Page MenuHomePhabricator

Identify participating wikis for Paste Check A/B experiment
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

This task involves the work of identifying the Wikipedias that will participate in the A/B experiment of Paste Check.

There are two parts to this task:

  1. Identifying the wikis we will approach about participating in the controlled experiment of Paste Check
  2. Finalizing the set of wikis that consent to participate in the experiment

Selection requirements

  • Wikis that receive a sizable inflow of newcomers and population of Junior Contributors (≀100 cumulative edits)
    • We're specifically seeking wikis to be present in the test that see newcomers editing from within Sub-Saharan Africa
  • Wikis whose linguistic and technical configurations represent the complexity we can expect in the Movement. This way, we can ensure Paste Check is "robust" enough to work well for all Wikipedias.
    • Language orientations:
      • RTL
      • LTR
    • Scripts/Alphabets
      • Arabic
      • Kanji
      • Latin
  • Wikis from whom volunteer(s) have expressed a specific interest in Paste Check being made available
  • NOT actively participating in another Edit Check-related experiment (e.g. T400101, T387918)
  • Enough qualifying edit sessions for test to reach statistical significance within 6 weeks. See: T403861.

Candidate wikis

WARNING: this list is actively being edited and not final.
IDWikiContact (if any)Language orientationScript/AlphabetMonthly active newcomers (≀100 cumulative edits)Link to on-wiki discussion(s)Status (e.g. support, no objections, objections)
1.de.wiki@Johannnes89LTRLatin4,516πŸ’¬No reaction
2.pl.wikisuggested by @Natalia_Szafran-KozakowskaLTRLatin1,154πŸ’¬β”one question about detection
3.id.wikisuggested by @BAPerdana-WMF and @IKristiani-WMFLTRLatin990πŸ’¬no reaction
4.vi.wikisuggested by @PPhamLTRLatin514πŸ’¬no reaction
5.tw.wikisuggested by @STei-WMFLTRLatinπŸ’¬no reaction
6.simple.wikisuggested by @RAdimer-WMFLTRLatin422πŸ’¬No reaction, archived
7.it.wikiLTRLatin2,062πŸ’¬πŸ’š 3 reactions in favor
8.nl.wikiLTRLatin1,004πŸ’¬No reaction, archived
9.cs.wikicontact: JBeranek-WMFLTRLatin621πŸ’¬No reaction
10.uk.wikiLTRCyrillic1,024πŸ’¬no reaction
11.ru.wikiLTRCyrillic2,743πŸ’¬no reaction, but noticed
12.bn.wikiLTRBengali321πŸ’¬no reaction
13.hi.wikiLTRDevanagari196πŸ’¬no reaction
14.zh.wikisuggested by @VenusluiLTRKanji1,098πŸ’¬β” questions about the start date and the configuration of the link in the paste check card
15.ar.wikiRTLArabic1,388πŸ’¬no reaction, but translation done
16.fa.wikiRTLArabic1,852πŸ’¬no reaction
17.sw.wikisuggested by @Geugeor-WMFLTRLatinπŸ’¬no reaction
18.dag.wikisuggested by @Geugeor-WMFLTRLatinπŸ’¬no reaction
19.gpe.wikisuggested by @Geugeor-WMFLTRLatinpending
20.fte.wikisuggested by @Geugeor-WMFLTRLatinpending
21.wlx.wikisuggested by @Geugeor-WMFLTRLatinpending
22.fon.wikisuggested by @Geugeor-WMFLTRLatinπŸ’¬no reaction
23.ca.wikisuggested by @IZapico-WMFLTRLatinπŸ’¬no reaction, but moved to a better place
24.eu.wikisuggested by @IZapico-WMFLTRLatinπŸ’¬no reaction, but moved to a better place
25.gl.wikisuggested by @IZapico-WMFLTRLatinπŸ’¬no reaction

Event Timeline

Restricted Application added a subscriber: alaa. Β· View Herald TranscriptSep 3 2025, 11:01 PM
Aklapper renamed this task from Identify participating wikis for Pastae Check A/B experiment to Identify participating wikis for Paste Check A/B experiment .Sep 4 2025, 8:24 AM
Restricted Application added a subscriber: Stang. Β· View Herald TranscriptSep 4 2025, 3:30 PM

Per what @MNeisler and I discussed offline on Wednesday, in order to draw conclusions isolated to Paste Check it's necessary that the controlled experiment me scoped to wikis where no other Edit Check-related experiments are live.

The announcement is ready to be posted. I'm collecting translations now; the goal is to post before the end of this week.

@Geugeor, which of the wikis you listed are okay if I send them a message in French?

For French, there is only: fon.wiki

I posted the message.

Not posted yet at:

Done at:

  • it.wikipedia.org
  • fon.Wikipedia.org

All wikis (minus three), from T403637, have been informed of the upcoming project.

So far, no direct reactions, except Italian Wikipedia, where they look forward to testing it.

@Trizek-WMF: might you be able to update the table in the task description to reflect where announcements have and have not yet been published?

Trizek-WMF renamed this task from Identify participating wikis for Paste Check A/B experiment to Identify participating wikis for Paste Check A/B experiment.Oct 1 2025, 1:22 PM
Trizek-WMF updated the task description. (Show Details)

Per offline discussion, the Paste Check experiment will launch on all wikis listed in the task description EXCEPT gpe.wiki, fte.wiki, and wlx.wiki.

Wikis have been identified, so the task is now completed.