Page MenuHomePhabricator

Display an entry for page in watchlist when page protection expired; Display an entry in user page when user blocking expired
Open, LowPublic

Description

Hello. When some page is protected, the user that watches it can see the logger entry in the watchlist. But when the protection expired, there is no message, because it is done automatically. Think about this example: autopatrolled level page gets sysop protection for a year. After that it changes to nothing. And nobody knows it should be protected as autopatrolled again. Could you please create a dummy user that will "remove" the protection when it expires? So there will be new entry in watchlist: "loggerboy changed page protection from sysop to nothing at date", and it will appear in watchlist? And the same for user blocking expiration in user page. Less important, but a notification for the sysop that made protection or blocking in the first place can improve the previous part, but not replace it. Thank you.

Event Timeline

Restricted Application added a subscriber: Aklapper. · View Herald Transcript
Aklapper renamed this task from Watchlist page protection and user block expiration in logger to Display an entry for page in watchlist when page protection expired; Display an entry in user page when user blocking expired.Oct 22 2016, 9:52 PM
Aklapper triaged this task as Low priority.

And the same for user blocking expiration in user page. Less important, but a notification for the sysop that made protection or blocking in the first place

What is "user page" here? A notification on the user talk page of the sysop, or via Notifications (Echo), or both? Or something on the user page of the previously blocked user?

In general, this task seems to cover several requests. For future reference, please only file one issue per task - see https://mediawiki.org/wiki/How_to_report_a_bug . Thanks!

A logger entry where unblocked user home page is the target, exactly as it's done for blocking.

See T41038 for the problem, that a protection removes the other protection.

When the unprotect of the page is shown on recentchanges/watchlist than all users will see it and also the edit warriors knows the can start again. That's sounds not so good - but all can have good and bad sides

I really like this feature idea. Per Umherirrender, it would probably need to limit the display to admins though.

If it's possible, good enough for me.

jsn.sherman subscribed.

This would be much more likely to be considered by the moderator tools team if it were reframed into a problem statement, whereas this has some really specific solution requests in it. I'm not sure that watchlist makes sense as a home for this kind of information. If I understand correctly, the issue is the lack of visibility into expirations?

@jsn.sherman Problem statement/Use-case: As an admin on a wiki, I can currently see log-entries in my watchlist (or RecentChanges) for when a temporary Page-Protection is added, but there are no indications when that temporary status expires. -- I want [admin-only?] lines added to my watchlist (and RC?), indicating that a page I watchlist is no longer protected. That new indication would help remind me to play closer attention to that page in the near-future, or give me context for why it is suddenly getting vandalism/etc again.
E.g. screenshot of what I currently see in my watchlist, for a temporarily-protected page:

image.png (154×1 px, 68 KB)

However, I think the separate idea of a indicator for "temporary user-block expiry" would require a different phab-task & discussion. (As Aklapper wrote far above).