have an opt out. He has a player option. There’s a decent chance he exercises it. If he doesn’t, the Braves haven’t lost anything. They are back where they started.
@bhambrave Same thing
The good old “Asian player? He sucks!” sentiment on MLBTR comment sections… What is it with people like you?
yeah the worst is that othtani guy, totally overrated
Steinbrenner – Stop with the racial crap.
Yeah, that’s totally the problem here lmfao.
Contributes nothing to the conversation & encourages those who are cultist raciest maggots to jump in.
@Steinbrenner: Do you always like your own posts?
They have chosen…Wisely
Grasshopper approves.
Braves Wisely Claim Brett. There, I fixed it.
A bargain a day keeps last place away.
AA setting up for next season while most MLB GM’s are busy planning their post season island getaways.
Best GM in the game.
I think all GM’s should claim players wisely.
So this is now the first cost of prematurely elevating Eldridge to the 40.
What has he delivered so far? NOTHING !!
Additional cost will come either in terms of another organizational player that will have to be let go after the World Series or after the end of Spring Training 2026 or a free agent player who cannot be signed in the off season due to a lack of 40 man roster space. Foolish Roster Management..
Eldridge is getting valuable time in the majors at the very low cost of a great guy (Wisely) that is a AAAA player who was taking up a 40man spot on the Giants. This call-up does not effect Eldridge’s eligibility and is a great move even if he does produce much. You’re upset about losing a guy that in 3 yrs w/ the Giants (420 AB) is batting 217 with 7 bombs. and is behind Schmidt & Koss in INF and 6th OF behind Gilbert & McCray.. Additional costs should be Meckler.
I concur with the “Foolish Roster Management” assessment on Smith.
I interpret the move as a white flag on the season & shortsighted $$$
Wisely is a baseball brat who anyone would want to root for. He had his moments with Sf and I wish him well wherever he lands.
A FAR BETTER ALTERNATIVE TO CLAIMING BRETT FOOLISHLY
Never heard of Wisely but he is already an improvement over no hitting Luke Williams.
They’ve chosen Wisely