
I received complimentary copies of some of these books for honest reviews of their content, which is separate from my personal assessment of their covers here.
I’m not strictly a “judge a book by its cover” kind of reader. Still, I have an appreciation for cover art as a part of the overall reading experience. Here are covers that particularly stood out to me from books I read this calendar year. The books are listed in the order I read them.
![]()
Readers:
Don’t miss the additional books to pick up at the end of the list, along with the bottom link to more Book Awards posts.
Authors and Cover Designers:
If you’d like a medal for making this list, head toward the bottom of this post.

Before the Ever After
Jacqueline Woodson
•
Middle Grade Fiction
The young son of a pro football star, and the effects of his dad’s head injuries.
There’s such genius in the illustration of falling autumn leaves, here. The way they’re slipping right through the fabric of the boy’s hoodie. The way the man’s frame, strong in its outline, is made up completely of those fragile, colorful leaves. Poignant imagery reflecting this story of father-son love.

The Healing Summer
Heather B. Moore
•
Women’s Fiction
(Gentle Read)
Two women head to San Francisco to find a hero from over 70 years ago.
Such a calming painting of a seaside sunrise with minimal colors. Distant birds hovering above as the sailboats with translucent sails grace the surface of a reflective body of water. Soothing signs of a healing summer indeed.

Miramar Bay
Davis Bunn
•
Contemporary Fiction
(Gentle Read)
Putting his acting career on hold, he escapes to a seaside town to soul search.
More of the seaside, but now at sunset—amber in its glow as the light glints off that golden key on a shore graced with shells. This isn’t the latest cover of this novel, but it’s still my favorite.

Earth’s the Right Place for Love
Elizabeth Berg
•
Historical Love Story
(some violence; brief language)
He’s in love with the most desirable girl in his high school class. But she has a crush on his older brother.
I love the way the larger-than-life flower petals and leaves partially frame an experience…as a guy and girl of simple, vintage style sit together in just the right place, under the bluish light of a faraway moon.

Embers in the London Sky
Sarah Sundin
•
Christian Historical Romance
(war violence; theme of domestic abuse)
World War II. A BBC correspondent in a burning capital city. And a widow desperate to find her three-year-old son.
No, the London sky—so often painted with heathery clouds ready to rain—isn’t supposed to be glowing deep red with the remnants of fire. But, there it is. Glowing over the dust and rubble created by war, while a mother in danger conveys love to her little boy. Such storytelling in an image.

The Blossom and the Firefly
Sherri L. Smith
•
Young Adult Historical Love Story
(war violence)
He’s ready to die for his country. She feels like she’s died already. And then the two of them meet each other.
That thoughtful look on the face of a young woman in a light, dusty sepia behind a pastel blossom near her ear, above a Japanese warplane diving straight downward: quite the blend of imminent danger, understated emotion, and quiet beauty on this cover.

Whispers in the Valley
Lance Wubbels
•
Christian Historical Fiction
(some war violence)
Her husband is home on leave from the war, but something more must be done to keep their farm going.
I miss the days when Dan Thornberg (yes, I’ve known his name since the ’90s) was the staff artist at Bethany House Publishers, adding wonderful visuals to historical fiction. This illustration of a wife in thought and her husband in observation as they stand amid the gentle hills and their farmland under puffy, white clouds in a blue sky—oh, my. Bring on the nostalgia.

The Lady with the Dark Hair
Erin Bartels
•
Christian Split-Timeline Fiction
(some war violence)
Her family history is on shaky ground as questions arise about her ancestor’s greatest painting.
With only about half of this dark-haired lady’s face visible before those multicolored smatterings of oil paint, this cover art strikes a perfect tone of gorgeous mystery.

Everlasting
Amanda MacLean
•
Christian Historical Romance
(some violence)
A missing gold miner. His twin sister, determined to find him. And a reporter posing as a detective.
Do you know what’s most significant to me about this collage of scenes featuring a romantic couple in vintage style? After discovering this novel back in the ’90s, I couldn’t remember the title, the author name, or the publisher. But the memory of this lovely illustrated cover art, especially the heroine pictured in the center, stuck with me for decades until I found the book again—identifying it by its artwork. Book cover designs indeed matter!

Jeeves and the King of Clubs
Ben Schott
•
Historical Fiction | Humor
(Gentle Read)
To fight treason, the British government needs the help of an inimitable valet’s hapless gentleman employer! Apparently.
Oh, what a cover of vintage high class: the dutiful valet, standing erect at service, as a shadow stretches from him in the silhouette of a wealthy man at stylish leisure. What a snazzy contrast!

Code Name Butterfly
Embassie Susberry
•
Historical Fiction
(war violence)
1941 Paris. A Black American journalist mistaken for Josephine Baker. And a spy network to resist Nazi occupation.
Below, a woman somewhat in shadow, appearing ready for travel as she faces warplanes flying over the Eiffel Tower. Above, the partial headshot of a serious, even shrewd woman in sophisticated vintage dress, with a telling butterfly brooch pinned near her shoulder. A beautiful cover that speaks perfectly of World War II intrigue.

A Brilliant Night of Stars and Ice
Rebecca Connolly
•
Christian Historical Fiction
(brief mild language; brief violence)
The captain of the Carpathia wakes to a distress signal from a ship on its maiden voyage: the Titanic.
It is indeed a brilliant night depicted here, out on the ocean. The sparkling beauty is clear—and what gets me most is the image of the iceberg. Its imposing tip visible over the water’s surface, while the greater mass of it is visible in the darkening depths beneath. The overall imagery brings the brilliance and beauty together with an icy, oceanic omen.

Peace on Earth
Maia Ross
•
Cozy Mystery
(some mild language; brief violence)
This holiday season, a young friend asks the formidable Irma for help with figuring out a financial snafu.
I make it no secret that I absolutely love Christmastime, and I accordingly love the fitting holiday look of this cover. The string of multicolored lights against the blue background, the multicolored dots of light in the word “Earth,” the hint of bokeh lights above it all, the glassiness and snowiness of the snow globe—oh, wait. That beautiful globe is broken on one side. A sign that Irma does indeed need to save Christmas!

*Throwback*
from Favorite Covers 2019
Unscripted
Davis Bunn
•
Contemporary Fiction
An unlikely film project could help a ruined line producer redeem his career.
This cover strikes the right serious tone in clear but unassuming, deftly blended green and gold, with a contemplative hero looking out over Hollywood from “behind Hollywood,” where the lights make a statement without a bright and glamorous feel. Excellent imagery!


Entries for 2024’s Favorite Covers giveaway are now closed, but comments on the post are remaining open.

Giveaway is open to U.S. residents and mailing addresses only in the contiguous U.S., Alaska, and Hawaii. Entrants must be 18 years of age or older. One randomly determined winner will be notified by email on Monday, December 2, 2024. If the winner does not respond by Wednesday, December 4, 2024, a different entrant will be selected. Add p[dot]prospects[at]live[dot]com to your address book to ensure that a giveaway notification isn’t sent to your junk mail/spam box. For additional giveaway terms, see the Blog Giveaways and Giveaway Privacy information on my Policies page. Entering the giveaway indicates your agreement to the terms.


Before I read the homage to P.G. Wodehouse up there, Jeeves and the King of Clubs, I read some of the work of Wodehouse himself. I made a few fan art book covers too. 😀
You may enjoy reading Wodehouse’s classic British humor as much as I have so far. Feel free to click my fan art cover below to grab a free Kindle copy of Book One in the Jeeves and Wooster series,
My Man Jeeves.

“Our heartstrings are waiting for music we’ve yet to play…”
•
Last year, one of my books got a cover makeover to match the love and music theme reflected through the name of the series: Heartstrings. Take a look at this sweet contemporary love story,
We Were Real.


Congratulations, authors, and thank you for writing your books! If yours has one of my favorite covers this year, you’re welcome to a complimentary medal to display on your website, blog, social media—wherever you wish. If you know the artist who designed your cover, feel free to pass on the word about the award. The artists are welcome to display the medal as well. Click the image below and contact me to receive a full size PNG medal. Thanks again!
![]()
Coming Up:
Favorite Reads 2024
Friday, November 15th
•
Noteworthy Reads 2024
Monday, November 18th
•
Favorite Book Titles 2024
Friday, November 22nd












































































