Change in Raptor behaviour #7107
Description
Summary
This commit 26e41f4 changes the result of the speed test for the following 3 cases: 1, 14, 22, 23, 33, and 36 (travelSearch.csv included).
This is might be a bug or fixing a bug, but we should probably investigate to find out. This might related to the increased responstime we saw when the PR #6084 was merged into dev-2.x. However, the tests I have done on my local machine and on the OTP performance-test does not indicate anything for this commit. I have not been able to reproduce the performance issue on my local machine, instead all my tests show the opposite - about 6-8% improved performance for the Raptor after the PR #6084 was merged.
I tested with the latest Norwegian dataset (30. Nov 2025).
Details
Test Cases
testCaseId,description,departure,arrival,window,origin,fromPlace,fromLat,fromLon,destination,toPlace,toLat,toLon,category,modes
1,"Intercity Notodden to Oslo",08:00,12:00,2h,Notodden Skysstasjon,NSR:StopPlace:20762,59.556698,9.25651,Oslo Bussterminal,NSR:StopPlace:6505,59.91177,10.757994,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
2,"Intercity Gol to Oslo",11:00,15:00,1h,Gol,NSR:StopPlace:324,60.69917,8.97123,Billingstad,NSR:StopPlace:577,59.874783,10.483057,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
3,"Oslo local, Slependen to city center",15:00,17:00,1h30m,IKEA Slependen,NSR:StopPlace:4401,59.87577,10.500488,Oslo Bussterminal,NSR:StopPlace:6505,59.91177,10.757994,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
4,"Outskirts Sponvika to Skjærhalden",16:00,20:30,1h,Sponvika,NSR:StopPlace:3009,59.09267,11.229988,Skjærhalden,NSR:StopPlace:1845,59.025497,11.036771,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
5,"Rural Ørje to Skjønhaug, Østold",13:00,14:30,1h10m,Ørje busstorg,NSR:StopPlace:911,59.480717,11.656314,Skjønhaug torv,NSR:StopPlace:1005,59.641224,11.315405,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
7,"Oslo outskirts Prinsdal to Solemskogen",17:00,20:00,2h,Prinsdal,NSR:StopPlace:6740,59.834175,10.807415,Solemskogen,NSR:StopPlace:6626,59.979305,10.817612,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
8,"Rural Drevsjø to Dalsbygda",08:00,16:00,2h,Drevsjø,NSR:StopPlace:8674,61.886,12.030646,Dalsbygda sentrum,NSR:StopPlace:8189,62.527782,11.108747,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
9,"Intercity Gjøvik to Lillehammer",15:00,17:00,1h30m,Steinvegen,NSR:StopPlace:14093,61.13245,10.454416,Holsjordet,NSR:StopPlace:14320,61.099922,10.47955,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
10,"Commuter Hokksund to Fossekallveien, Buskerud",08:00,15:00,5h,Hokksund stasjon,NSR:StopPlace:245,59.767204,9.910567,Fossekallveien,NSR:StopPlace:15726,60.178715,10.257535,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
11,"Commuter Torggata to Høyjord, Vestfold",13:00,16:00,1h,Torggata,NSR:StopPlace:17452,59.417572,10.482581,Høyjord,NSR:StopPlace:18872,59.366146,10.120965,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
12,"Commuter Meieritorvet to Sykehjemet, Telemark",10:00,11:30,1h,Meieritorvet,NSR:StopPlace:20257,59.13879,9.648428,Skien sykehjem,NSR:StopPlace:19979,59.213493,9.596075,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
13,"Rural Hastensund to Kolbjørnsvik, Agder",09:30,11:30,1h,Hastensund,NSR:StopPlace:21979,58.50631,8.922674,Kolbjørnsvik,NSR:StopPlace:24171,58.451637,8.76895,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
14,"Rural Hauge to Heskestad, Rogaland",08:00,15:16,4h,Hauge i Dalane,NSR:StopPlace:26062,58.343338,6.29508,Heskestad,NSR:StopPlace:26370,58.490974,6.361217,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
15,"Bergen local, Melkeplassen to Starefossbakken",16:00,18:00,1h30m,Melkeplassen,NSR:StopPlace:31882,60.376045,5.303988,Starefossbakken,NSR:StopPlace:29147,60.387913,5.35192,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
16,"Rural fjords, Helgheim to Vik",14:00,17:00,2h,Helgheim,NSR:StopPlace:34066,61.231983,7.115655,Vik kommunehus,NSR:StopPlace:37210,61.08844,6.579569,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
17,"Local, Ålesund",08:00,10:00,1h15m,Slinningsodden,NSR:StopPlace:41499,62.461693,6.16515,Kråmyra,NSR:StopPlace:40181,62.47539,6.191737,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
18,"Rural via Trondheim, Meldal-Fillan",07:00,20:00,8h,Meldal sentrum,NSR:StopPlace:42516,63.04669,9.713128,Fillan busstasjon,NSR:StopPlace:43785,63.60113,8.973342,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
19,"Rural Verrabotn to Snåsa, Trøndelag",06:00,18:00,4h,Verrabotn,NSR:StopPlace:45683,63.802647,10.581465,Snåsa,NSR:StopPlace:673,64.245766,12.380184,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
20,"Harstad local",15:00,17:00,1h50m,Harstad kirke,NSR:StopPlace:52154,68.801636,16.534492,Lamoveien,NSR:StopPlace:53953,68.81136,16.507952,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
21,"Rural Billefjord to Karasjok, Finnmark",08:00,18:00,8h,Indre Billefjord,NSR:StopPlace:57518,70.31518,25.046686,Karasjok bussterminal,NSR:StopPlace:56754,69.472664,25.5169,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
22,"Outskirts, Hamar-Oslo",09:00,16:00,3h,Hjellum,NSR:StopPlace:11701,61.768383,9.527959,Lyngveien,NSR:StopPlace:6645,59.897415,10.792623,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
23,"Train, Trondheim-Brønnøysund",04:00,26:00,12h,Trondheim S,NSR:StopPlace:659,63.436462,10.398694,Brønnøysund sentrum,NSR:StopPlace:51790,65.4755,12.211214,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
24,"Fly, Sogndal-Molde",08:00,22:00,4h,Sogndal Lufthamn,NSR:StopPlace:750,61.157547,7.137634,Molde Lufthavn,NSR:StopPlace:735,62.746407,7.260933,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
25,"Express bus, Haugesund-Trysil",00:01,26:00,10h,Haugesund bussterminal,NSR:StopPlace:26084,59.416233,5.27443,Trysil busstasjon,NSR:StopPlace:7310,61.318344,12.260398,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
27,"Express bus, Tromsø-Hammerfest",15:00,26:00,3h,Tromsø Prostneset,NSR:StopPlace:52273,69.647705,18.959843,Hammerfest bussterminal,NSR:StopPlace:56676,70.66445,23.680502,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
28,"Oslo high frequency",16:05,18:05,2h,Marienlyst,,59.932322,10.724663,Kjøbenhavngata,,59.928979,10.769432,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
29,"Too high heuristic cost OTP#3835",19:30,21:00,0h30m,Hauketo stasjon,NSR:StopPlace:6710,59.845947,10.803125,Steinberg stasjon,NSR:StopPlace:58839,59.75957,9.961188,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
30,"Crossing Oslo to Asker",09:00,,2h,Lillestrøm,,59.9559,11.0509,Asker,,59.8367,10.4249,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
31,"Crossing Oslo to Hokksund",09:00,,2h,Lillestrøm,,59.9559,11.0509,Hokksund,,59.7705,9.9088,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
33,"Stavanger to Bergen",09:00,,2h,Stavanger,,58.9698356,5.7278252,Bergen,,60.3920207,5.329484,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
36,"Drammen to Ålesund",10:00,,3h,Drammen,,59.7176376,10.2612305,Ålesund,,62.4869530,6.1303710,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
40,"Carl Berners Plass to Kolbotn - arrive by",,19:00,,Carl Berners Plass,,59.9261, 10.7753,Kolbotn,,59.8112, 10.7986,transit,TRANSIT|WALK
41,"Spikkestad to Gardemoen - arrive by",,17:00,,Spikkestad,NSR:StopPlace:694,59.7453,10.3417,Gardemoen,NSR:StopPlace:269,60.1931,11.0968,transit,RAIL|WALK
SpeedTest config
{
"feedId" : "RB",
"testDate": "2025-12-03",
"graph": "../../otp/norway/graph-otp2-${otp.serialization.version.id}.obj",
"tuningParameters": {
"dynamicSearchWindow": {
"minTransitTimeCoefficient": 0.75,
"minWaitTimeCoefficient": 0.0
},
"stopTransferCost": {
"DISCOURAGED": 86400,
"ALLOWED": 3000,
"RECOMMENDED": 300,
"PREFERRED": 0
}
},
"routingDefaults": {
"streetRoutingTimeout": "5s",
"numItineraries" : 12,
"transferPenalty": 0,
"turnReluctance": 1.0,
"elevatorBoardTime": 90,
"elevatorBoardCost": 90,
"elevatorHopTime" : 20,
"elevatorHopCost": 20,
"bicycle": {
"speed": 5,
"reluctance": 5.0,
"boardCost": 600,
"walk": {
"reluctance": 10.0
},
"parking": {
"cost": 120
}
},
"car" : {
"reluctance": 10,
"decelerationSpeed": 2.9,
"accelerationSpeed": 2.9,
"rental": {
"dropOffTime": "120s"
}
},
"walk": {
"speed": 1.3,
"reluctance": 4.0,
"stairsReluctance": 1.65,
"boardCost": 600
},
"wheelchairAccessibility": {
"trip": {
"onlyConsiderAccessible" : false
},
"stop": {
"onlyConsiderAccessible": false
},
"elevator": {
"onlyConsiderAccessible": false
}
},
"otherThanPreferredRoutesPenalty": 300,
"transferSlack": 120,
"boardSlackForMode" : {
"AIRPLANE": "35m"
},
"alightSlackForMode": {
"AIRPLANE": "15m"
},
"accessEgress": {
"maxDurationForMode": {
"BIKE_RENTAL": "20m",
"SCOOTER_RENTAL": "20m"
}
},
"maxDirectStreetDurationForMode": {
"CAR": "12h"
},
"itineraryFilters": {
"transitGeneralizedCostLimit": {
"costLimitFunction": "900 + 1.5x",
"intervalRelaxFactor": 0.75
},
"bikeRentalDistanceRatio": 0.3
},
"ignoreRealtimeUpdates": false,
"geoidElevation": false,
"maxJourneyDuration" : "36h",
"drivingDirection": "right",
"transferOptimization": {
"optimizeTransferWaitTime": true,
"minSafeWaitTimeFactor": 5.0,
"backTravelWaitTimeFactor": 1.0,
"extraStopBoardAlightCostsFactor": 8.0
},
"relaxTransitGroupPriority": "12m + 1.12x",
"transitGroupPriority": {
"global": [
{
"modes": [
"AIRPLANE"
]
}, {
"subModes": [
"localCarFerry"
]
}, {
"agencies": [
"RB:FLT:Authority:FLT"
]
}, {
"subModes": [
"highSpeedRail",
"regionalRail",
"interregionalRail",
"longDistance",
"international",
"sleeperRailService",
"nightRail",
"replacementRailService",
"crossCountryRail",
"railReplacementBus"
]
}, {
"agencies": [
"RB:ATU:Authority:1",
"RB:BOR:Authority:1",
"RB:BSR:Authority:1",
"RB:BSR:Authority:2",
"RB:TID:Authority:TID",
"RB:UNI:Authority:UNI"
]
}, {
"agencies": [
"RB:VYB:Authority:1",
"RB:VYX:Authority:1"
]
}, {
"agencies": [
"RB:FLI:Authority:FlixMobility"
]
}, {
"agencies": [
"RB:NBU:Authority:002"
]
}, {
"agencies": [
"RB:NWY:Authority:d1ea7af1-3c2a-4825-893f-21408ef08480"
]
}
]
}
}
}