Skip to main content
Robert Sietsema

Robert Sietsema

Critic

Robert Sietsema is the former Eater NY senior critic, with more 35 years of experience as a restaurant critic in New York City. Previously, he has written for the Village Voice, Lucky Peach, Gourmet, and dozens of other publications. He specializes in food that’s fun to eat and not expensive, covering the five boroughs, New Jersey, and beyond.

Latest articles by Robert Sietsema

MapEater NY
The Best Pizzerias of New York CityThe Best Pizzerias of New York City
MapEater NY

The city’s wide-ranging pizza landscape includes coal-fired, Neapolitan, Sicilian, and New York-style slices

By Melissa McCart, Robert Sietsema and 1 more
MapEater NY
The Best Indian Restaurants in NYCThe Best Indian Restaurants in NYC
MapEater NY

A selection of outstanding spots serving the subcontinent’s diverse cuisine throughout New York City

By Nadia Chaudhury and Robert Sietsema
MapEater NY
The Best Places to Eat in ChinatownThe Best Places to Eat in Chinatown
MapEater NY

From fresh rice noodle rolls to dumplings, a dining guide to New York’s oldest and most famous Chinatown in Manhattan

By Eater Staff and Robert Sietsema
MapEater NY
The Best West Village Restaurants in NYCThe Best West Village Restaurants in NYC
MapEater NY

Where to find great dining in the landmarked Manhattan neighborhood

By Robert Sietsema, Emma Orlow and 1 more
MapEater NY
The Best Bagels in New York CityThe Best Bagels in New York City
MapEater NY

The city’s top bagel spots keep evolving

By Robert Sietsema and Nadia Chaudhury
MapEater NY
The Best Fried Chicken in NYCThe Best Fried Chicken in NYC
MapEater NY

Where to find fried chicken as a starter, in sandwiches, as a main event with sides, or atop waffles at restaurants across the city

By Robert Sietsema and Melissa McCart
MapEater NY
The Best Affordable Restaurants in NYCThe Best Affordable Restaurants in NYC
MapEater NY

Where to eat inexpensive delicious meals for $25 and under across the city

By Nadia Chaudhury and Robert Sietsema
MapEater NY
The Best Diners in NYCThe Best Diners in NYC
MapEater NY

Vintage and aspirational old-time restaurants from every borough

By Melissa McCart and Robert Sietsema
MapEater NY
NYC’s Essential Barbecue RestaurantsNYC’s Essential Barbecue Restaurants
MapEater NY

Where to find the city’s best brisket, sausages, burnt ends, and smoked bologna

By Robert Sietsema
MapEater NY
The Best Restaurants in TribecaThe Best Restaurants in Tribeca
MapEater NY

The Manhattan neighborhood offers surprising options among several Michelin-starred spots, family-friendly picks, and more

By Robert Sietsema and Melissa McCart