Jack Grealish transfer damages Premier League integrity and nobody seems to care
Jack Grealish is loving his loan time with Everton but Manchester City's £100m man will not be able to play at the Etihad on Saturday because of Premier League rules
Crystal Palace’s smooth start to the season hit its first serious bump in the road when Oliver Glasner’s side were beaten by Everton in the most recent round of Premier League fixtures. The defeat meant Palace were overtaken by Manchester City in the table, Pep Guardiola’s side now a point and a place ahead in fifth position.
On the resumption of the club programme, City themselves face an Everton team whose mild rejuvenation at a new stadium can only have been enhanced by that late winner in the 2-1 victory over Palace. David Moyes’ men should be buoyant going to the Etihad - well, as buoyant as any team that has not won at a particular venue in fifteen years can be.
As buoyant as any team managed by a coach who has been beaten thirteen times by Guardiola, drawing on three occasions and winning only once can be. It is a tall order for Everton but in the context of their decent opening to the season, it is even taller....because Moyes is forbidden from fielding his best team at the Etihad next Saturday.
Moyes is forbidden from fielding the team that snatched a great victory over Palace. Moyes is forbidden from fielding the player who scored the late winner in the game, the player who has been, arguably, the club’s outstanding performer this season.
READ MORE: Erling Haaland receives verdict after Man City ace sent home from Norway dutyREAD MORE: Jack Grealish has already given Man Utd green light for huge transferHow can that be right? Crystal Palace, now a point behind Guardiola’s team, had to face an Everton side that is, in effect, ordered by the Premier League to be WEAKER against Manchester City. They facilitate the agreement that says an on-loan player cannot play against his employer.
How can that be fair? But that is just one aspect of a Premier League loan system that fundamentally undermines the integrity of the competition.
And no-one seems to care about it. No-one at all. The rules are the same for everyone etc, etc. True, but not everyone can borrow Jack Grealish, the £100million man.
If he is not running the show against your side or scoring added-time winners against your side, there cannot be many fans up and down the country who are not pleased to see Grealish playing well and enjoying his football. More than a lot of those fans, I most certainly am.
But Grealish’s fine form for Everton and his enforced exclusion from their next match is a reminder of the Premier League loan system’s fundamental flaws. Premier League clubs earn enough money to actually buy their own players, not ask for favours.
With typical enthusiasm, Grealish has bought into all things Everton but he remains a Manchester City employee. There is a lot of talk about how it would be great if Grealish makes Hill Dickinson Stadium his permanent home. And it sure would.
But the chances of that are slim. If Grealish has a great season and a European powerhouse comes in for him, would he stay at Everton (assuming they are not in the Champions League)? Almost certainly not.
Aston Villa is a big club but Marcus Rashford always had his sights set on something bigger during his loan spell under Unai Emery. Loan moves are - and always have been - moves of convenience. Grealish certainly needed game-time in a season that precedes a World Cup and Everton needed a box-office talent to light up a flash new home on the banks of the Mersey.
As for Manchester City, even a fraction of Grealish’s salary off the wage bill for 12 months is useful. Happy days for everyone…except for the integrity of the Premier League.
Join our new WhatsApp community and receive your daily dose of Mirror Football content. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
Sky has slashed the price of its Essential TV and Sky Sports bundle ahead of the 2025/26 season, saving members £336 and offering more than 1,400 live matches across the Premier League, EFL and more.
Sky will show at least 215 live Premier League games next season, an increase of up to 100 more.
