WEBVTT

00:00:19.119 --> 00:00:21.121
GOOD MORNING. I'D LIKE TO CALL

00:00:21.187 --> 00:00:22.989
TO ORDER THIS MEETING OF THE

00:00:23.056 --> 00:00:23.990
SENATE STANDING COMMITTEE ON

00:00:24.057 --> 00:00:25.759
HOUSING. WE DO NOT YET HAVE A

00:00:25.825 --> 00:00:27.026
QUORUM, SO THE COMMITTEE WILL

00:00:27.093 --> 00:00:28.294
OPERATE AS A SUBCOMMITTEE TO

00:00:28.361 --> 00:00:30.397
HEAR BILL PRESENTATIONS, AND

00:00:30.463 --> 00:00:31.965
WE'LL BEGIN FIRST WITH FILE

00:00:32.031 --> 00:00:34.768
ITEM TWO, SB 457 BY SENATOR

00:00:34.834 --> 00:00:36.002
BOOKER AND SENATOR, WHENEVER

00:00:36.069 --> 00:00:38.304
YOU'RE READY, YOU MAY PRESENT.

00:00:38.371 --> 00:00:46.212
ALSO VERY NICE TIE. C  GIANTS.

00:00:46.279 --> 00:00:48.848
THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. BEFORE WE

00:00:48.915 --> 00:00:50.450
GET STARTED, I WANT TO THANK

00:00:50.517 --> 00:00:51.551
THE COMMITTEE STAFF HAS BEEN

00:00:51.618 --> 00:00:52.719
INCREDIBLY CONSTRUCTIVE

00:00:52.786 --> 00:00:54.554
THROUGHOUT THE WHOLE PROCESS.

00:00:54.621 --> 00:00:55.855
COMING OFF THE SENATE FLOOR

00:00:55.922 --> 00:00:57.390
EARLIER THIS YEAR, THE BILL

00:00:57.457 --> 00:00:59.225
CLARIFIED WHAT CONSTITUTED A

00:00:59.292 --> 00:01:00.994
VALID IN-KIND SERVICES A CITY

00:01:01.060 --> 00:01:02.796
CAN OFFER FOR THE PURPOSES OF

00:01:02.862 --> 00:01:04.597
RECEIVING CREDIT FOR PRESERVING

00:01:04.664 --> 00:01:05.698
NATURALLY OCCURRING AFFORDABLE

00:01:05.765 --> 00:01:07.200
HOUSING. WORKING WITH SPUR,

00:01:07.267 --> 00:01:08.968
WE'VE AMENDED THE BILL TO

00:01:09.035 --> 00:01:10.737
ADDITIONALLY DIRECT HCD TO

00:01:10.804 --> 00:01:12.539
DEVELOP AND PUBLISH ECONOMIC

00:01:12.605 --> 00:01:13.573
MODELS THAT WOULD ALLOW

00:01:13.640 --> 00:01:15.041
JURISDICTIONS TO QUICKLY AND

00:01:15.108 --> 00:01:16.142
ACCURATELY ESTIMATE THE

00:01:16.209 --> 00:01:17.944
REALISTIC DEVELOPMENT CAPACITY

00:01:18.011 --> 00:01:19.746
OF ANY GIVEN SITE GROUNDED IN

00:01:19.813 --> 00:01:22.215
REAL DATA FOR SITE INVENTORY

00:01:22.282 --> 00:01:24.017
ANALYSIS. HISTORICALLY, THE

00:01:24.083 --> 00:01:25.118
LACK OF STANDARDIZATION IN THIS

00:01:25.185 --> 00:01:26.719
ANALYSIS HAS MEANT EVERY CITY

00:01:26.786 --> 00:01:27.854
HAS USED A DIFFERENT METHOD,

00:01:27.921 --> 00:01:30.890
EVEN DIFFERING BETWEEN PARCELS.

00:01:30.957 --> 00:01:32.692
WHAT'S GREAT ABOUT THIS BILL?

00:01:32.759 --> 00:01:34.794
IT'S A REFORM BILL THAT EVEN

00:01:34.861 --> 00:01:36.296
HOUSING ADVOCATES CAN LOVE.

00:01:36.362 --> 00:01:37.730
HOUSING ADVOCATES, LOCAL

00:01:37.797 --> 00:01:38.531
GOVERNMENTS, DEVELOPERS ALL

00:01:38.598 --> 00:01:39.666
AGREE THAT OUR CURRENT APPROACH

00:01:39.732 --> 00:01:42.101
NEEDS TO CHANGE. IT'S TOO TIME

00:01:42.168 --> 00:01:43.770
CONSUMING. THE BANG FOR THE

00:01:43.837 --> 00:01:46.139
BUCK JUST REALLY ISN'T THERE.

00:01:46.206 --> 00:01:50.310
THIS WILL JUST MAKE IT A MUCH.

00:01:50.376 --> 00:01:51.978
MUCH FASTER AND MORE ECONOMICAL

00:01:52.045 --> 00:01:54.481
TO DEVELOP HOUSING ELEMENTS.

00:01:54.547 --> 00:01:55.682
THE BILL IS A MEANINGFUL STEP

00:01:55.748 --> 00:01:56.783
FORWARD TOWARDS A MORE DATA

00:01:56.850 --> 00:01:58.284
DRIVEN HOUSING ELEMENT PROCESS

00:01:58.351 --> 00:02:00.086
THAT WILL REDUCE AMBIGUITY.

00:02:00.153 --> 00:02:01.554
THAT HAS CAUSED MANY CITIES,

00:02:01.621 --> 00:02:02.689
BOTH TIME AND MONEY, AT THE

00:02:02.755 --> 00:02:03.923
EXPENSE OF DEVELOPMENT REQUESTS,

00:02:03.990 --> 00:02:05.758
AND I VOTE. THANK YOU. DO YOU

00:02:05.825 --> 00:02:07.594
HAVE ANY WITNESSES IN SUPPORT?

00:02:07.660 --> 00:02:10.163
WE HAVE. YEAH. MICHAEL. MICHAEL.

00:02:10.230 --> 00:02:12.265
SPUR. MAYBE. CERTAINLY FOR

00:02:12.332 --> 00:02:13.800
TECHNICAL. OKAY. THANK YOU VERY

00:02:13.867 --> 00:02:15.168
MUCH. WE'LL INVITE ANYONE ELSE

00:02:15.235 --> 00:02:16.302
WHO'D LIKE TO EXPRESS SUPPORT

00:02:16.369 --> 00:02:18.338
FOR SB 457. PLEASE COME FORWARD

00:02:18.404 --> 00:02:19.339
AND STATE YOUR NAME,

00:02:19.405 --> 00:02:20.340
ORGANIZATION AND POSITION ON

00:02:20.406 --> 00:02:23.042
THE BILL. SEEING NO ONE COME

00:02:23.109 --> 00:02:24.043
FORWARD, ARE THERE ANY

00:02:24.110 --> 00:02:27.814
OPPOSITION WITNESSES? SEEING NO

00:02:27.881 --> 00:02:29.015
OPPOSITION WITNESSES? WE DON'T

00:02:29.082 --> 00:02:30.283
HAVE A QUORUM YET. I'LL BRING

00:02:30.350 --> 00:02:32.151
IT BACK TO THE DAIS FOR ANY

00:02:32.218 --> 00:02:33.152
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. VICE

00:02:33.219 --> 00:02:36.389
CHAIR. THANK YOU. SO I LIKE THE

00:02:36.456 --> 00:02:38.958
INTENT OF THIS BILL BECAUSE

00:02:39.025 --> 00:02:42.829
CITIES HAVE HAD VERY, VERY

00:02:42.896 --> 00:02:44.697
DIFFICULT TIME TRYING TO GET

00:02:44.764 --> 00:02:48.334
THROUGH THEIR HOUSING ELEMENTS

00:02:48.401 --> 00:02:50.470
AND THE BACK AND FORTH THAT HAS

00:02:50.537 --> 00:02:53.339
HAPPENED BETWEEN THEM. HCD NOT

00:02:53.406 --> 00:02:54.440
HAVING CLEAR DIRECTION ON WHAT

00:02:54.507 --> 00:02:57.243
IT IS THAT THEY NEED TO HAVE

00:02:57.310 --> 00:03:00.680
BETTER AND AND THEN ALSO, YOU

00:03:00.747 --> 00:03:02.282
KNOW, LACKING SOME OF THE

00:03:02.348 --> 00:03:03.783
EXPERTISE BECAUSE, YOU KNOW,

00:03:03.850 --> 00:03:06.286
THEY FRANKLY HAVE A SHORTAGE OF

00:03:06.352 --> 00:03:09.589
COMMUNITY PLANNERS OUT THERE.

00:03:09.656 --> 00:03:12.058
SO THAT PART OF IT I, I'M GOOD

00:03:12.125 --> 00:03:13.493
WITH, I'M A LITTLE NERVOUS

00:03:13.560 --> 00:03:15.361
ABOUT THE PART WHERE WE'RE KIND

00:03:15.428 --> 00:03:21.401
OF GIVING HCD. KIND OF A LOT OF

00:03:21.467 --> 00:03:24.070
LEGAL DEFERENCE BEFORE WE HEAR

00:03:24.137 --> 00:03:26.105
WHAT THEIR METHODOLOGY IS.

00:03:26.172 --> 00:03:28.274
BECAUSE IF THEIR METHODOLOGY TO

00:03:28.341 --> 00:03:30.076
DEAL WITH SOME OF THIS IS WORSE

00:03:30.143 --> 00:03:32.211
THAN WHAT WE STARTED WITH,

00:03:32.278 --> 00:03:33.446
THAT'S A CONCERN. I'D RATHER

00:03:33.513 --> 00:03:36.115
HEAR THEIR METHODOLOGY FIRST.

00:03:36.182 --> 00:03:39.752
YOU KNOW, FRANKLY, FROM MY

00:03:39.819 --> 00:03:42.255
PERSPECTIVE, MY SEVERAL CITIES

00:03:42.322 --> 00:03:45.491
PERSPECTIVE, HCD IS REALLY

00:03:45.558 --> 00:03:47.327
HOUSING. AND THE COMMUNITY

00:03:47.393 --> 00:03:48.795
DEVELOPMENT PART DOESN'T

00:03:48.861 --> 00:03:51.664
PERTAIN. AND WE SHOULD JUST

00:03:51.731 --> 00:03:56.803
RENAME IT HOUSING. AND, AND SO

00:03:56.869 --> 00:03:58.605
THAT THAT'S THE PART OF THIS

00:03:58.671 --> 00:04:01.741
THAT MAKES ME A LITTLE BIT

00:04:01.808 --> 00:04:04.243
LEERY OF, OF, YOU KNOW, BEING

00:04:04.310 --> 00:04:06.846
ON BOARD WITH THIS. SO I'D HAVE

00:04:06.913 --> 00:04:08.581
TO SEE THEIR METHODOLOGY BEFORE

00:04:08.648 --> 00:04:11.818
I CAN SUPPORT THE BILL. THANKS.

00:04:11.884 --> 00:04:13.252
THANK YOU. THANK YOU SO MUCH,

00:04:13.319 --> 00:04:14.921
SENATOR, FOR THIS BILL. IT'S A

00:04:14.988 --> 00:04:16.055
IT'S A REALLY EXCELLENT BILL. I

00:04:16.122 --> 00:04:17.924
THINK, SHOWING HOW INNOVATION

00:04:17.991 --> 00:04:20.159
CAN REALLY HELP IMPROVE OUR

00:04:20.226 --> 00:04:21.928
HOUSING ELEMENT PROCESS.

00:04:21.995 --> 00:04:26.899
SENATOR BALTIMORE AND SB 457.

00:04:26.966 --> 00:04:29.802
YOU KNOW, ONCE AGAIN, LOCAL

00:04:29.869 --> 00:04:30.870
AGENCIES ARE NOT REQUIRED TO

00:04:30.937 --> 00:04:34.474
USE THE TOOL. BUT FOR THOSE

00:04:34.540 --> 00:04:35.642
JURISDICTIONS THAT DON'T HAVE,

00:04:35.708 --> 00:04:39.078
YOU KNOW, YOU KNOW, A HUGE

00:04:39.145 --> 00:04:40.980
PLANNING DEPARTMENT, YOU KNOW,

00:04:41.047 --> 00:04:42.415
THIS TOOL COULD REALLY HELP

00:04:42.482 --> 00:04:44.917
WITH THE SITE TO SITE CAPACITY

00:04:44.984 --> 00:04:47.086
ANALYSIS. YOU KNOW, I KNOW

00:04:47.153 --> 00:04:48.221
HAVING CHAIRED THE COG IN THE

00:04:48.287 --> 00:04:49.989
BAY AREA ASSOCIATION OF

00:04:50.056 --> 00:04:51.457
GOVERNMENTS THAT A LOT OF LOCAL

00:04:51.524 --> 00:04:52.091
JURISDICTIONS, INCLUDING

00:04:52.158 --> 00:04:53.559
SMALLER CITIES, ARE REALLY

00:04:53.626 --> 00:04:55.795
RESOURCE CONSTRAINED AND THE

00:04:55.862 --> 00:04:57.530
STATE IS REQUIRING THAT LOCAL

00:04:57.597 --> 00:04:58.965
AGENCIES HAVE TO DO A LOT IN

00:04:59.032 --> 00:04:59.766
DEVELOPING THESE HOUSING

00:04:59.832 --> 00:05:01.534
ELEMENTS. SO THIS IS A REALLY

00:05:01.601 --> 00:05:02.935
GREAT IDEA TO PROVIDE

00:05:03.002 --> 00:05:04.003
ADDITIONAL TOOL TO MAKE IT

00:05:04.070 --> 00:05:05.672
EASIER AND TO MAKE SURE CITIES

00:05:05.738 --> 00:05:06.973
COMPLY, BECAUSE THAT'S THE GOAL,

00:05:07.040 --> 00:05:08.641
IS TO ACHIEVE COMPLIANCE. SO I

00:05:08.708 --> 00:05:09.842
WANT TO THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

00:05:09.909 --> 00:05:10.877
AND SENATOR CABALDON, ANY

00:05:10.943 --> 00:05:13.012
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS ON SB 457?

00:05:13.079 --> 00:05:14.681
NOW, I'LL TURN IT BACK TO YOU

00:05:14.747 --> 00:05:15.882
TO MAKE A CLOSING STATEMENT.

00:05:15.948 --> 00:05:16.883
YEAH. THANK YOU. YEAH. ALL I

00:05:16.949 --> 00:05:18.685
REPRESENT ARE SMALL AND MEDIUM

00:05:18.751 --> 00:05:19.686
SIZED CITIES. SO WE'RE

00:05:19.752 --> 00:05:20.853
OPTIMISTIC THIS WILL BE HELPFUL.

00:05:20.920 --> 00:05:21.921
I APPRECIATE THE THE COMMENTS

00:05:21.988 --> 00:05:23.089
OF SENATOR SATO. HOPEFULLY

00:05:23.156 --> 00:05:26.325
WE'LL WE'LL FIND THAT THAT THAT

00:05:26.392 --> 00:05:28.094
YOU WILL BE HAPPY WITH THE

00:05:28.161 --> 00:05:28.895
METHODOLOGY. WE'LL SEE HOW IT

00:05:28.961 --> 00:05:31.531
ALL GOES. BUT CERTAINLY FEEL

00:05:31.597 --> 00:05:33.399
THIS IS A BIG STEP FORWARD. I

00:05:33.466 --> 00:05:34.500
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE

00:05:34.567 --> 00:05:35.635
VOTE. THANK YOU. SENATOR, WE

00:05:35.702 --> 00:05:37.437
DON'T HAVE A QUORUM, BUT WHEN

00:05:37.503 --> 00:05:38.604
WE DO, WE WILL ENTERTAIN A

00:05:38.671 --> 00:05:40.406
MOTION AT THAT TIME. THANK YOU.

00:05:40.473 --> 00:05:41.474
AND, SERGEANT, IF YOU CAN

00:05:41.541 --> 00:05:44.711
CONTACT CENTER DROSSOS OFFICE,

00:05:44.777 --> 00:05:45.912
JUST LET HER KNOW THAT WE'RE

00:05:45.978 --> 00:05:47.714
READY TO HAVE HER PRESENT. I

00:05:47.780 --> 00:05:49.015
KNOW THAT SHE'S IN THE HEALTH

00:05:49.082 --> 00:05:51.484
COMMITTEE. YEAH. AND SO

00:05:51.551 --> 00:05:52.719
COMMITTEE WILL RECESS FOR FIVE

00:05:52.785 --> 00:05:53.853
MINUTES WHILE WE WAIT FOR THE

00:05:53.920 --> 00:06:00.893
NEXT AUTHOR TO PRESENT.

00:06:10.636 --> 00:06:11.003
ALL

00:06:11.070 --> 00:06:13.473
OVER TO THE VICE CHAIR AS I

00:06:13.539 --> 00:06:16.509
PRESENT THE NEXT BILL ON BEHALF

00:06:16.576 --> 00:06:22.215
OF THE AUTHOR. ALL RIGHT. THE

00:06:22.281 --> 00:06:24.684
NEXT BILL WE WILL BE HEARING IS

00:06:24.751 --> 00:06:28.654
SB 1388 BY THE AUTHOR IS

00:06:28.721 --> 00:06:30.990
SENATOR DURAZZO, AND IT'S GOING

00:06:31.057 --> 00:06:34.761
TO BE PRESENTED BY THE CHAIR

00:06:34.827 --> 00:06:37.997
THANK YOU. THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR.

00:06:38.064 --> 00:06:40.333
MEMBERS. SB 1388 ESTABLISHES

00:06:40.399 --> 00:06:41.934
THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING RISK

00:06:42.001 --> 00:06:43.736
REDUCTION PROGRAM TO HELP

00:06:43.803 --> 00:06:44.837
AFFORDABLE HOUSING PROVIDERS

00:06:44.904 --> 00:06:47.006
REDUCE INSURANCE COSTS BY

00:06:47.073 --> 00:06:49.842
PROVIDING TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE.

00:06:49.909 --> 00:06:52.044
THIS WILL SUPPORT PROVIDERS IN

00:06:52.111 --> 00:06:53.846
PURSUING ALTERNATIVE INSURANCE

00:06:53.913 --> 00:06:54.914
MODELS AND SECURING MORE

00:06:54.981 --> 00:06:57.083
AFFORDABLE HOUSING OPTIONS THAN

00:06:57.150 --> 00:06:58.417
AVAILABLE IN THE CURRENT MARKET.

00:06:58.484 --> 00:07:02.121
WANT TO CLARIFY THAT THIS IS

00:07:02.188 --> 00:07:04.423
NOT PROVIDING SPECIFIC LOANS?

00:07:04.490 --> 00:07:05.358
THIS IS ABOUT PROVIDING

00:07:05.424 --> 00:07:07.160
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE.

00:07:07.226 --> 00:07:08.594
CALIFORNIA IS FACING A DUAL

00:07:08.661 --> 00:07:09.896
CRISIS AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING

00:07:09.962 --> 00:07:11.831
AND INSURANCE CRISIS, AND WHILE

00:07:11.898 --> 00:07:13.199
CALIFORNIA IS EXPERIENCING AN

00:07:13.266 --> 00:07:14.700
ONGOING SUPPLY SHORTAGE OF

00:07:14.767 --> 00:07:16.536
AFFORDABLE HOUSING, AFFORDABLE

00:07:16.602 --> 00:07:17.937
HOUSING PROVIDERS ACROSS

00:07:18.004 --> 00:07:20.106
CALIFORNIA ARE FACING LIMITED

00:07:20.173 --> 00:07:21.574
AVAILABILITY OF INSURANCE

00:07:21.641 --> 00:07:23.376
COVERAGE, INCLUDING SIGNIFICANT

00:07:23.442 --> 00:07:25.144
PREMIUM AND DEDUCTIBLE COST

00:07:25.211 --> 00:07:26.279
INCREASES, REDUCTIONS IN THE

00:07:26.345 --> 00:07:28.047
SCOPE AND QUALITY OF COVERAGE.

00:07:28.114 --> 00:07:29.348
AND CALIFORNIA HAS EXPERIENCED

00:07:29.415 --> 00:07:30.449
SOME OF THE HIGHEST INSURANCE

00:07:30.516 --> 00:07:31.784
PREMIUM HIKES IN THE UNITED

00:07:31.851 --> 00:07:34.086
STATES, WITH INCREASES AS HIGH

00:07:34.153 --> 00:07:36.956
AS 500%. THE SENATOR WANTED TO

00:07:37.023 --> 00:07:38.090
NOTE. IN HER DISTRICT, THE

00:07:38.157 --> 00:07:40.293
LITTLE TOKYO SERVICE CENTER, A

00:07:40.359 --> 00:07:41.694
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT NONPROFIT,

00:07:41.761 --> 00:07:43.229
HAD INSURANCE PREMIUMS RISE BY

00:07:43.296 --> 00:07:46.399
OVER 300%. THE SEVERE INSURANCE

00:07:46.465 --> 00:07:47.867
CRISIS IS SIGNIFICANTLY

00:07:47.934 --> 00:07:49.168
INCREASING COSTS FOR AFFORDABLE

00:07:49.235 --> 00:07:51.103
HOUSING DEVELOPERS BY LIMITING

00:07:51.170 --> 00:07:52.205
THEIR ABILITY TO BUILD NEW,

00:07:52.271 --> 00:07:53.940
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND PRESERVE

00:07:54.006 --> 00:07:55.775
EXISTING UNITS. GIVEN THESE

00:07:55.842 --> 00:07:56.809
INSURANCE CHALLENGES, MANY

00:07:56.876 --> 00:07:57.877
PROVIDERS HAVE EXPRESSED

00:07:57.944 --> 00:08:00.079
INTEREST IN ALTERNATIVE RISK

00:08:00.146 --> 00:08:01.314
FINANCING OPTIONS TO INCREASE

00:08:01.380 --> 00:08:02.582
THE AVAILABILITY AND

00:08:02.648 --> 00:08:04.083
AFFORDABILITY OF INSURANCE

00:08:04.150 --> 00:08:05.451
COVERAGE. HOWEVER, SEVERAL

00:08:05.518 --> 00:08:06.519
AFFORDABLE HOUSING NON-PROFITS

00:08:06.586 --> 00:08:08.354
LACK THE TECHNICAL EXPERTISE

00:08:08.421 --> 00:08:10.189
NECESSARY TO EVALUATE,

00:08:10.256 --> 00:08:10.957
ESTABLISH OR PARTICIPATE IN

00:08:11.023 --> 00:08:13.392
THESE MODELS. THE BILL WILL

00:08:13.459 --> 00:08:14.160
ADDRESS THESE CHALLENGES BY

00:08:14.227 --> 00:08:15.595
HAVING THE STATE PROVIDE

00:08:15.661 --> 00:08:16.629
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE TO

00:08:16.696 --> 00:08:18.064
AFFORDABLE HOUSING DEVELOPERS

00:08:18.130 --> 00:08:19.498
SO THEY CAN PURSUE RISK

00:08:19.565 --> 00:08:20.933
MITIGATION STRATEGIES AND

00:08:21.000 --> 00:08:22.768
ALTERNATIVE RISK FINANCING

00:08:22.835 --> 00:08:23.836
OPTIONS. HOUSING PROVIDERS NEED

00:08:23.903 --> 00:08:25.671
AFFORDABLE INSURANCE OPTIONS,

00:08:25.738 --> 00:08:27.106
SO CALIFORNIA CAN CONTINUE TO

00:08:27.173 --> 00:08:28.374
WORK TOWARDS OUR HOUSING GOALS

00:08:28.441 --> 00:08:30.710
OF CREATING AFFORDABLE HOUSING,

00:08:30.776 --> 00:08:31.777
AFFORDABLE INSURANCE TO CREATE

00:08:31.844 --> 00:08:33.746
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. SB 1388

00:08:33.813 --> 00:08:35.348
WILL REDUCE THE BEARS FRUIT

00:08:35.414 --> 00:08:36.816
PRODUCTION AND PRESERVATION OF

00:08:36.883 --> 00:08:38.251
ESSENTIAL AFFORDABLE HOUSING

00:08:38.317 --> 00:08:39.785
AND HELP US REACH OUR GOALS AND

00:08:39.852 --> 00:08:41.254
AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME, I

00:08:41.320 --> 00:08:42.555
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR VÀ. THANK

00:08:42.622 --> 00:08:43.623
YOU. AND WE HAVE A WITNESS

00:08:43.689 --> 00:08:48.661
TODAY. THE WITNESS IN SUPPORT.

00:08:48.728 --> 00:08:51.264
ARE YOU A JUST A QUICK SUPPORT

00:08:51.330 --> 00:08:52.632
HERE ON BEHALF OF ENTERPRISE

00:08:52.698 --> 00:08:53.699
COMMUNITY, GRACIELA CASTILLO

00:08:53.766 --> 00:08:55.167
HERE ON BEHALF OF ENTERPRISE

00:08:55.234 --> 00:08:57.003
COMMUNITY PARTNERS AND HOUSING

00:08:57.069 --> 00:08:58.237
CALIFORNIA, STRONG SUPPORTERS

00:08:58.304 --> 00:08:59.538
AND CO-SPONSORS OF THE BILL.

00:08:59.605 --> 00:09:03.109
ALL RIGHT. OTHER SUPPORT.

00:09:03.175 --> 00:09:04.477
CLIFTON WILSON ON BEHALF OF THE

00:09:04.543 --> 00:09:05.978
BURBANK HOUSING DEVELOPMENT

00:09:06.045 --> 00:09:07.013
CORPORATION ALSO IN SUPPORT.

00:09:07.079 --> 00:09:08.347
THANK YOU, THANK YOU. DO WE

00:09:08.414 --> 00:09:09.515
HAVE ANY OPPOSITION OUT IN THE

00:09:09.582 --> 00:09:11.350
ROOM? IF NOT, I'LL BRING IT

00:09:11.417 --> 00:09:13.286
BACK TO THE DAIS. I DON'T HAVE

00:09:13.352 --> 00:09:14.387
ANY QUESTIONS. YOU MAY CLOSE

00:09:14.453 --> 00:09:15.454
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE

00:09:15.521 --> 00:09:16.756
AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME.

00:09:16.822 --> 00:09:18.557
ABSOLUTELY. SO WE ARE WAITING

00:09:18.624 --> 00:09:20.359
FOR A QUORUM TO BE ESTABLISHED

00:09:20.426 --> 00:09:22.161
AND WHICH WE WILL ONCE IT'S

00:09:22.228 --> 00:09:23.296
ESTABLISHED, WE WILL BE VOTING

00:09:23.362 --> 00:09:25.164
ON THE TWO BILLS THAT WE HAVE

00:09:25.231 --> 00:09:28.301
ALREADY HEARD. AND SO AT THIS

00:09:28.367 --> 00:09:30.136
TIME, WE'RE GOING TO BE GOING

00:09:30.202 --> 00:09:40.479
INTO RECESS. ALL RIGHT.

00:09:42.048 --> 00:09:42.515
AND WE

00:09:42.581 --> 00:09:44.116
HAVE ESTABLISHED A QUORUM. SO

00:09:44.183 --> 00:09:45.351
I'D LIKE TO ASK THE COMMITTEE

00:09:45.418 --> 00:09:48.154
ASSISTANT, PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.

00:09:48.220 --> 00:09:49.255
SENATORS ARE AGAIN HERE AGAIN

00:09:49.322 --> 00:09:51.424
HERE CIERTO CIERTO HERE.

00:09:51.490 --> 00:09:53.225
CABALDON CABALDON HERE.

00:09:53.292 --> 00:09:55.328
CABALLERO. CORTEZ. HERE. CORTEZ

00:09:55.394 --> 00:09:57.530
HERE. GERARDO. GONZALEZ.

00:09:57.596 --> 00:10:00.533
GONZALEZ HERE. GRAYSON. OKUBO

00:10:00.599 --> 00:10:02.902
HERE. PADILLA. OKAY. THANK YOU.

00:10:02.969 --> 00:10:05.771
COLLEAGUES. WE DID HEAR THE TWO

00:10:05.838 --> 00:10:07.940
BILLS. SO I WILL ENTERTAIN A

00:10:08.007 --> 00:10:10.476
MOTION FIRST ON SB 1388 TO RAZO.

00:10:10.543 --> 00:10:12.712
IS THERE A MOTION MOVED BY

00:10:12.778 --> 00:10:14.313
SENATOR GONZALEZ? THANK YOU. IF

00:10:14.380 --> 00:10:15.881
WE CAN PLEASE CALL. THE MOTION

00:10:15.948 --> 00:10:17.683
IS THAT THE ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS

00:10:17.750 --> 00:10:20.252
BE CONCURRED IN SENATORS ER I

00:10:20.319 --> 00:10:23.122
ER I COR TO COR TO NØ. C .

00:10:23.189 --> 00:10:24.523
BALDWIN. BALDWIN. AYE.

00:10:24.590 --> 00:10:27.393
CABALLERO. CORTEZ. CORTEZ. I

00:10:27.460 --> 00:10:29.729
GIRALDO. GONZALEZ. GONZALEZ.

00:10:29.795 --> 00:10:32.098
AYE. GRAYSON. OKOBOJI. OKOBOJI.

00:10:32.164 --> 00:10:33.899
NO. PADILLA. WE'LL KEEP THAT

00:10:33.966 --> 00:10:36.202
BILL ON CALL. AND LASTLY, ITEM

00:10:36.268 --> 00:10:38.938
TWO, SB 457. BECKER I'LL

00:10:39.005 --> 00:10:40.740
ENTERTAIN A MOTION ON THAT BILL.

00:10:40.806 --> 00:10:42.074
MOVE BY SENATOR BALDWIN. THANK

00:10:42.141 --> 00:10:43.876
YOU. IF YOU CAN PLEASE CALL THE

00:10:43.943 --> 00:10:45.444
ROLL MOTION THAT THE ASSEMBLY

00:10:45.511 --> 00:10:46.445
AMENDMENTS BE CONCURRED IN

00:10:46.512 --> 00:10:50.082
SENATORS ER I. ER AYE CIERTO

00:10:50.149 --> 00:10:52.251
CIERTO NØ. BALDWIN. BALDWIN.

00:10:52.318 --> 00:10:55.221
AYE. CABALLERO. CORTEZ. CORTEZ.

00:10:55.287 --> 00:10:58.724
AYE. GONZALEZ. GONZALEZ. AYE.

00:10:58.791 --> 00:11:02.028
GRAYSON. OKOBOJI. OTTOBONO. BY

00:11:02.094 --> 00:11:03.763
THE. OKAY. WE'LL KEEP THAT

00:11:03.829 --> 00:11:04.930
PHONE CALL AS WELL. AND THANK

00:11:04.997 --> 00:11:06.966
YOU TO MY COLLEAGUES. WE'LL

00:11:07.033 --> 00:11:09.101
WAIT. WE'LL RECESS COMMITTEE

00:11:09.168 --> 00:11:10.503
AND WAIT FOR OTHER MEMBERS TO

00:11:10.569 --> 00:11:20.746
JOIN TO ADD ON. THANK YOU.

00:11:25.217 --> 00:11:26.018
WE

00:11:26.085 --> 00:11:27.820
WILL GO THROUGH THE ROLL FOR

00:11:27.887 --> 00:11:29.221
SENATOR CABALLERO, STARTING

00:11:29.288 --> 00:11:33.859
WITH ONE SB 1388 DURAZZO

00:11:33.926 --> 00:11:36.062
SENATORS. CABALLERO, CABALLERO.

00:11:36.128 --> 00:11:37.530
AYE. WE'LL KEEP THAT PHONE CALL.

00:11:37.596 --> 00:11:40.800
THANK YOU. AND LASTLY TO SB 457

00:11:40.866 --> 00:11:42.902
BECKER. SENATORS. CABALLERO,

00:11:42.968 --> 00:11:44.003
CABALLERO. AYE WE'LL KEEP THAT

00:11:44.070 --> 00:11:45.204
PHONE CALL AS WELL. THANK YOU,

00:11:45.271 --> 00:11:47.139
THANK YOU. I'M ASSUMING THEY

00:11:47.206 --> 00:11:51.944
WERE ALL. AYE BILLS AND I CHAIR

00:11:52.011 --> 00:11:55.214
I YEAH I KNEW THAT THERE WAS

00:11:55.281 --> 00:11:56.749
ONE. THAT'S NOT ON OUR AGENDA

00:11:56.816 --> 00:12:00.586
AS WE DISCUSSED YESTERDAY. YEAH.

00:12:00.653 --> 00:12:16.936
WE'LL SEE IF THEY.

00:12:53.405 --> 00:12:53.839
WILL OPEN

00:12:53.906 --> 00:12:55.374
THE ROLL FOR SENATE. PADILLA IF

00:12:55.441 --> 00:12:56.675
WE COULD START FIRST WITH FILE

00:12:56.742 --> 00:13:00.713
ONE SB 1388 BY SENATOR BARRASSO,

00:13:00.779 --> 00:13:02.581
SENATORS PADILLA BY THE CALL.

00:13:02.648 --> 00:13:03.949
THANK YOU. AND FOLLOWED HIM TO

00:13:04.016 --> 00:13:07.219
SB 457 BY BECKER, SENATORS

00:13:07.286 --> 00:13:08.754
PADILLA BY THE EYE. AND WE'LL

00:13:08.821 --> 00:13:10.656
KEEP THAT BILL ON CALL AS WELL.

00:13:10.723 --> 00:13:11.757
AND WE'LL WAIT FOR OTHER

00:13:11.824 --> 00:13:12.892
MEMBERS TO ADD ON. THANK YOU

00:13:12.958 --> 00:13:14.593
FOR YOUR PATIENCE, MR. CHAIRMAN.

00:13:14.660 --> 00:13:30.876
THANK YOU.

00:13:35.381 --> 00:13:36.448
AND SO WE WILL OPEN

00:13:36.515 --> 00:13:38.184
THE ROLL NOW FOR SENATOR RAZO,

00:13:38.250 --> 00:13:39.585
STARTING FIRST WITH HER BILL,

00:13:39.652 --> 00:13:43.923
SB 1388, SENATORS. DURAZZO.

00:13:43.989 --> 00:13:46.091
DURAZZO. AYE. OKAY. WE'LL KEEP

00:13:46.158 --> 00:13:47.893
THAT BILL ON CALL. AND LASTLY,

00:13:47.960 --> 00:13:50.095
FILE ITEM TWO, SB 457 BY

00:13:50.162 --> 00:13:52.264
SENATOR BECKER, SENATORS

00:13:52.331 --> 00:13:56.535
DURAZZO AYE. DURAZZO. AYE. OKAY.

00:13:56.602 --> 00:13:58.003
THE MOTION WAS ASSEMBLY

00:13:58.070 --> 00:14:00.105
AMENDMENTS BE CONCURRED IN. AND

00:14:00.172 --> 00:14:01.907
SO THANK YOU, SENATOR RUSSELL.

00:14:01.974 --> 00:14:04.510
WE ARE DONE. AND WE WILL RECESS

00:14:04.577 --> 00:14:05.578
THE COMMITTEE AND WAIT FOR

00:14:05.644 --> 00:14:07.313
SENATOR GRAYSON. THANK YOU.

00:14:07.379 --> 00:14:25.097
THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. THANK YOU.

00:14:27.766 --> 00:14:28.701
WE'RE GOING TO RECONVENE THE

00:14:28.767 --> 00:14:29.868
SENATE HOUSING COMMITTEE

00:14:29.935 --> 00:14:43.315
HEARING. ALL GOOD. OKAY. WE'RE

00:14:43.382 --> 00:14:44.917
GOING TO OPEN THE ROLL FOR

00:14:44.984 --> 00:14:45.918
SENATOR GRAYSON, AND WE'LL

00:14:45.985 --> 00:14:47.319
START FIRST ON FILE ITEM ONE,

00:14:47.386 --> 00:14:50.055
SB 1388 BY SENATOR DURAZZO.

00:14:50.122 --> 00:14:51.123
MOTION. MOTION IS THAT THE

00:14:51.190 --> 00:14:52.224
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS BE

00:14:52.291 --> 00:14:54.727
CONCURRED IN. SENATOR GRAYSON.

00:14:54.793 --> 00:14:56.161
GRAYSON. AYE. OKAY. THAT THAT

00:14:56.228 --> 00:14:58.130
MOTION PASSES ON A VOTE OF 8 TO

00:14:58.197 --> 00:15:00.899
2. AND NOW FILE ITEM TWO, SB

00:15:00.966 --> 00:15:02.101
457. BECKER. THE MOTION IS THAT

00:15:02.167 --> 00:15:03.168
THE ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS BE

00:15:03.235 --> 00:15:05.170
CONCURRED IN SENATOR GRAYSON.

00:15:05.237 --> 00:15:06.672
GRAYSON. AYE. AND THAT MOTION

00:15:06.739 --> 00:15:08.707
PASSES ON A VOTE OF 8 TO 2 AS

00:15:08.774 --> 00:15:10.242
WELL. THANK YOU, SENATOR. WITH

00:15:10.309 --> 00:15:12.711
THAT, THE SENATE COMMITTEE ON

00:15:12.778 --> 00:15:14.647
HOUSING IS NOW ADJOURNED. THANK

00:15:14.713 --> 00:15:30.829
YOU. MR.