This is some text inside of a div block.
Explore more blogs
Nonprofit trends & insights

7 inspiring fundraising success stories powered by Givebutter

From million-dollar peer-to-peer campaigns to creative auctions, virtual events, and online fundraising wins, these seven nonprofits used Givebutter to raise more than $5.5M for their missions. Here’s how they did it.

Faustina Mulnik
September 1, 2026
Nerd Mr Butter

Table of contents

This is some text inside of a div block.

Table of contents

Subscribe

Don't miss out on weekly insights about all things fundraising and donor relations!
Success! Check your inbox, good news is on its way 💛
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Google
Add us as a preferred source on Google
Google
Add us as a preferred source on Google

What do a medical school endowment, a virtual YMCA fundraiser, a rare disease research campaign, and an auction featuring artwork made by rescued farm animals have in common?

Together, they helped raise more than $5.5M for causes that matter. All using Givebutter.

No two organizations followed the same recipe. Some leaned into peer-to-peer fundraising. Others found success through events, auctions, or online giving.

Each used Givebutter to make it easier for supporters to participate and connect with the mission, while helping their teams trade spreadsheets, manual exports, and disconnected systems for more time spent storytelling and building community.

Their fundraising software case studies are proof that with the right tools, a sprinkle of creativity, and plenty of heart, amazing things can happen. Let's take a look. 💛

7 nonprofits that crushed their fundraising goals with Givebutter

Seven nonprofits, seven unique challenges, and seven fundraising success stories powered by Givebutter. Here’s the spread:

1. Unless U: Raised $111K+ online after replacing a patchwork of fundraising tools 🎊

Unless U is a small, Alabama-based nonprofit dedicated to helping adults with disabilities continue learning, building relationships, and developing vocational skills long after high school.

For Marketing and Development Director Marye Grace Sauermann, supporting that mission meant juggling multiple tools. Donor records lived in one platform, email communications in another, and fundraising events somewhere else entirely.

That disconnected setup was putting valuable supporter relationships at stake:

“We were using Bloomerang and Mailchimp, but I could never get Zapier to work. I felt like I was always missing contacts.” — Marye Grace Sauermann, Marketing and Development Director, Unless U

After months of searching for a better solution, she discovered Givebutter.

The platform brought donor management, email communications, and fundraising events together in one place. Better yet, Givebutter's core features were free, allowing Unless U to test drive the platform without stretching its budget.

Get started with Givebutter’s CRM for free

Once the team made the switch, it was clear they'd found the missing ingredient.

For the first time, they had a complete view of more than a decade of donor relationships, allowing them to spend less time managing software and more time connecting with supporters.

As the organization grew more comfortable with Givebutter, they upgraded to How to create a donation page that converts (with real examples) →

2. GOSUMEC Foundation USA: Raised $2.5M after starting with just 25 supporters 💪

As a busy physician and Co-Founder of Double your donor base the GOSUMEC way →

3. The Summit Center: Turned a walkathon into a $296K community-powered success 🎉

Peer-to-peer fundraising: Steps, examples, & free toolkit →

5. Unity Farm Sanctuary: Exceeded its auction goal by 521% and raised $150K+ ⚡

Donor engagement: Top strategies, KPIs, & plan template →

7. Summit Area YMCA: Transformed a pandemic setback into a $377K fundraising win 🌟

The Summit Area YMCA relies on community fundraising to support programs ranging from childcare to food insecurity relief.

So when COVID-19 forced the organization to cancel its annual campaign kickoff event, the team had to rethink its entire fundraising strategy. Fast.

With time running out, the YMCA turned to Givebutter to launch its first-ever virtual fundraising campaign.

To recreate the energy of an in-person event online, the team used Givebutter's livestreaming tools to share stories, celebrate impact, and bring supporters together from wherever they were.

At the same time, Givebutter's team fundraising features turned volunteers into fundraisers, giving each team its own fundraising page, progress thermometer, and easy-to-use sharing tools.

The simplicity was exactly what the team had hoped for. As team member Kaitlin put it:

“We were trying to find something user-friendly and fun—something our volunteers wouldn’t have to spend a lot of time learning, but that would still make a big impact.” — Kaitlin, Team Member, The Summit Area YMCA

The result was a virtual campaign that felt surprisingly personal.

Supporters tuned into livestreams, fundraising teams rallied their networks, and donors left messages of encouragement on the supporter feed, creating a sense of community even while everyone was apart.

And while the campaign was born out of necessity, it quickly became one of the YMCA's most successful fundraising efforts, engaging more than 500 supporters, activating 33 fundraising teams, and raising over $377K for the organization's mission.

Along the way, the YMCA discovered that some of its most valuable fundraising lessons came from an event that almost didn't happen at all. Kaitlin shared:

“We're so happy to have found [Givebutter]. [...] We're thinking we'll never go back to fully in-person; it may just be hybrid from now on.” — Kaitlin, Team Member, The Summit Area YMCA

Looks like the YMCA found a recipe worth keeping. 🧈

What these fundraising success stories have in common

From a rare disease research campaign that raised more than $2M to an animal art auction that exceeded its goal by 521%, these organizations may have had different missions, but their success stories share a few familiar ingredients:

The gist: These stories suggest that when fundraising tools are accessible, connected, and supporter-friendly, many organizations are able to break through the busywork and focus on raising some serious dough for their mission. 🥖

Ready to write your own fundraising success story with Givebutter?

The organizations featured here couldn't be more different. They serve different communities, face different challenges, and raise money in very different ways.

What they shared was a fundraising platform that could adapt to their goals instead of forcing them into a one-size-fits-all approach.

Whether you're planning your first campaign, looking for a better donor management system, or searching for new ways to engage supporters, Givebutter gives you the tools to do it all in one place.

Best of all, you can get started with Givebutter's core features for free.

Create your account in minutes—no credit card required—and see what you can accomplish.

Sign up for FREE today.

FAQs

What types of nonprofits use Givebutter?

From schools and faith-based organizations to animal rescues, community programs, and charitable nonprofits, Givebutter supports a wide variety of missions.

While its free core features make it especially appealing to small- and mid-sized organizations, larger nonprofits also use Givebutter to streamline fundraising, events, donor management, and supporter engagement.

How much does Givebutter cost for nonprofits?

For many nonprofits, Givebutter costs exactly what they like to hear: $0.

Givebutter's core fundraising tools are free to use, which means you can create donation forms, fundraising pages, events, auctions, and more without paying platform fees.

Here's how: when you enable optional donor tips, your nonprofit pays $0 in platform fees and $0 in processing fees. If a donor doesn't cover the cost themselves, the Givebutter Guarantee steps in and covers it for you—so you still keep 100% of what you raise.

Prefer to turn tips off? That's fine too. A flat 3% platform fee applies, plus standard payment processing (2.9% + 30¢ for cards, 1.9% + 30¢ for ACH). You can choose to pass those fees on to donors, make them optional, or absorb them yourself. We’re nothing if not flexible.

Need a few extra bells and whistles? Givebutter Plus adds advanced automation, marketing, and productivity tools. But as many of the success stories above show, plenty of nonprofits are already raising serious dough with the free tool alone.

Can small nonprofits really raise significant funds online?

They sure can! And some of the stories in this article are proof of that.

Successful online fundraising isn't always about having the biggest budget or the largest team. More often, it's about making the most of your resources and giving supporters easy ways to get involved.

With the right tools (like Givebutter) in place, even small nonprofits can launch campaigns, build donor relationships, host events, and raise impressive amounts online, sometimes far more than they ever expected.

Next year, you could be one of our leading fundraising software case studies.

What features do these fundraising software case studies use most?

While every organization used Givebutter differently, a few features showed up again and again:

The butter part? Many organizations combined several of these tools together to create seamless fundraising experiences for both their teams and their supporters.

Share this article

Subscribe

Don’t miss out on weekly insights!
150K+ changemakers already subscribed
Newsletters
Success! Check your inbox, good news is on its way 💛
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Copy Page

Raise funds better, faster, and for free with Givebutter

More to explore

Mr Butter living the Givebutter experience

The Givebutter experience: 7 things you’ll love

Curious what it’s actually like to fundraise with Givebutter? Here’s a behind-the-scenes look at what nonprofit teams experience on the backend, what donors see on the front end, and why so many organizations choose to switch.

by 
Faustina Mulnik
The Givebutter experience: 7 things you’ll love
Mr Butter learning how do nonprofits make money

How do nonprofits make money? 5 revenue streams explained

Learn how nonprofits make money through top revenue sources—and how to stabilize income and do more with the funds you raise.

by 
Nicola Scoon
How do nonprofits make money? 5 revenue streams explained
Butter character next to donation landing page on a computer

How to create a donation page that converts (with real examples)

Learn how to set up a donation page that drives results with practical steps, optimization tips, and top examples from real nonprofits.

by 
Rachel Ayotte
How to create a donation page that converts (with real examples)
Mr Butter exploring Zelle for nonprofits

Zelle for nonprofits: What it can (& can't) do

Zelle is fast, free, and familiar, but it's not built for nonprofit fundraising. Learn where it falls short on donor data and tax receipts, plus which free alternatives make it easier to accept and track donations.

by 
Kate Romain
Zelle for nonprofits: What it can (& can't) do
Mr Butter choosing the top text-to-donate paltform

8 top text-to-donate platforms donors & nonprofits love to use

Choosing a text-to-donate platform comes down to how you fundraise and who you're trying to reach. This guide walks through 8 top options to help you find the right fit for your organization.

by 
Faustina Mulnik
8 top text-to-donate platforms donors & nonprofits love to use
Explore all blogs

Never miss a thing

Stay updated on our latest insights, events, and good news
Newsletters
Success! Check your inbox, good news is on its way 💛
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.