Collage of a reel of film, two Black American actors in a vintage movie, and a box of popcorn with movie tickets in it

Race Films and Malt Shop Milestones

Illustration of a movie clapperboard and a reel of film above images of three teenage girls of color with vintage hairstyles

The heroines of Malt Shop Milestones: Vicky, Berta, and Ari

In Book Three of my postwar historical fiction series,
Malt Shop Milestones,
the heroine goes out on separate occasions to see two movies:
Junction 88 (1948)
and
Killer Diller (1948).

Reel News, Reel Features

Before most American households had televisions, taking a trip to the movie theater often meant spending a whole afternoon or evening there. With one ticket, you’d get to see not one movie but a bundle of them: one or two feature films along with a few short films, usually including a newsreel.

A lot of people were familiar with newsreels from, say, Fox Movietone News and Paramount News. But in the 1940s and ’50s, there was a film production company that focused on bringing news pertaining to Black Americans: All-American News, which made newsreels specifically for showing in Black American theaters.

Here’s a reel of All-American News from 1945.

So, you can imagine more newsreels that would come before feature films like Junction 88 and Killer Diller.

Junction 88 is a small-town tale about a songwriter’s romantic dreams and the beginnings of his career. Killer Diller (also produced by the All-American film company) is a musical comedy packed with an array of performing artists.

These movies are two of about five hundred “race films” in America’s history.

Singers Wyatt Clark, Marie Cooke, and Bob Howard star in Junction 88.

Singer and pianist Nat “King” Cole, comedian Jackie “Moms” Mabley, bandleader Andy Kirk, and more performers take to the stage in Killer Diller.

Race, Music, and Miracles

Race films featured Black American casts and were produced for Black audiences from around the time of the First World War until the early 1950s or so.

In Junction 88, Cooke and Clark play sweethearts, Lolly and Buster.

Musical numbers were common in race films, and the genre had some different levels of story content. For instance, in a movie that doesn’t appear in Malt Shop Milestones, Miracle in Harlem (1948), there’s a little collection of musical performances woven through a central story: a dramatic murder mystery seasoned with themes of romance and family.

Miracle in Harlem is considered to be one of the best race films, and it’s among those that I’ve watched myself. Aside from its comedy moments I didn’t care for, I as a lover of vintage cinema can say I dig Miracle. (And if you’ve checked out the soundtrack of Malt Shop Milestones Book Two, where Savannah Churchill sings “I Want to Be Loved,” you’ll recognize her delivering that romantic ballad in this movie!)

A couple of seconds are cut off of the beginning and end of this Miracle in Harlem trailer. But you get the idea of it!

In contrast, when it comes to pictures like Junction 88 and Killer Diller, their light stories are pretty much or completely like secondary aspects of the pictures. It’s rather clear that for movies of their variety, the key purpose is to showcase Black American talent like singing and dancing, whether through several short scenes or through long central acts.

For instance, Junction 88 isn’t even 50 minutes long. But its share of music could satisfy a musical twice its length: seven original songs, one with a romantic reprise, and a dance number at a concert.

On a Junction 88 stroll, Howard (as himself) sings “Walking with Caroline.”

The musical emphasis in race films makes sense to me, given that the musical film genre was quite the sensation in those days. I also find it interesting that during a period when unjust civil codes and social inequities imposed limits on opportunities for Black American singers and dancers, there came the genre of race films, often serving as a musical stage.

How Sweet the Soundie

Now, there was a time when Americans could watch musical performances on Panorams: coin-operated movie jukeboxes located in public places like restaurants, hotel lobbies, and department stores. Those jukebox movies were called Soundies, and they featured all genres of music, from classical to country-western to jazz and more. And yes indeed, there were Soundies that featured Black American artists—but unlike musical feature films, Soundies were each only about three minutes long.

Here’s a 1945 Soundie, “Five Salted Peanuts,” performed by the jazz trio The Counts and the Countess.

In addition to their short length, Soundies were only around for a fairly short time: for about six years during the 1940s. (By the start of my Malt Shop Milestones series, Soundies were already becoming a thing of the past.) And, of course, people back then couldn’t pull out smartphones to watch music and dance videos whenever they liked. Moreover, while the popularity of televisions did grow after the Second World War, again, they hadn’t become nearly as common in households as they are now.

So, for much of the time before most Americans had televisions, having the chance to see onscreen musical performances meant going out to watch movies in theaters.

Front. Center. Seen.

Although watching movies was as much a part of Black culture as it was for other Americans, the mainstream movie industry in America usually wouldn’t cast Black actors in integral roles, particularly beyond the racially stereotypical. (Stereotypical servant roles, for example.)

There were some cases when Black Americans would appear in short, entertaining sideshows in mainstream movies that weren’t about them. This included movies where the segments with Black actors would be cut out of the versions shown in various theaters in the American Deep South, where overt racism was heavy. And in plenty of cases, mainstream movie casts excluded Black people altogether.

So, although race films were mostly low-budget productions, they were popular among their segregated target audience.

While I quite enjoy listening to the record of Savannah Churchill singing “I Want to Be Loved,” it’s something else to not only hear her but to see her perform in Miracle in Harlem.

Race films were shown in designated Black theaters, in theaters in Black neighborhoods, and in certain other theaters that only allowed Black moviegoers to attend at assigned, separate hours for matinée or midnight movie showings. “Midnight rambles,” those late-night showings were called.

In whichever situation where Black Americans would watch race films, it was a big deal for them to see themselves onscreen, front and center. To see themselves in more than just supporting or minor roles. As more than just stereotyped characters.

Go to the video clip of "Somewhere Happy with You"

(This looped Junction 88 clip of Buster and Lolly is playful and precious, as he sings “Somewhere Happy with You.”)

Hollywood, Harlem, and Hopping

The large majority of race films were made outside of Hollywood, and fewer than one hundred of them remain today. Still, some actors and artists in race films also had recognition in the wider entertainment industry.

Here’s a clip from a featurette about Butterfly McQueen, who plays a secretary in the comedy story portions of Killer Diller. The actress is most known for her Hollywood role as Prissy in 1939’s Gone with the Wind.

Nat “King” Cole, who performs jazz in Killer Diller’s variety show with the King Cole Trio, would soon gain wide recognition as a solo artist in mainstream pop music with the hit ballad “Nature Boy.”

During Killer Diller’s central act—a variety show jumping with jazz, dancing, and stand-up comedy—the Four Congaroos dance group performs the Lindy Hop: the original swing dance, born in Harlem.

In that performance, I recognized some of the choreography I’d seen from the Harlem Congaroos, a subgroup of Whitey’s Lindy Hoppers, in a clip from a 1941 musical comedy, Hellzapoppin’. (I know, that’s quite a title—and no, that isn’t a race film. 😀 ) The dance similarities are no wonder, as choreographer Frankie Manning dances in both films.

The autobiography Frankie Manning: Ambassador of Lindy Hop by Frankie Manning and Cynthia R. Millman

Whitey’s Lindy Hoppers, a group formed by Herbert “Whitey” White, disbanded when many of the group’s male dancers, including Manning, went to serve in the military during the Second World War. After his service in the U.S. Army, Manning formed the Four Congaroos group in 1947.

The Four Congaroos’ performance in Killer Diller may be my favorite part of the movie.

A black and white strip of film that says "The End"

Again, Junction 88 and Killer Diller tie in to Book Three in the
Malt Shop Milestones series,
but you’ll want to read all the books!

Go to the Malt Shop Milestones series page

Meet Nadine C. Keels, author and blogger of hope and inspiration

The Story Lady (1991)


3 and a Half Stars

The Story Lady (1991)
Also called The Christmas Story Lady
Rated TV-G

| Description

• Family Drama

Grace McQueen (Jessica Tandy) is a retired widow who isn’t content to just settle back. She discovers the world of public access television and puts on her own children’s story hour—drawing the attention of a large company looking for its next moneymaker in children’s programming.

| My Thoughts

My goodness. I remember seeing the TV promos back when this movie was first set to air. Not sure how much I appreciated it then, but I’ve enjoyed watching the movie again and again in more recent years.

Warmth, Hope, and Inspiration

Not only does this hit my nostalgic spot in all of its “made-for-TV in the ’90s” glory, but there’s plenty of warmth and hope here in terms of friendship and family.

Plus, I love Grace’s sense of purpose: her desire to make a difference in others’ lives and her determination to make it happen even after having multiple doors closed in front of her. This is definitely inspiring comfort-watching for me, especially during the holidays.


Go to Nadine's Holiday Books

Victoria in Dover (1954)


3 Stars

Victoria in Dover (1954)
Not Rated

| Description

• Vintage Period Drama

Crowned the Queen of England at a young age, Victoria has much to learn—and the obligation to choose a husband.

| My Thoughts

What I really liked? Victoria the television series (2016-2019), particularly the first two seasons. Including the Season Two Christmas special!

And what I absolutely love watching again and again? The Young Victoria (2009), one of my all-time favorite movies.

Figuring ahead of time that these two modern productions showcasing Queen Victoria’s younger years must be superior to the vintage Austrian production I was about to watch, I approached Victoria in Dover imagining that it would be quaint and hoping it would be entertaining.

Well.

Much Ado about Dover?

The title and descriptions I’d seen gave me the impression that Victoria’s romance (stemming from her trip to Dover) is the point of the film. Strangely enough, the first, romance-less hour or so wasn’t that entertaining for me.

I reckon it would have been better to go in knowing that Victoria doesn’t meet Prince Albert until more than halfway through the film. And I think one of the film’s alternate titles, The Story of Vickie, is more fitting, as this is a general story about young Victoria becoming queen. Not mainly about her Dover adventure.

Too Little Ado about the Age Gap?

Speaking of Dover and, hence, Albert, I wouldn’t call the actors a great casting match. The real Victoria and Albert were only a few months apart in age. The actress playing teenage Victoria in this film was sixteen at the time—and she looked it. The actor playing Albert was in his thirties—and he looked it.

Together onscreen, the two of them look obviously mismatched.

A Box of Light

Compared to the sets in the modern productions I mentioned above, a lot of the scenes in this older picture look and sound somewhat like they’ve been filmed in a box, with painted backgrounds for outdoor scenery through the palace windows and whatnot. There isn’t too much along the lines of epic atmosphere in this one.

Even so, overall, this film is light, bright, earnest here, comedic there. And I could ignore the inaccurate age difference just enough to mildly enjoy the eventual, sprightly, old-fashioned screen romance for what it is.

Not sorry for the chance to see this picture at least once.

Go to Nadine's Books of Hope and Inspiration

The Citadel (1983)


3 and a Half Stars

The Citadel (1983)
Not Rated
(but I’d say it’s PG)

| Description

• Vintage Period Drama Series

In the 1920s, a young, idealistic doctor, Andrew Manson, takes up his first post in a mining community. But he soon finds himself at odds with the dysfunctional medical system. And in time, Andrew risks losing his idealism to the lure of the fashionable, greedy world of London medicine.

| My Thoughts

I found out about this British drama miniseries when I came across the 1937 novel it’s based on. I think it’s likely I wouldn’t have followed all of the events onscreen quite as well if I hadn’t read the novel first, but either way, I’m glad I did both.

In a Box of Browns?

Like certain other vintage British films I’ve watched, this drama from the early ’80s doesn’t meet my aesthetic preferences. The overall look is muddy on the eyes with drab browns and dull greens, and the series feels and sounds like much of it was filmed in a box.

But I wanted to watch this not for the aesthetics but for Andrew’s story. Overall, it’s a compelling one.

Jerky and Wifely Issues

Now, phase when Andrew gradually becomes a jerk was about as aggravating for me to watch as it was to read. And a significant aspect of his downward spiral in this television version, with extra little helpings of fairly desperate “drama” added in, lessened my respect for him in his husband role even more than when I read the book’s version of the situation.

On that note, certain matters in the novel that I found disappointing in regard to Andrew’s wife Christine didn’t improve for me here. Yes, her character is handled a little differently in a few ways in this adaptation, but I’m still not a fan of how some critical issues play out in her marriage and how the story ultimately handles her.

Institutions and Human Lives

The broader message from Andrew’s journey resonates—particularly in regard to the folly of valuing, defending, and upholding institutions for their own sake while lacking or losing what should be the institutions’ real concerns: human lives and wellbeing.

And on the level of the individual, it’s still something to see what results when Andrew—as a person, as a doctor, and as a man of compassion and conviction—comes back to his senses.


Here’s my review of The Citadel, the novel.

Go to Nadine's Books of Hope and Inspiration