This post is the single authoritative registration of the skills seat. Four-section template; the job description is versioned at .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/lanes/skills.md — ⛔ not copied here.
Current PM
⏳ vacant — the previous holder, session_01HZfg2AwVX191qCizp88gQr (skills seat R1, seated 2026-09-15T01:37Z; GitHub account os-zhuang — its content writes read back claude[bot] through 2026-09-15T20:04Z and os-zhuang from 2026-09-16T01:53Z, the account swap recorded on #18334 ), SIGNED OFF at 2026-09-16T04:32Z on the maintainer's order on the direct channel (「当前任务处理完,合并后就下班」, given after PR #18359 landed); the 收班简报 is the newest comment on this post and is the release marker — a successor seats immediately by /pm-dispatch 接手 after reading this post.
接任台账 (hand-off ledger, written at sign-off)
In flight: 0 devs. Every dev of the shift reported and was reviewed; no dev session to archive (all were in-session subagents of the previous session, none a CCR session).Governed PRs hung for an authorized APPROVED — 4 , each with its four-piece (record on the PR, 速读终稿, ACCEPT on the card, needs-user-decision, reviewer hotlong — os-zhuang is the author of all four under the previous seat's write identity and can neither be requested nor approve): AGENTS.md §3 criterion ③ tests the branch's WHOLE ancestry, so --force-with-lease is dead letter for every branch cut from main (measured: 33 pairs vs 1 scoped; control: main itself reads 32) #18178 docs(agents): criterion ③'s test is scoped to the branch's own commits — the unranged git log walked all of main and made force-with-lease dead letter #18351 ec9ef17b, AGENTS.md :473–:474; record 5691146373, ACCEPT 5691146817) · [finding] the enqueue bar 「每一个 check 全绿」 is unsatisfiable as written — every landing carries 7-10 skipped checks, and nothing distinguishes an expected skip from a path-filter miss #18308 fix(pm): the enqueue bar names expected skips — a path-filtered job's skip is not a failure, and a check reports the skips outside the declared roster #18357 7a1f99ea, SKILL.md :629 + scripts/pm/check-expected-skips.mjs + package.json; record 5691464077, ACCEPT 5691461390; head green 42 / 42) · [finding] Clause-②: yes on a non-spec, non-skills lane — the protocol says the contract-review-tier review is the spec seat's, but spells no handoff (who is asked, by which artefact), so a lane seat reaches for an in-seat PASS the harness classifier then refuses as self-approval #18349 docs(pm): the clause-② contract review is tier-bound — the dispatching seat reviews in-seat at CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER, no seat list #18363 a0f37dda, SKILL.md :513 / :523 / :641 + contract-review.md :26 / :41 / :51 / :52 + one platform-readings row; record 5692045480, ACCEPT 5692045887; Lint & Repo Gates still running at sign-off) · [finding] guard-governed-enqueue.selftest.sh: the case 「an exception-row path in a repo this container cannot resolve」 is not hermetic — it reads 54 passed / 1 failed on any box with a sibling /home/user/cloud checkout, green in CI only because CI has none #18321 fix(hooks): guard-governed-enqueue's sibling-checkout lookup is injectable, so its self-test is hermetic on a box that carries the sibling #18365 5391e5c0, the two guard-governed-enqueue hook files; record 5692046150, ACCEPT 5692046598; Lint & Repo Gates still running at sign-off; the red TypeScript Type Check is on the superseded commit 68d26af5, noted at 5691988381). On an APPROVED: ruling C by the seat holder of that moment (record on the current head, --pair 0, every check success or a rostered skip — read with check-expected-skips.mjs on PR fix(pm): the enqueue bar names expected skips — a path-filtered job's skip is not a failure, and a check reports the skips outside the declared roster #18357 needs-user-decision, ready through the CCR route, auto-merge SQUASH, provenance, three readings, residue, landing record); the approver may also flip ready + enqueue directly. The previous session keeps its PR subscriptions on the four and, if woken by an approval, performs that landing itself (留守 on exactly these four; nothing else).Queue (pm:queue, this lane, unassigned) at sign-off, in total order — 13 : p2 · Bug — [finding] guard-governed-enqueue's slug reader keeps a .git suffix — a sibling cloned with the conventional URL never resolves, and a bare gh pr merge N on such a clone derives a slug the API 404s on, so the guard fails OPEN #18366 slug_of keeps a .git suffix: a conventional-URL sibling never resolves, and the bare gh pr merge N slug 404s the guard OPEN; hooks, rules layer; SERIAL behind PR fix(hooks): guard-governed-enqueue's sibling-checkout lookup is injectable, so its self-test is hermetic on a box that carries the sibling #18365 [cloud] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17163 objectstack-ai/cloud) · [finding] objectui's half-state findings reach no reader: the board has no anchor by ruling, and its copy of check-half-states still refuses in agent containers with the conclusion #13544 disproved #18290 check-half-states.mjs copy; waits on the maintainer's objectui#9395 A / B / C) · [finding] post-stamped | tail -N && label-write silently breaks the comment-before-label pairing — the pipeline returns tail's 0, so a REFUSED comment still lets the label land #18337 [finding] REST 写侧强制头 Content-Type 的规则只住在 platform-readings.md —— 「动手前查一行」的 rest-channel.md 写侧段零提及、零交叉引用,一个班次内三席踩中 #18339 [finding] rest-channel :54 still says the REST actor is 「按会话」 claude[bot] or a user — the token class follows the Claude Code account and flipped inside one session twice; one in-place re-key pointing at the fact table #18360 Content-Type cross-reference, :54's 「按会话」 re-key — a three-card FOLD on one file, 82 / 82 in place; the previous seat drafted its claims and dispatch text but did NOT dispatch — start from the three cards' bodies and gradings 5691531819 / 5691532336 / [finding] rest-channel :54 still says the REST actor is 「按会话」 claude[bot] or a user — the token class follows the Claude Code account and flipped inside one session twice; one in-place re-key pointing at the fact table #18360 ADR-0135 的两处过期物随 #14361 的 Fixes 一起消失:Consequences 的 Until then 前件已过,:63 的 grep 配方读起来像通用总体筛而两个方向各错(本席自己误用两次) #18345 Until then passage and the :63 recipe's scope; docs/adr/**, rules layer; SERIAL behind PR docs(adr): ADR-0135's two prose citations of the code name what the code now says #18344 [finding] git-history.mjs touchIsProvable reports boundary: false for a registered graft boundary whose parent has since been fetched — the refusal is right, the flag and the reason text are wrong #18355 touchIsProvable boundary flag false negative; scripts/pm/git-history.mjs, non-governed) · Wire check-harness-current.mjs --self-test (PR #18352) into lint.yml's shallow-history self-test collector — a self-test nobody runs is the injury check-self-test-wired exists for #18356 check-harness-current.mjs --self-test into lint.yml's shallow-history collector; dispatchable now; region-parallel with Wire pnpm check:pm-expected-skips (PR #18357) into lint.yml beside the other check:pm-* steps — a self-test no workflow names is outside check-self-test-wired's population #18358 Wire pnpm check:pm-expected-skips (PR #18357) into lint.yml beside the other check:pm-* steps — a self-test no workflow names is outside check-self-test-wired's population #18358 pnpm check:pm-expected-skips into lint.yml; SERIAL behind PR fix(pm): the enqueue bar names expected skips — a path-filtered job's skip is not a failure, and a check reports the skips outside the declared roster #18357 [finding] platform-readings :134 / :143 list the draft flip and the auto-merge mount as GraphQL-only and stand a seat down for them in a rate-limit window — both have live ccr routes, the only routes since lock 1 #18361 docs(pm): the clause-② contract review is tier-bound — the dispatching seat reviews in-seat at CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER, no seat list #18363 platform-readings 的 detach 处方没说 pid 从哪来 —— 用 pgrep -f 重新推导会自匹配到包装器自己,监视器永远等自己 #18362 [finding] guard-governed-enqueue's 「no checkout available」 fail-open is pinned by no self-test case in any environment — the case that claimed it never reaches it; one hermetic case with the injected empty root #18367 fix(hooks): guard-governed-enqueue's sibling-checkout lookup is injectable, so its self-test is hermetic on a box that carries the sibling #18365 [finding] guard-governed-enqueue's slug reader keeps a .git suffix — a sibling cloned with the conventional URL never resolves, and a bare gh pr merge N on such a clone derives a slug the API 404s on, so the guard fails OPEN #18366 hotcrm has no half-state patrol anchor, so the pm:dispatched + assignee residue after a Fixes auto-close has now been repaired by hand seven rounds running #14881 The M9.1 / M9.2 expression phases — including "ast becomes required in build output" — are asserted in six files and one published docs page, and defined in no ADR #17323 skills: evaluate whether the published security/platform guidance must teach the app-capability vs system-permission distinction and the isDefault → everyone binding rule (after #17189) #17359 pm:blocked, [www.objectos.ai] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17165 [Decision] 22 pure-objectui defect cards live in objectstack under repo:objectui, but objectui IS reachable — the seam fallback is being used where its precondition does not hold #17250 pm:awaiting-maintainer, Published-skills factual sweep: verify every behavioral claim in skills/** against the implementation — program anchor #13658 Skills catalog optimization program (maintainer-directed): audit every skill on both roots, then optimize — program anchor #14292 [program] CLAUDE.md is a pointer to AGENTS.md in every repo — no second instruction set to maintain (maintainer 2026-09-09) #17161 PM corpus audit (maintainer-directed): classify every instruction line — keep / duplicate / demote / delete — then rewrite and re-lock every ratchet #13597 pm:dispatched.Hot-file serial queue at sign-off : SKILL.md — PR fix(pm): the enqueue bar names expected skips — a path-filtered job's skip is not a failure, and a check reports the skips outside the declared roster #18357 docs(pm): the clause-② contract review is tier-bound — the dispatching seat reviews in-seat at CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER, no seat list #18363 origin/main; platform-readings.md — PR docs(pm): the clause-② contract review is tier-bound — the dispatching seat reviews in-seat at CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER, no seat list #18363 docs(pm): platform-readings retires the denied enqueue tool's rows and reads the REST token class per write, not per session #18359 [finding] platform-readings :134 / :143 list the draft flip and the auto-merge mount as GraphQL-only and stand a seat down for them in a rate-limit window — both have live ccr routes, the only routes since lock 1 #18361 platform-readings 的 detach 处方没说 pid 从哪来 —— 用 pgrep -f 重新推导会自匹配到包装器自己,监视器永远等自己 #18362 docs(pm): the clause-② contract review is tier-bound — the dispatching seat reviews in-seat at CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER, no seat list #18363 [finding] post-stamped | tail -N && label-write silently breaks the comment-before-label pairing — the pipeline returns tail's 0, so a REFUSED comment still lets the label land #18337 [finding] REST 写侧强制头 Content-Type 的规则只住在 platform-readings.md —— 「动手前查一行」的 rest-channel.md 写侧段零提及、零交叉引用,一个班次内三席踩中 #18339 [finding] rest-channel :54 still says the REST actor is 「按会话」 claude[bot] or a user — the token class follows the Claude Code account and flipped inside one session twice; one in-place re-key pointing at the fact table #18360 Wire check-harness-current.mjs --self-test (PR #18352) into lint.yml's shallow-history self-test collector — a self-test nobody runs is the injury check-self-test-wired exists for #18356 Wire pnpm check:pm-expected-skips (PR #18357) into lint.yml beside the other check:pm-* steps — a self-test no workflow names is outside check-self-test-wired's population #18358 .claude/hooks/guard-governed-enqueue* — PR fix(hooks): guard-governed-enqueue's sibling-checkout lookup is injectable, so its self-test is hermetic on a box that carries the sibling #18365 [finding] guard-governed-enqueue's slug reader keeps a .git suffix — a sibling cloned with the conventional URL never resolves, and a bare gh pr merge N on such a clone derives a slug the API 404s on, so the guard fails OPEN #18366 [finding] guard-governed-enqueue's 「no checkout available」 fail-open is pinned by no self-test case in any environment — the case that claimed it never reaches it; one hermetic case with the injected empty root #18367 docs(agents): criterion ③'s test is scoped to the branch's own commits — the unranged git log walked all of main and made force-with-lease dead letter #18351 Cross-lane memos : objectui#9395 A / B / C (A recommended; [finding] objectui's half-state findings reach no reader: the board has no anchor by ruling, and its copy of check-half-states still refuses in agent containers with the conclusion #13544 disproved #18290 gen-sdui-manifest.sh hardcodes port 5180 and one log path, so two concurrent runs in a container can dump the OTHER run's server #9578 fix(tooling): error-status gate names the real cause when a code leaves the ungraded set (#9563) #9577 skills/** review to this lane) — the previous seat recommended returning it to the ui seat under the [finding] Clause-②: yes on a non-spec, non-skills lane — the protocol says the contract-review-tier review is the spec seat's, but spells no handoff (who is asked, by which artefact), so a lane seat reaches for an in-seat PASS the harness classifier then refuses as self-approval #18349 docs(pm): the clause-② contract review is tier-bound — the dispatching seat reviews in-seat at CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER, no seat list #18363 [PM seat] triage (objectstack-wide) — 🟢 在席 session_01WDxrLMPs5TyKB45RPiJuLo · R+244 · harness **CURRENT** · 写入身份 os-sam(User)六轮稳定 · ⭐ **pm:retriage 两仓清零** · 本轮:objectui#6653 改造为先测量 · #7997 关 completed → 残余立 #9593 · 更正本席 #18362 的行号漂移 · 欠账:objectui ①50/④34/finding 39 · objectstack ①31/③7+16/finding 35 · 决策箱 1(#18364 待一个字母)· ⚠️ #18172 仍是唯一 p1 · ⚠️ objectui domain:ui 席 #5560 因同一 harness STALE 于 04:45Z 收班 #6015 Maintainer items (report only) : hotlong's approvals on the four PRs; a dedicated low-privilege GitHub account (or the App installation token) behind seat sessions — the approver account now authors every seat artefact; the board-archive surplus 17 (board-snapshot run 46 RED); the runbook ceiling; objectui#9395; [cloud] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17163 Timers: none. The patrol Routine (trig_01W822gWwQ64s2HfHUfkfKUN) and the accelerator (trig_01EAuFgusXR8J3FSCBWd9Bdr) were deleted at sign-off; the only standing wake is the previous session's PR subscriptions on the four hung PRs.Landed this shift ×36 (see LANDED below); the shared checkout claude/relaxed-rubin-a3ffs8 is at origin/main b57671ed and pushed. · session session_01HZfg2AwVX191qCizp88gQr · seated 2026-09-15T02:02Z on the maintainer's /pm-dispatch skills summon · R1 · this session serves at the contract-review tier (CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER), the mandated floor for the SKILL.md chain · body refreshed 2026-09-16T04:32Z at the SHIFT END (wave 39 — the previous session signed off; the wave-38 events follow for the record: the [finding] check-harness-current.mjs prints the graft boundary as a harness path's latest touch on a shallow checkout — the CURRENT / STALE verdict holds by construction, but the printed sha is not a reading of the path #18330 fix(pm): check-harness-current prints boundary, not a fabricated sha, when a harness path's latest touch is not provable on the shallow checkout #18352 1411cf2c at 2026-09-16T03:12Z; the [finding] the enqueue bar 「每一个 check 全绿」 is unsatisfiable as written — every landing carries 7-10 skipped checks, and nothing distinguishes an expected skip from a path-filter miss #18308 fix(pm): the enqueue bar names expected skips — a path-filtered job's skip is not a failure, and a check reports the skips outside the declared roster #18357 AGENTS.md §3 criterion ③ tests the branch's WHOLE ancestry, so --force-with-lease is dead letter for every branch cut from main (measured: 33 pairs vs 1 scoped; control: main itself reads 32) #18178 docs(agents): criterion ③'s test is scoped to the branch's own commits — the unranged git log walked all of main and made force-with-lease dead letter #18351 [finding] the seat's REST writes now land as a USER account, not claude[bot] — the durability premise in platform-readings, #6015 and every Routine prompt is falsified #18334 [finding] post-stamped | tail -N && label-write silently breaks the comment-before-label pairing — the pipeline returns tail's 0, so a REFUSED comment still lets the label land #18337 [finding] REST 写侧强制头 Content-Type 的规则只住在 platform-readings.md —— 「动手前查一行」的 rest-channel.md 写侧段零提及、零交叉引用,一个班次内三席踩中 #18339 ADR-0135 的两处过期物随 #14361 的 Fixes 一起消失:Consequences 的 Until then 前件已过,:63 的 grep 配方读起来像通用总体筛而两个方向各错(本席自己误用两次) #18345 [finding] platform-readings: the REST proxy's write identity changed mid-shift with no seat action — content writes read back claude[bot] (installation) until 2026-09-15T20:04Z and os-zhuang / User via app claude (user-to-server) from 2026-09-16T01:53Z — the register has no row saying the token class is re-read, not assumed #18350 [finding] the seat's REST writes now land as a USER account, not claude[bot] — the durability premise in platform-readings, #6015 and every Routine prompt is falsified #18334 Wire pnpm check:pm-expected-skips (PR #18357) into lint.yml beside the other check:pm-* steps — a self-test no workflow names is outside check-self-test-wired's population #18358 [finding] platform-readings: four rows describe MCP enable_pr_auto_merge / disable_pr_auto_merge behaviour a seat can no longer reach once lock 1 denies the enqueue class (:41 · :49 · :58 · :60) #18320 [finding] the seat's REST writes now land as a USER account, not claude[bot] — the durability premise in platform-readings, #6015 and every Routine prompt is falsified #18334 On a shallow checkout git log -1 -- <path> names a commit that never touched the path — measured: the seating charter reading returned a real sha from an unrelated driver-test commit #18180 [finding] measure-self-test-floor.mjs refuses to print any census on current main — its recogniser reads two landed handshake spellings as absent, so the instrument cannot answer the floor question anyone runs it for #18329 [finding] check-harness-current.mjs prints the graft boundary as a harness path's latest touch on a shallow checkout — the CURRENT / STALE verdict holds by construction, but the printed sha is not a reading of the path #18330 [finding] objectql hook-wrappers.ts: two docblocks still state the retired batch model for the before* dispatch of a predicate write in the present tense, while the code beneath binds per row #18331 [cloud] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17163 session_01VxjMEAhT53WHUCtP9WMrSU seated at 2026-09-15T13:45Z and STOOD DOWN at 2026-09-15T15:54Z — [PM seat] triage (objectstack-wide) — 🟢 在席 session_01WDxrLMPs5TyKB45RPiJuLo · R+244 · harness **CURRENT** · 写入身份 os-sam(User)六轮稳定 · ⭐ **pm:retriage 两仓清零** · 本轮:objectui#6653 改造为先测量 · #7997 关 completed → 残余立 #9593 · 更正本席 #18362 的行号漂移 · 欠账:objectui ①50/④34/finding 39 · objectstack ①31/③7+16/finding 35 · 决策箱 1(#18364 待一个字母)· ⚠️ #18172 仍是唯一 p1 · ⚠️ objectui domain:ui 席 #5560 因同一 harness STALE 于 04:45Z 收班 #6015 fix(settings,pm-dispatch): deny mcp__github__update_pull_request and route the ready flip through the CCR routes #18276 cloud (read-only) and cloned objectos + hotcrm anonymously, deepened each to 400 first-parent commits; topological window clean on the pair, and a 7-day date-window baseline over the three newly attached repos lists 9 governed merges for the maintainer's recognition (see the audit line below); next tips objectstack=827cacbf4b79 · objectui=88561fdc4856 · cloud=cb8ee7ff60c0 · objectos=cb0c1467b040 · hotcrm=9f13c77eb493; PR fix(settings,pm-dispatch): deny mcp__github__update_pull_request and route the ready flip through the CCR routes #18276 feat(pm): a gate pins permissions.deny to the charter's content-write roster #18285 [finding] platform-readings: four rows describe MCP update_pull_request as a live channel after lock 1 denies it (:43 · :46 · :47 · :338), plus the PR-body second-footer reading #18280 ⚠️ os-zhuang is a GOVERNED_APPROVERS account: this seat writes no approving review under any account (red line); reported to the maintainer in the round report. Takeover compression: the previous body (os-project-manager · session_01DAcomhvR9kKizeYgg89Vo8; brief 5673402511 is the release) is restated below; older history lives in this post's edit history and in that brief. Round-open marker 5673548571 carries the four mutex readings, the charter re-read at b3b43b6 (8c657f7 / 9b00f9f), the harness reading (CURRENT) and the REST probe.
Maintainer rulings in force (verbatim on their cards, ⛔ not restated): tier policy (#17285 → PR #17294 ) · card-home (#17288 ) · review-of-record (#17302 ) · #17189 rider → #17359 (blocked) · forced-takeover (#17033 ) · #17323 ruled B (batch #123 item 1, 5644710461) · #17624 ruled B · #17942 Q1 = A / Q2 = three-class table; Q3 WITHDRAWN by triage ruling ③ (5652544529: grading, routing, dedupe, shadow check are triage's; the skills lane's finding self-triage exception stands per lanes/skills.md; while #6015 is VACANT this seat routes bare cards as stand-in triage — 代扫 — and stops the moment a triage seat sits) · #17934 = shape 1 · governed-surface tiering (#17950 ): rules layer waits for an authorized approval, only references/** lands through the queue after in-seat contract-tier review · ruling C (#17971 , 5652306063; 「C. approve 后不管后续改动都由席位落地:」): once an authorized APPROVED review (os-zhuang / hotlong, not dismissed) exists on a governed PR, the OWNING seat lands it — record on the current head, --pair exit 0, all checks green, clear needs-user-decision, ready, auto-merge SQUASH · batch default 3 (#18125 → PR #18128 ) · write identity follows the CHANNEL (#18205 → PR #18216 ): REST-proxy-only content writes, user.login names the token, the session ID is the attribution; the ACCEPT refuses a report whose mcp_calls names a write tool.
Inherited + running ledger (hand-off)
In flight: 0 devs (sign-off). Governed PRs awaiting an authorized approval: 4 — see the 接任台账 above for heads, records and the ruling-C recipe: PR docs(agents): criterion ③'s test is scoped to the branch's own commits — the unranged git log walked all of main and made force-with-lease dead letter #18351 AGENTS.md §3 criterion ③ tests the branch's WHOLE ancestry, so --force-with-lease is dead letter for every branch cut from main (measured: 33 pairs vs 1 scoped; control: main itself reads 32) #18178 fix(pm): the enqueue bar names expected skips — a path-filtered job's skip is not a failure, and a check reports the skips outside the declared roster #18357 [finding] the enqueue bar 「每一个 check 全绿」 is unsatisfiable as written — every landing carries 7-10 skipped checks, and nothing distinguishes an expected skip from a path-filter miss #18308 docs(pm): the clause-② contract review is tier-bound — the dispatching seat reviews in-seat at CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER, no seat list #18363 [finding] Clause-②: yes on a non-spec, non-skills lane — the protocol says the contract-review-tier review is the spec seat's, but spells no handoff (who is asked, by which artefact), so a lane seat reaches for an in-seat PASS the harness classifier then refuses as self-approval #18349 fix(hooks): guard-governed-enqueue's sibling-checkout lookup is injectable, so its self-test is hermetic on a box that carries the sibling #18365 [finding] guard-governed-enqueue.selftest.sh: the case 「an exception-row path in a repo this container cannot resolve」 is not hermetic — it reads 54 passed / 1 failed on any box with a sibling /home/user/cloud checkout, green in CI only because CI has none #18321 On a shallow checkout git log -1 -- <path> names a commit that never touched the path — measured: the seating charter reading returned a real sha from an unrelated driver-test commit #18180 fix(pm): the charter latest-touch reading is taken depth-independently — a shallow clone's git log names a commit that never touched the path #18327 d977c7a5; design (B) — git-history.mjs gains a touch mode that prints a last-touch sha only when every parent the commit object names is present locally AND diff-tree touches the path, else fetch --deepen doubling from 64, --unshallow, then exit 2 with EMPTY stdout; SKILL.md :89 re-keyed in place to 「…最新触碰 sha 走 git-history.mjs touch」, 119 → 117 B, 812 / 812; self-test 37 → 54, 17-case battery; the mechanism ESTABLISHED on a constructed repo at two depths — the boundary object still names a parent the clone lacks, git diffs it against the empty tree; the seat's live probes on the shared shallow checkout: lanes/skills.md REFUSED naming boundary 9b00f9f9, SKILL.md answered 53dd5aaa without a fetch, both agreeing with REST; record 5685889073 PASS, 速读终稿 5685889666, ACCEPT 5685890066, needs-user-decision, reviewers os-zhuang + hotlong requested 2026-09-15T18:33Z) · [finding] 两份已发布 skills 仍教 before* 钩子整批触发,并推销一个没有生产者的诊断(HookConditionLimitation) #18221 docs(skills): before* hooks on a predicate write dispatch per row — the two published skills stop teaching a batch dispatch and a retired guard #18328 96718735; the two PUBLISHED skills corrected at eight sites to the contract's per-row before* dispatch — D1 / D2, the payload rule D3 with MULTI_UPDATE_HOOK_KEY_DIVERGENCE, the D6 ceiling — the four true table rows byte-identical to main, the false family 0 inside both files, the skills token ratchet in headroom; the dev's one-off engine probe measured the per-row shape; built at the review tier by the skills/** mandate; record 5685957577 PASS, 速读终稿 5685958192, ACCEPT 5685958748, needs-user-decision, reviewers requested 2026-09-15T18:37Z) · [Decision] permissions.deny: extend declared = enforced to the enqueue class — deny mcp__github__enable_pr_auto_merge too, or keep it hook-guarded only? #18282 fix(settings,pm): deny the MCP enqueue class — enable/disable_pr_auto_merge join lock 1 and the roster gate #18317 ad7a3da5; ruling 5682626575 A — enable_pr_auto_merge + disable_pr_auto_merge in permissions.deny 15 → 17, the roster gate 17 = 17 with 36 cases, rest-channel :53 「auto-merge MCP 锁 1 同拒」; hooks untouched; record 5684320675 PASS, 速读终稿 5684321187, ACCEPT 5684321543, needs-user-decision, reviewers os-zhuang + hotlong requested 2026-09-15T16:49Z; the objectui mirror of lock 1 gets its own card after the landing, per the ruling) · [Decision] AGENTS.md's comment rule vs preserved verbatim maintainer rulings that contain a model identifier — carve out quotations (A), treat them as violations (B), or leave it undecided (C) #18092 docs(agents): the comment rule exempts a verbatim maintainer ruling preserved as a quotation block #18315 b671f83b; AGENTS.md :441–:444 — 「Two exemptions: a harness-written Co-Authored-By trailer … and a verbatim maintainer ruling preserved as a quotation block」, 1075 / 1075 paid by the restated clause 「the pair stays model-free」; the probe half measured EMPTY — no repository code reads prose for model identifiers, the counts the card feared were seat hand-greps; record 5684207107 PASS, 速读终稿 5684216809, ACCEPT 5684217387, needs-user-decision, reviewers os-zhuang + hotlong requested 2026-09-15T16:42Z); all four land by ruling C after their approvals; ⚠️ PR fix(settings,pm): deny the MCP enqueue class — enable/disable_pr_auto_merge join lock 1 and the roster gate #18317 Check Changeset failure from 16:42Z, before skip-changeset was applied — the two later runs of the same check read skipped, the platform counts the newest, and a REST re-run is 403 for the installation; update-branch is the fallback if the enqueue is refused. ACCEPTED, landing in-seat: 0 · ENQUEUED: 0 (PR docs(pm): platform-readings retires the denied enqueue tool's rows and reads the REST token class per write, not per session #18359 [finding] platform-readings: a phrase that only exists after joining (string concatenation, markdown emphasis, a wrapped line) reads 0 under a single-line grep in both directions — the instrument row PR #18194 could not fit into the rules layer #18195 [finding] platform-readings: write identity is a per-session credential shape — installation → claude[bot], user-to-server → the human login with performed_via_github_app: claude; GET /user answers the human login in BOTH, so it is not the probe #18158 [finding] MCP search_issues DID honour GitHub qualifiers (repo: is: label:) in two exact readings — the ledger's "qualifier form returns total_count 0" rule needs a second session before it stands or falls #16762 [finding] issue 的 comments 字段可读出 1 而 list 与 timeline 两条通道都读 0 —— 可复现,带四张对照 #18219 [finding] platform-readings: a suspended account's EVENTS are erased with its content (labels stay, the labeled actor is gone) — and the one variable shared by the two suspended triage accounts is the hourly periodic-burst shape, not volume #18147 [finding] a PCRE negative lookahead followed by a character class silently loses its through the GitHub comment API — the published command then errors to stderr and prints 0, which reads as a clean absence #18258 [finding] objectui CI concurrency is keyed on the PR number, so re-running a superseded head cancels the current head — a re-run is a write, not a read #18262 claude/issue-18195-platform-readings-fold, default tier (--tier names no mandate for references/**), dispatched 2026-09-15T06:25Z; the [finding] MCP search_issues DID honour GitHub qualifiers (repo: is: label:) in two exact readings — the ledger's "qualifier form returns total_count 0" rule needs a second session before it stands or falls #16762 search_issues total_count: 208 / incomplete_results: false for the qualifier-shaped query and the seat's REST control GET /issues?labels=pm:queue&state=open = 208 at 2026-09-15T06:25Z (qualifiers ARE honoured; the register's「limited-form total_count: 0」row is false). Governed PRs awaiting an authorized approval: 0 — PR fix(settings,pm-dispatch): deny mcp__github__update_pull_request and route the ready flip through the CCR routes #18276 LANDED this shift ×36 (instants are merged_at, the group's fast-forward — see [finding] platform-readings: in a merge-queue repository the squash commit's committer date is the ENQUEUE instant, not the landing — merged_at and the merged event carry the fast-forward #18274 [finding] half-state H31 binds a PR to a card by its Part of line, so every correctly-gated epic tracker gets a row telling a seat to hang a gate nothing will clear #18229 fix(pm): bind H31's carrier pair through the closing keyword #18243 ecf91cb44194107bcb8be8f20ea3fd97562f18d7 at 2026-09-15T03:44Z · [finding] check-clause2-carriers: an unreadable or off-tier Served-tier: line is refused only beside a gate clear (C7) — a non-gated pair with the same record passes exit 0, against contract-review.md :29 「无此行不成裁决」 #18174 fix(pm): judge a review of record's Served-tier: line on every pair that has one #18251 fd1247142a4beac65f9016de78f70caf7bb976b3 at 2026-09-15T04:51Z · class (a): pnpm check:pm-dispatch-gates cannot complete inside the container's ~10-minute foreground cap — measured 9m0s then exit 124, twice; the wall-clock twin of #17708 #18201 perf(pm): discover each tree once per process — the dispatch-gates self-test now reaches a verdict inside the foreground cap #18255 47bfcd090c809cf219e4fa497fe363bb94a22388 at 2026-09-15T05:15Z · [finding] H64 fires on REST writes that #18205 made correct — its REST implies claude[bot] premise was superseded, and its remedy cannot clear it #18237 fix(pm): H64 keys on the session id in the text, not on the author account #18257 e592b4b6b7fe62e465a3eead0c6f9a8e94838585 at 2026-09-15T05:18Z · [finding] platform-readings: the session proxy serves CCR routes on api.github.com for ready-for-review, auto-merge, review threads and resolve — every seat landing action now has a REST spelling authored claude[bot] #18130 pm(skills): probe the unexercised CCR routes and the shared MCP user bucket into the REST channel register #18259 c053f748b68c6b877b0462d491b47dff27915692 at 2026-09-15T05:48Z · [finding] board-snapshot: the archive holds nothing above #17726 — the delta walk sits two days behind the live board while the per-run budget goes to history, so the 2026-09-14 suspension's cards were never captured #18137 fix(pm): red the board-snapshot run when the archive has gone stale #18266 e9091487f5adeb74b580b927921ee83e32550a84 at 2026-09-15T06:02Z (landing record 5675544938) · [finding] check-clause2-carriers: a contract-review record whose head sha shares one code span with its key names NO head (H51_SHA_SPAN), so C6 reads 「no review of record」 where one exists — contract-review.md :28 never says the span holds the sha alone #18141 fix(pm): say the head sha sits in a code span of its own, and name the refused spelling #18270 48a93fb6824ca0804bae4b0b1c4eb2fa24ded0eb at 2026-09-15T06:20Z (landing record 5675706948) · 共享身份的限流纪律不存在：一次限流信号约束的是「身份」不是「客户端」，而规矩只说了不要重试 —— 2026-09-10 全 fleet 停摆事故 #17374 pm-dispatch: reconcile the quota rows with the identity-bound rate limit; merged-write rule; account-suspension recovery readings #18242 1a02ef17d61b00dcf1658d0ac99e35d0a706200e at 2026-09-15T06:20Z (governed; APPROVED by os-zhuang, ruling-C provenance 5675577662, landing record 5675706748) · [finding] AGENTS.md states the merge queue's required set as six contexts and calls the rest advisory — it is seven, and no gate reds on the stale sentence #17798 fix(agents,gates): the merge queue blocks on seven contexts, and a set-stating surface is now a census #18244 1297178e968bbfa0bed51de24ed3d596d63dd0dd at 2026-09-15T06:32Z (governed; APPROVED by os-zhuang, ruling-C provenance 5675577896; landing record posted 2026-09-15T06:40Z) · finding(agents): .claude/agents/os-dev.md:288 orders the dev seat to hang needs:contract-review on the PR, and the dev's container forbids label writes — measured on two independent runs today #18181 docs(agents): the contract-review carrier is the seat's to hang; --pair PR-NUMBER is the only spelling #18250 41ff021ca77930b13c167274857d2b689a91220e at 2026-09-15T06:32Z (governed; APPROVED ×2, provenance 5675627247; landing record posted 2026-09-15T06:40Z) · [finding] Two triage gradings named a target the governing ADR itself rejects — the grading quotes no line of the adjudication it routes against #17497 docs(pm-dispatch): a triage direction landing in an adjudicated area quotes the governing line #18256 681317c3acbb80290a02c7d093c1be53fdb346a7 at 2026-09-15T06:35Z (governed; APPROVED, provenance 5675627549; landing record posted 2026-09-15T06:40Z); the three were one queue chain — merged_at 06:32:45Z ×2 then 06:35:29Z · [finding] check-dispatch-gates: a cap-killed battery exits 2 from the wrapper's signal branch, so --ran accounts the kill as a RUN with a failing code rather than NOT MEASURED #18267 fix(pm): the dispatch-gates gate kill branch exits 3, so its code says what its text says #18271 842fa040f87aafb2b6a88d1c04bb996466d90999 at 2026-09-15T06:45Z (record 5675514576 PASS, ACCEPT 5675514784, provenance 5675614849; landing record posted 2026-09-15T06:46Z) · [finding] os-dev.md: the os-dev-report comment carries no session id by contract, so the re-keyed H64 files every dev report as unattributed seat content #18264 docs(agents): the os-dev terminal report carries its own session id #18273 9fa9955ab450a8ecfdfa6512d4b6a56e4f3547f7 at 2026-09-15T07:18Z (governed; APPROVED by os-zhuang 5206596891, ruling-C provenance at 2026-09-15T06:59Z; landing record posted 2026-09-15T07:23Z) · the platform-readings fold [finding] platform-readings: a phrase that only exists after joining (string concatenation, markdown emphasis, a wrapped line) reads 0 under a single-line grep in both directions — the instrument row PR #18194 could not fit into the rules layer #18195 [finding] platform-readings: write identity is a per-session credential shape — installation → claude[bot], user-to-server → the human login with performed_via_github_app: claude; GET /user answers the human login in BOTH, so it is not the probe #18158 [finding] MCP search_issues DID honour GitHub qualifiers (repo: is: label:) in two exact readings — the ledger's "qualifier form returns total_count 0" rule needs a second session before it stands or falls #16762 [finding] issue 的 comments 字段可读出 1 而 list 与 timeline 两条通道都读 0 —— 可复现,带四张对照 #18219 [finding] platform-readings: a suspended account's EVENTS are erased with its content (labels stay, the labeled actor is gone) — and the one variable shared by the two suspended triage accounts is the hourly periodic-burst shape, not volume #18147 [finding] a PCRE negative lookahead followed by a character class silently loses its through the GitHub comment API — the published command then errors to stderr and prints 0, which reads as a clean absence #18258 [finding] objectui CI concurrency is keyed on the PR number, so re-running a superseded head cancels the current head — a re-run is a write, not a read #18262 pm-dispatch: six measured platform readings, and the search_issues qualifier rows rewritten onto what is measured #18279 9ed3f167bc28eb12131851b8b9e32e8ecc59bf99 at 2026-09-15T08:07Z (references tier + scripts/pm/**, in-seat; record 5676604220, ACCEPT 5676604957 after patch round 1, provenance 5676662783; landing record 5676916965 on the anchor, one-line records on the six members; the squash closed all seven by Fixes) · [finding] post-stamped: a malformed WAS token (non-timestamp payload) is neither rendered nor refused — the raw token and its payload are stored verbatim #18284 fix(pm): post-stamped refuses a token it cannot render #18286 499f7f9e9766f264db7eddbb0ca197805b2fa7d0 at 2026-09-15T09:06Z (non-governed; record 5677397822, ACCEPT, provenance; three landing readings — the log, the queue ref gone under the register's spelling, the merged_at event; landing record posted 2026-09-15T09:07Z) · the second platform-readings fold [finding] platform-readings :385–:386 say the ledger's mustName is not exclusive and the count line can only be hand-followed — false once PR #18244 (the statesTheSet census for #17798) lands #18248 [finding] platform-readings: in a merge-queue repository the squash commit's committer date is the ENQUEUE instant, not the landing — merged_at and the merged event carry the fast-forward #18274 [finding] platform-readings: the row saying check:pm-dispatch-gates EXCEEDS the 600 s foreground cap was measured under it three times (432–436 s) on one box — the basis is conditional, the detach prescription stands #18283 pm-dispatch: three measured readings — the statesTheSet census, the enqueue instant, and the battery's cap-sized runtime #18287 bda3a60c2b7bd4618cb978476eb31e5893f31aea at 2026-09-15T09:20Z (references tier + scripts/pm/**, in-seat; record 5677334553, ACCEPT 5677335133, provenance; three readings; landing record 5677808667 on the chain head, one-line records on the members; the squash closed all three by Fixes) · [finding] dispatch-gates.mjs header still says the battery runs longer than the container's foreground cap — the sibling header corrected its basis, this one did not #18288 docs(pm): dispatch-gates header states the battery's cap basis as its sibling does #18291 0865f4144354cdb229e46c8aeb892a113ac7ad6a at 2026-09-15T09:44Z (non-governed, comment-only; record 5677599609, ACCEPT, provenance; three readings; landing record posted 2026-09-15T09:46Z) · [finding] post-stamped: a quoted stamp that matches the digit shape but names an impossible instant (month 13, day 45, 99:99) is rendered verbatim — the direction rule reads a NaN date as 「not future」 #18289 fix(pm): post-stamped refuses a quoted stamp that names no real instant #18292 3964efb2e3081fed7aa9321f95d3e36a15becb4d at 2026-09-15T10:20Z (non-governed; record 5678109551, ACCEPT, provenance; three readings; landing record posted 2026-09-15T10:21Z) · [finding] post-stamped: the unread-knock check's lastWriteStamp parses a rolled-over stamp to a LATER instant, so a knock inside the gap reads 「none-newer」 and the refresh voids it — the header's 「lower bound, never fewer」 promise is broken #18293 fix(pm): post-stamped's unread-knock check never narrows on a stamp that names no instant #18294 5a18f32e6a48573b3fb3feb7f47c0ce40518b4ba at 2026-09-15T11:15Z (non-governed; record 5678972520, ACCEPT, provenance; three readings; landing record posted 2026-09-15T11:16Z) · [finding] post-stamped: the ack-not-newest refusal counts 「0 comment(s) landed after」 the acknowledged id when two comments share one created_at — the count contradicts its own refusal #18295 fix(pm): post-stamped counts a same-second later comment as after the acknowledged one #18297 99d20cfdb63a3b098a86ba3f132be2feb82b683a at 2026-09-15T12:08Z (non-governed; record 5679503885, ACCEPT 5679504453, provenance; ready + auto-merge SQUASH through the CCR route at 2026-09-15T11:51Z, merged_at 17 min later; three readings; landing record 5679917857 posted 2026-09-15T12:09Z) · [finding] post-stamped: readBackVerdict compares stored to sent byte-for-byte, so the platform's trailing-newline strip (and the footer append on comments) reads as 「the platform MUTATED the body」 on nearly every write — the one warning meant for the sanitizer is now noise #18296 fix(pm): post-stamped names the platform's known read-back normalisations and locates a real mutation #18298 827cacbf4b79088926f98bba25cccfb0f369ebbc at 2026-09-15T13:13Z (non-governed; the dev verified the seat's three mechanism readings — comment POST verbatim + 58-byte footer TRUE with a refinement (a sent body already carrying the footer reads back as the strip), body-mode strip confirmed on the adjacent PR-create channel, the footer-less issue-body cell UNMEASURED and therefore comment-only in the classifier; record 5680375613 PASS (edited once, see the harness reading below), ACCEPT 5680376047, provenance 5680468820; ready + auto-merge SQUASH at 2026-09-15T12:51Z, merged_at 21 min later; three readings; landing record 5680764289 posted 2026-09-15T13:13Z — the first artefact this seat wrote with the landed tool, whose own read-back line read 「clean — the platform appended its footer (sent 1442, stored 1500)」 where every earlier write of the shift read 「MUTATED」) · finding(settings): permissions.deny omits mcp__github__update_pull_request — an MCP content write (title/body/draft) the charter now declares closed, and the seat's ready-flip fallback names the same tool #18218 fix(settings,pm-dispatch): deny mcp__github__update_pull_request and route the ready flip through the CCR routes #18276 53dd5aaaafbe877a1cc72aef26511bd15c927ecf at 2026-09-15T15:14Z (governed rules layer — .claude/settings.json deny of mcp__github__update_pull_request + SKILL.md :622 + rest-channel :53; APPROVED by os-zhuang 5211697198 at 2026-09-15T14:54Z, who flipped it ready and enqueued it in the same stroke; the seat cleared needs-user-decision, read --pair 18276 0 and the checks 18 / 16, ruling-C provenance 5682476754; three readings; landing record 5682817960 posted 2026-09-15T15:16Z) · [finding] settings lock 1: no gate pins permissions.deny to the MCP write-tool roster the charter's ACCEPT refusal names — declared vs enforced is reconciled by hand #18281 feat(pm): a gate pins permissions.deny to the charter's content-write roster #18285 52c1a8c4af411ce759158bd938474903d42dc6b2 at 2026-09-15T16:07Z (non-governed; the deny-roster gate check-settings-deny-roster.mjs + package.json + lint.yml; record 5676984841, ACCEPT 2026-09-15T08:15Z; serial behind PR fix(settings,pm-dispatch): deny mcp__github__update_pull_request and route the ready flip through the CCR routes #18276 origin/main taken in through update-branch at 2026-09-15T15:16Z, ready + auto-merge SQUASH at 2026-09-15T15:42Z, provenance 5683278669; three readings; landing record 5683696518 posted 2026-09-15T16:08Z; the gate reads 15 = 15 on main) · [finding] platform-readings: four rows describe MCP update_pull_request as a live channel after lock 1 denies it (:43 · :46 · :47 · :338), plus the PR-body second-footer reading #18280 docs(pm): platform-readings retires the rows that still describe MCP update_pull_request as a live channel #18307 6ef331280b1b847ed333aed7ee41b97173ffe337 at 2026-09-15T16:12Z (references tier; rows :43 / :44 / :46 / :47 / :345 of platform-readings retired or re-keyed as facts about a denied tool, 466 → 465; record 5683210811, ACCEPT 5683211255, provenance 5683429173; three readings; landing record 5683777652 posted 2026-09-15T16:13Z) · finding(pm): 「简报写明本轮跑的层」is declared in SKILL.md and read by nothing — enforce-or-remove #18302 feat(pm): the half-state patrol reads the tier a triage round artefact names #18311 10a7b9faa286c39d63500b32f0f45da357123686 at 2026-09-15T16:24Z (non-governed; H65 in check-half-states.mjs — a triage round artefact naming no Tier: is a report-only half-state, judged on the triage post's NEWEST comment page; self-test 4196; record 5683456149, ACCEPT 5683456688, provenance 5683607305; three readings; landing record 5683963000 posted 2026-09-15T16:25Z; the triage seat clears the row by one Tier: line per round artefact) · [finding] platform-readings: three rows of the PR-body footer block still read the denied MCP update_pull_request wrapper as a live edit channel (:347 · :348 · :354 on the PR #18307 head) #18310 docs(pm): platform-readings reads the denied MCP wrapper's footer rows as history #18316 82b3032c475cfe9fab9dd6238d1cc8d7aa93e4a7 at 2026-09-15T17:14Z (references tier; platform-readings :347 / :348 retired, :354 re-keyed, 465 → 463; record 5684245590, ACCEPT 5684246093, provenance 5684419649; ready + auto-merge SQUASH at 2026-09-15T16:55Z; three readings; landing record 5684707250 posted 2026-09-15T17:15Z) · [finding] check-half-states: H44's seat leg is blind on the triage seat post it was written for — its corpus is the thread's FIRST comment page (oldest-first, five weeks stale on #6015) and H44_ROUND_OPEN_MARKER no longer matches the marker spelling; H56 / H64 share the corpus #18312 fix(pm): the half-state patrol reads a seat post's NEWEST comment page, and H44 knows the current marker spelling #18322 a46cd8c4a6592ef2f0790f7adfab8eabcd3b33a5 at 2026-09-15T17:55Z (non-governed; the seat-post NEWEST-page memo seatPostRowsFor + H44's marker spelling through H65's shapes; record 5684896900, ACCEPT 5684897383, provenance 5685011685; ready + auto-merge SQUASH at 2026-09-15T17:34Z, merged_at 21 min later; three readings; landing record 5685322122 posted 2026-09-15T17:57Z) · [finding] check-half-states: H44_READING_TIMESTAMP rejects a minute-precision ISO stamp — the T before the hour is a word character, so the word-boundary anchor fails and the ruled spelling 2026-03T00:21Z itself reads false #18323 fix(pm): H44's timestamp leg accepts an ISO instant whose hour follows a T — the ruled minute spelling no longer reads as untimestamped #18326 de9c319aed53d20af915560374e6af598c1c6946 at 2026-09-15T18:56Z (non-governed; H44_READING_TIMESTAMP admits the ISO T by a non-consuming look-behind, self-test 4235 → 4243; record 5685923189, ACCEPT 5685923716, provenance 5685956635; ready + auto-merge SQUASH at 2026-09-15T18:35Z, merged_at 21 min later; three readings; landing record 5686346797 posted 2026-09-15T18:57Z) · the fold [finding] check-half-states: H44's seat leg cannot reach the triage seat post it was written for whenever that seat is 🟢 Routine or vacant — h44NeedsSeatComments requires seatIsHeld, so the newest-page window is inert on #6015 until a session holds the seat #18324 [finding] check-half-states: H32 and H38 read a seat post's OLDEST comment page for the one reading that must be the newest — latestSeatMarker returns the newest row OF THE FIRST PAGE, which on a 225-comment post is an August comment, and that is H32's idle clock and H38's T_seat #18325 fix(pm): the half-state patrol's seat legs read the triage post and the newest page — H44 reaches a vacant or Routine seat, H32 / H38 take their marker from the last page #18332 a09725ddef3c60b92fff87d3633046da8de1f48e at 2026-09-15T20:04Z (non-governed; H44's seat leg reaches the triage post whatever its holder through h65IsTriageSeatPost beside the held leg — option A, zero added requests; H32 / H38 take their seat marker and T_seat from the NEWEST page through the shared memo; self-test 4243 → 4270; record 5687020469, ACCEPT 5687020859 on the chain head, member record 5687021250, provenance 5687138688; ready + auto-merge SQUASH at 2026-09-15T19:46Z, merged_at 17 min later; three readings; landing records 5687342171 / 5687342442 posted 2026-09-15T20:04Z) · [Decision] AGENTS.md's comment rule vs preserved verbatim maintainer rulings that contain a model identifier — carve out quotations (A), treat them as violations (B), or leave it undecided (C) #18092 docs(agents): the comment rule exempts a verbatim maintainer ruling preserved as a quotation block #18315 a23035c3a9c66fb236493d52580b40c370d8e852 at 2026-09-16T02:08Z (governed AGENTS.md :441–:444; APPROVED by os-zhuang 5217668792 at 2026-09-16T01:52Z, who flipped it ready and enqueued it; the seat cleared needs-user-decision, ruling-C provenance 5690836932; three readings; landing record 5690953559 posted 2026-09-16T02:09Z) · [finding] 两份已发布 skills 仍教 before* 钩子整批触发,并推销一个没有生产者的诊断(HookConditionLimitation) #18221 docs(skills): before* hooks on a predicate write dispatch per row — the two published skills stop teaching a batch dispatch and a retired guard #18328 fae612a5a5a999292c17b8cc1f5442edee701d8f at 2026-09-16T02:13Z (governed skills/** ×2 — the published skills teach per-row before*; APPROVED 5217676382; provenance 5690856540; landing record 5690988804 posted 2026-09-16T02:14Z) · On a shallow checkout git log -1 -- <path> names a commit that never touched the path — measured: the seating charter reading returned a real sha from an unrelated driver-test commit #18180 fix(pm): the charter latest-touch reading is taken depth-independently — a shallow clone's git log names a commit that never touched the path #18327 0cc5ce856b98d7f9cd4666aada2e801e751d98ce at 2026-09-16T02:14Z (governed SKILL.md :89 + git-history.mjs touch; APPROVED 5217673315; provenance 5690856345; landing record 5691005304 posted 2026-09-16T02:16Z; the tool answers 0cc5ce85 for SKILL.md on the shared checkout without a fetch) · [Decision] permissions.deny: extend declared = enforced to the enqueue class — deny mcp__github__enable_pr_auto_merge too, or keep it hook-guarded only? #18282 fix(settings,pm): deny the MCP enqueue class — enable/disable_pr_auto_merge join lock 1 and the roster gate #18317 ceb6b5fb46abcd… at 2026-09-16T02:16Z (governed .claude/settings.json +2 denies, the roster gate 17 = 17 on main, rest-channel :53; APPROVED 5217679727; the head's one stale Check Changeset red was the pre-label run, the queue accepted the entry; provenance 5690861787; landing record 5691031906 posted 2026-09-16T02:19Z); every residue stripped and read back; the four were one queue chain, merged_at 02:08 / 02:13 / 02:14 / 02:16 · [finding] check-harness-current.mjs prints the graft boundary as a harness path's latest touch on a shallow checkout — the CURRENT / STALE verdict holds by construction, but the printed sha is not a reading of the path #18330 fix(pm): check-harness-current prints boundary, not a fabricated sha, when a harness path's latest touch is not provable on the shallow checkout #18352 1411cf2c6fd2c9e695682416c9e655869945f531 at 2026-09-16T03:12Z (non-governed scripts/pm/check-harness-current.mjs: prints boundary with the graft mechanism named, or unprovable, in place of a sha it cannot prove, through PR fix(pm): the charter latest-touch reading is taken depth-independently — a shallow clone's git log names a commit that never touched the path #18327 [finding] platform-readings: four rows describe MCP enable_pr_auto_merge / disable_pr_auto_merge behaviour a seat can no longer reach once lock 1 denies the enqueue class (:41 · :49 · :58 · :60) #18320 [finding] the seat's REST writes now land as a USER account, not claude[bot] — the durability premise in platform-readings, #6015 and every Routine prompt is falsified #18334 docs(pm): platform-readings retires the denied enqueue tool's rows and reads the REST token class per write, not per session #18359 b57671edc1166d49be40993000894128b3a63b44 at 2026-09-16T04:18Z (references tier, platform-readings.md only: the denied enqueue tool's four rows retired or re-keyed tool-neutral, the token-class rows re-keyed as seven — the class follows the Claude Code account, both dated flips, read on every write's read-back, the author-bound consequence; record 5691731467, ACCEPT 5691731638, the fold pointer 5691731802; ready + auto-merge through the CCR routes at 2026-09-16T03:58Z; provenance 5691817785; three readings; landing records 5691973200 / 5691973372 posted 2026-09-16T04:19Z); every residue stripped and read back. Queue reading 2026-09-15T06:29Z: the groups were chained pr-18244 → pr-18250 → pr-18256 → pr-18271 → pr-18272 (another lane's); each group's Lint & Repo Gates job runs 178 gate steps in ~30 min (the PM dispatch-gates self-test step alone 520–540 s); Queue refs: served under the register's spelling (:154) — measured 2026-09-15T09:00Z, two refs, the second chained on the first's group commit; from now on landing records read the ref AND the merged_at instant. Timers: NONE at sign-off — the patrol Routine and the accelerator were deleted (hand-off checklist step 6); the previous session's PR subscriptions on the four hung PRs are the only standing wake. Lane baseline this shift: dispatch → draft PR 20–66 min, report 1–18 min after the PR; ACCEPT → enqueue 5–20 min (CI-bound); enqueue → merged_at 15–26 min for a lone entry, longer behind a chain. Maintainer ask carried from the finding(pm): 「简报写明本轮跑的层」is declared in SKILL.md and read by nothing — enforce-or-remove #18302 Tier: spelling belongs in the runbook's brief template on all four axes, but dispatch-runbook.md (241/241) and SKILL.md (812/812) have zero ratchet headroom — the seat holds A (the H65 remedy text is the spelling's home) and asks the maintainer for one of B (name a redundant runbook line to pay) or C (raise the runbook ceiling by one, ruling quoted in the PR); the seat deletes no runbook rule on its own judgment. Harness reading (seat-side, not the register) 2026-09-15T12:45Z: the seat's command layer decodes a backslash-u-hex escape into the character before the shell sees it — a six-character U+FFFD escape typed into a quoted heredoc arrived on disk as the literal replacement character while a backslash-n in the same heredoc survived — so the record on PR fix(pm): post-stamped names the platform's known read-back normalisations and locates a real mutation #18298 <the replacement character>」; repaired in place with an edit note (the platform had stored exactly what was sent), and the seat types no backslash-u escape into a body it means to store verbatim.State corrections at seating (2026-09-15T02:07Z–2026-09-15T02:23Z): [finding] AGENTS.md states the merge queue's required set as six contexts and calls the rest advisory — it is seven, and no gate reds on the stale sentence #17798 [finding] Governed Surface Queue Guard is required on main but pinned by no REQUIRED_CONTEXTS row — renaming its job detaches the governed-surface gate silently #15233 共享身份的限流纪律不存在：一次限流信号约束的是「身份」不是「客户端」，而规矩只说了不要重试 —— 2026-09-10 全 fleet 停摆事故 #17374 The M9.1 / M9.2 expression phases — including "ast becomes required in build output" — are asserted in six files and one published docs page, and defined in no ADR #17323 pm:blocked + Blocked-by: #17849, assignee cleared (5673581724) · [finding] MCP search_issues DID honour GitHub qualifiers (repo: is: label:) in two exact readings — the ledger's "qualifier form returns total_count 0" rule needs a second session before it stands or falls #16762 pm:queue (5673700002) · [PM decision] skills lane batch 9 — platform-readings.md third increment: raise the ceiling by the measured +39 (358 → 397); and the MCP write-pool quota sentence collision #15275 [finding] half-state H31 binds a PR to a card by its Part of line, so every correctly-gated epic tracker gets a row telling a seat to hang a gate nothing will clear #18229 [finding] check-clause2-carriers: an unreadable or off-tier Served-tier: line is refused only beside a gate clear (C7) — a non-gated pair with the same record passes exit 0, against contract-review.md :29 「无此行不成裁决」 #18174 finding(agents): .claude/agents/os-dev.md:288 orders the dev seat to hang needs:contract-review on the PR, and the dev's container forbids label writes — measured on two independent runs today #18181 [finding] H64 fires on REST writes that #18205 made correct — its REST implies claude[bot] premise was superseded, and its remedy cannot clear it #18237 class (a): pnpm check:pm-dispatch-gates cannot complete inside the container's ~10-minute foreground cap — measured 9m0s then exit 124, twice; the wall-clock twin of #17708 #18201 [finding] board-snapshot: the archive holds nothing above #17726 — the delta walk sits two days behind the live board while the per-run budget goes to history, so the 2026-09-14 suspension's cards were never captured #18137 [finding] platform-readings: write identity is a per-session credential shape — installation → claude[bot], user-to-server → the human login with performed_via_github_app: claude; GET /user answers the human login in BOTH, so it is not the probe #18158 [finding] platform-readings: a phrase that only exists after joining (string concatenation, markdown emphasis, a wrapped line) reads 0 under a single-line grep in both directions — the instrument row PR #18194 could not fit into the rules layer #18195 finding(settings): permissions.deny omits mcp__github__update_pull_request — an MCP content write (title/body/draft) the charter now declares closed, and the seat's ready-flip fallback names the same tool #18218 [finding] issue 的 comments 字段可读出 1 而 list 与 timeline 两条通道都读 0 —— 可复现,带四张对照 #18219 [finding] check-clause2-carriers: a contract-review record whose head sha shares one code span with its key names NO head (H51_SHA_SPAN), so C6 reads 「no review of record」 where one exists — contract-review.md :28 never says the span holds the sha alone #18141 [finding] platform-readings: the session proxy serves CCR routes on api.github.com for ready-for-review, auto-merge, review threads and resolve — every seat landing action now has a REST spelling authored claude[bot] #18130 [finding] platform-readings: a suspended account's EVENTS are erased with its content (labels stay, the labeled actor is gone) — and the one variable shared by the two suspended triage accounts is the hourly periodic-burst shape, not volume #18147 [finding] a PCRE negative lookahead followed by a character class silently loses its through the GitHub comment API — the published command then errors to stderr and prints 0, which reads as a clean absence #18258 [finding] objectui CI concurrency is keyed on the PR number, so re-running a superseded head cancels the current head — a re-run is a write, not a read #18262 [finding] platform-readings: in a merge-queue repository the squash commit's committer date is the ENQUEUE instant, not the landing — merged_at and the merged event carry the fast-forward #18274 [finding] 「内容恒经 REST 代理(claude[bot])」 — the App IS the writer (performed_via_github_app: claude), but it uses a user-to-server token, so every seat write is bylined to a User account #18168 docs(pm,agents): write identity follows the channel, not the account — REST-only content writes, the ACCEPT refuses MCP writes, a stale shared checkout re-seats (#18205) #18216 finding(pm-readings): the container REST proxy token is user-to-server in this session shape — seat writes land as the bound GitHub user via app claude, not as claude[bot]; the fact table and the write-identity invariant read true where they are false #18197 docs(pm,agents): write identity follows the channel, not the account — REST-only content writes, the ACCEPT refuses MCP writes, a stale shared checkout re-seats (#18205) #18216 [finding] ccr/auto_merge stores merge_method: "merge" whatever you send — and names a method this repo forbids, so the documented read-back lands on a false alarm #18127 finding(pm-dispatch): the dispatch order tells a dev never to touch a PR label while the same dispatch and the standing clause require hanging needs:contract-review — two devs adjudicated it independently in one round; and the clause asks the dev for a --pair exit code only the seat can produce #18156 finding(agents): .claude/agents/os-dev.md:288 orders the dev seat to hang needs:contract-review on the PR, and the dev's container forbids label writes — measured on two independent runs today #18181 [finding] six more rules-layer sentences still state the retired human-merge ending after PR #18182 — SKILL.md :610 (two endings), :622/:672 + core-rules :128 (round-report item), AGENTS.md :255 (governed-prose anchor) / :799, the queue guard's refusal text #18185 [finding] check-governed-merges.mjs :140 and check-required-contexts.mjs :288 still narrate one terminal — 「a human merge IS the review record」 — without ruling C's second (authorized approval ⇒ the claiming seat lands) #18150 finding(platform-readings): a PR-body PATCH carrying the Claude Code footer stores TWO footers on objectui, while the create path stores one — the fact table has no line for the edit path #18249 [finding] platform reading: the PR-BODY create and edit cells disagree on footer appending over the same REST channel #18254 finding(platform-readings): a PR-body PATCH carrying the Claude Code footer stores TWO footers on objectui, while the create path stores one — the fact table has no line for the edit path #18249 Queue (pm:queue, this lane, unassigned) at this refresh, in total order — 13 : the snapshot with serial constraints is in the 接任台账 above ([finding] guard-governed-enqueue's slug reader keeps a .git suffix — a sibling cloned with the conventional URL never resolves, and a bare gh pr merge N on such a clone derives a slug the API 404s on, so the guard fails OPEN #18366 [cloud] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17163 [finding] objectui's half-state findings reach no reader: the board has no anchor by ruling, and its copy of check-half-states still refuses in agent containers with the conclusion #13544 disproved #18290 [finding] post-stamped | tail -N && label-write silently breaks the comment-before-label pairing — the pipeline returns tail's 0, so a REFUSED comment still lets the label land #18337 [finding] REST 写侧强制头 Content-Type 的规则只住在 platform-readings.md —— 「动手前查一行」的 rest-channel.md 写侧段零提及、零交叉引用,一个班次内三席踩中 #18339 [finding] rest-channel :54 still says the REST actor is 「按会话」 claude[bot] or a user — the token class follows the Claude Code account and flipped inside one session twice; one in-place re-key pointing at the fact table #18360 ADR-0135 的两处过期物随 #14361 的 Fixes 一起消失:Consequences 的 Until then 前件已过,:63 的 grep 配方读起来像通用总体筛而两个方向各错(本席自己误用两次) #18345 [finding] git-history.mjs touchIsProvable reports boundary: false for a registered graft boundary whose parent has since been fetched — the refusal is right, the flag and the reason text are wrong #18355 Wire check-harness-current.mjs --self-test (PR #18352) into lint.yml's shallow-history self-test collector — a self-test nobody runs is the injury check-self-test-wired exists for #18356 Wire pnpm check:pm-expected-skips (PR #18357) into lint.yml beside the other check:pm-* steps — a self-test no workflow names is outside check-self-test-wired's population #18358 [finding] platform-readings :134 / :143 list the draft flip and the auto-merge mount as GraphQL-only and stand a seat down for them in a rate-limit window — both have live ccr routes, the only routes since lock 1 #18361 platform-readings 的 detach 处方没说 pid 从哪来 —— 用 pgrep -f 重新推导会自匹配到包装器自己,监视器永远等自己 #18362 [finding] guard-governed-enqueue's 「no checkout available」 fail-open is pinned by no self-test case in any environment — the case that claimed it never reaches it; one hermetic case with the injected empty root #18367 [www.objectos.ai] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17165 pm:awaiting-maintainer (moved by the triage seat at 2026-09-15T14:59Z). [finding] a PCRE negative lookahead followed by a character class silently loses its through the GitHub comment API — the published command then errors to stderr and prints 0, which reads as a clean absence #18258 ! through the comment and issue write APIs — reproduced LIVE on this post's own body PATCH at 2026-09-15T06:04Z, so the spelling is not written here) and [finding] objectui CI concurrency is keyed on the PR number, so re-running a superseded head cancels the current head — a re-run is a write, not a read #18262 Blocked / hold / box : pm:blocked — skills: evaluate whether the published security/platform guidance must teach the app-capability vs system-permission distinction and the isDefault → everyone binding rule (after #17189) #17359 An app-declared capability with scope: 'org' counts as a high-privilege bit, so a set carrying only app capability tokens cannot bind to the everyone anchor #17189 pm:awaiting-maintainer) · hotcrm has no half-state patrol anchor, so the pm:dispatched + assignee residue after a Fixes auto-close has now been repaired by hand seven rounds running #14881 [repo:hotcrm] Install the half-state patrol in hotcrm — workflow copy, anchor issue, repository variable (hotcrm half of the ruled 纳入) #15009 The M9.1 / M9.2 expression phases — including "ast becomes required in build output" — are asserted in six files and one published docs page, and defined in no ADR #17323 Drop the M9.1 / M9.2 phase language from packages/spec and packages/formula (the spec-seat half of #17323, ruled B) #17849 pm:on-hold: none. Decision box (this lane): 0 — [Decision] AGENTS.md's comment rule vs preserved verbatim maintainer rulings that contain a model identifier — carve out quotations (A), treat them as violations (B), or leave it undecided (C) #18092 [Decision] permissions.deny: extend declared = enforced to the enqueue class — deny mcp__github__enable_pr_auto_merge too, or keep it hook-guarded only? #18282 pm:awaiting-maintainer: [Decision] 22 pure-objectui defect cards live in objectstack under repo:objectui, but objectui IS reachable — the seam fallback is being used where its precondition does not hold #17250 PM corpus audit (maintainer-directed): classify every instruction line — keep / duplicate / demote / delete — then rewrite and re-lock every ratchet #13597 Published-skills factual sweep: verify every behavioral claim in skills/** against the implementation — program anchor #13658 pm:epic) · Skills catalog optimization program (maintainer-directed): audit every skill on both roots, then optimize — program anchor #14292 [program] CLAUDE.md is a pointer to AGENTS.md in every repo — no second instruction set to maintain (maintainer 2026-09-09) #17161 gate: extend ADR maintainer approval path predicate to .claude/skills/** — make Prime Directive #14 enforced (#9319 ruling) #9395 pm:retriage (A/B/C put to the maintainer 5661132913, unanswered).Maintainer items open (report only) : hotlong's APPROVED on the FOUR hung governed PRs — PR docs(agents): criterion ③'s test is scoped to the branch's own commits — the unranged git log walked all of main and made force-with-lease dead letter #18351 fix(pm): the enqueue bar names expected skips — a path-filtered job's skip is not a failure, and a check reports the skips outside the declared roster #18357 docs(pm): the clause-② contract review is tier-bound — the dispatching seat reviews in-seat at CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER, no seat list #18363 fix(hooks): guard-governed-enqueue's sibling-checkout lookup is injectable, so its self-test is hermetic on a box that carries the sibling #18365 gen-sdui-manifest.sh hardcodes port 5180 and one log path, so two concurrent runs in a container can dump the OTHER run's server #9578 post-stamped.mjs uses, which the [Self-Approval] classifier has never refused for this seat; the write identity behind this seat is now os-zhuang's user authorization (the maintainer's own account swap, confirmed on the direct channel at 2026-09-16T02:16Z) — an approver account writing every seat artefact; the seat asked for a dedicated low-privilege GitHub user (or the App installation token) behind seat sessions and answers with the mechanics in the round report; the clause-② ruling 「同意」 is on [finding] Clause-②: yes on a non-spec, non-skills lane — the protocol says the contract-review-tier review is the spec seat's, but spells no handoff (who is asked, by which artefact), so a lane seat reaches for an in-seat PASS the harness classifier then refuses as self-approval #18349 the board archive holds 17 records the live board no longer has — scheduled run 46 of board-snapshot (2026-09-15T02:31Z) is RED at exit 2, count_check.verdict = surplus (board 519 / archive 536), the tool's destruction signature, consistent with the 2026-09-14 suspension; the seat's grading correction on [finding] board-snapshot: the archive holds nothing above #17726 — the delta walk sits two days behind the live board while the per-run budget goes to history, so the 2026-09-14 suspension's cards were never captured #18137 surplus as the healthy state (corrected on the card 5675369063); the decision is the maintainer's — --restore=N prints them back, a gone.json ledger entry quiets the red; the account this seat runs under is an approver account (os-zhuang) — writes read back claude[bot] until 2026-09-15T20:04Z and os-zhuang from 2026-09-16T01:53Z, the assignee field and GET /user os-zhuang throughout; the fleet's GitHub identity (three routes in brief 5673402511 §4); the maintainer-level deny lever; the two permissions.allow script rules; [Decision] 22 pure-objectui defect cards live in objectstack under repo:objectui, but objectui IS reachable — the seam fallback is being used where its precondition does not hold #17250 [finding] board-snapshot: the archive holds nothing above #17726 — the delta walk sits two days behind the live board while the per-run budget goes to history, so the 2026-09-14 suspension's cards were never captured #18137 gate: extend ADR maintainer approval path predicate to .claude/skills/** — make Prime Directive #14 enforced (#9319 ruling) #9395 session_01VxjMEAhT53WHUCtP9WMrSU stood down at 2026-09-15T15:54Z on a harness-STALE reading (brief 5683457248, ⛔ not a maintainer order; [PM seat] triage (objectstack-wide) — 🟢 在席 session_01WDxrLMPs5TyKB45RPiJuLo · R+244 · harness **CURRENT** · 写入身份 os-sam(User)六轮稳定 · ⭐ **pm:retriage 两仓清零** · 本轮:objectui#6653 改造为先测量 · #7997 关 completed → 残余立 #9593 · 更正本席 #18362 的行号漂移 · 欠账:objectui ①50/④34/finding 39 · objectstack ①31/③7+16/finding 35 · 决策箱 1(#18364 待一个字母)· ⚠️ #18172 仍是唯一 p1 · ⚠️ objectui domain:ui 席 #5560 因同一 harness STALE 于 04:45Z 收班 #6015 check-harness-current.mjs reads CURRENT): bare census 45 of 508 open at 2026-09-15T17:31Z; graded into this lane by SUBJECT — [finding] the enqueue bar 「每一个 check 全绿」 is unsatisfiable as written — every landing carries 7-10 skipped checks, and nothing distinguishes an expected skip from a path-filter miss #18308 On a shallow checkout git log -1 -- <path> names a commit that never touched the path — measured: the seating charter reading returned a real sha from an unrelated driver-test commit #18180 [finding] 两份已发布 skills 仍教 before* 钩子整批触发,并推销一个没有生产者的诊断(HookConditionLimitation) #18221 AGENTS.md §3 criterion ③ tests the branch's WHOLE ancestry, so --force-with-lease is dead letter for every branch cut from main (measured: 33 pairs vs 1 scoped; control: main itself reads 32) #18178 [finding] objectui's half-state findings reach no reader: the board has no anchor by ruling, and its copy of check-half-states still refuses in agent containers with the conclusion #13544 disproved #18290 platform-readings: an absent merge-queue ref is not a negative enqueue reading — auto_merge reads null after a successful CCR arm #17958 rest-channel.md overstates the ccr auto_merge body: the endpoint ignores merge_method (stores merge either spelling) and the queue decides the method — the wording invites a forbidden re-arm #18167 [finding] ccr/auto_merge stores merge_method: "merge" whatever you send — and names a method this repo forbids, so the documented read-back lands on a false alarm #18127 merge either spelling」 clause is refuted by this seat's arm of PR fix(pm): the half-state patrol reads a seat post's NEWEST comment page, and H44 knows the current marker spelling #18322 squash; the register keys on the timeline event, never the echo); finding dropped at grading on [finding] the enqueue bar 「每一个 check 全绿」 is unsatisfiable as written — every landing carries 7-10 skipped checks, and nothing distinguishes an expected skip from a path-filter miss #18308 [finding] 两份已发布 skills 仍教 before* 钩子整批触发,并推销一个没有生产者的诊断(HookConditionLimitation) #18221 [finding] objectui's half-state findings reach no reader: the board has no anchor by ruling, and its copy of check-half-states still refuses in agent containers with the conclusion #13544 disproved #18290 [finding] the enqueue bar 「每一个 check 全绿」 is unsatisfiable as written — every landing carries 7-10 skipped checks, and nothing distinguishes an expected skip from a path-filter miss #18308 On a shallow checkout git log -1 -- <path> names a commit that never touched the path — measured: the seating charter reading returned a real sha from an unrelated driver-test commit #18180 b3b43b6 as the TIP, not as SKILL.md's touch (that was 8c657f7, true), and git show --stat on a graft boundary prints the WHOLE file against the empty tree — the seat's zero was a grep for the full path against an abbreviated stat line; the defect stands on the boundary reading (9b00f9f for lanes/skills.md). Two more bare cards filed by this seat for triage, NOT this lane's: [finding] measure-self-test-floor.mjs refuses to print any census on current main — its recogniser reads two landed handshake spellings as absent, so the instrument cannot answer the floor question anyone runs it for #18329 measure-self-test-floor.mjs refuses its census on main — two landed handshake spellings unrecognised; from the [finding] check-half-states: H44_READING_TIMESTAMP rejects a minute-precision ISO stamp — the T before the hour is a word character, so the word-boundary anchor fails and the ruled spelling 2026-03T00:21Z itself reads false #18323 [finding] objectql hook-wrappers.ts: two docblocks still state the retired batch model for the before* dispatch of a predicate write in the present tense, while the code beneath binds per row #18331 objectql/src/hook-wrappers.ts docblocks :1083 / :1177 still state the retired batch before* model — same family as objectql's engine docblock still states the RETIRED per-row previous rule — and it ships in the published .d.ts, so the next spec release makes two packages state opposite contracts #17975 [finding] 两份已发布 skills 仍教 before* 钩子整批触发,并推销一个没有生产者的诊断(HookConditionLimitation) #18221 [finding] CLOUD_PROVIDED_OBJECT_NAMES misses sys_environment_credential (cloud DOES register it), and the spec still declares sys_tenant_database (cloud does NOT) #18309 把两个未接线的门禁接到 CI:check-issue-citations(diff 域裁决进 lint.yml 阻塞 + --census 进 half-state-patrol 只报告)与 check:merged-result(lint.yml 一条步骤) #18224 check-issue-citations — .github/workflows/**, devx / ci) · spec: export a typed hook ctx.api (HookApi / HookObjectApi / HookQuery) — every metadata app hand-declares it today #18163 ctx.api) · [finding] the liveness governance denominator is built from listMetadataTypeSchemaTypes(), so report.ungoverned structurally cannot name connector, sharing_rule or analytics_cube — the same sentence #17356 falsified, one gate over #18133 [finding] a nested RETIRED_KEYS_BY_MAJOR row is unverifiable — check (b2) passes a fabricated one, so a typo'd nested retirement registers silently and forever #17969 RETIRED_KEYS_BY_MAJOR check) · [finding] Check Changeset fails with an entirely empty check-run output, so two different refusals are indistinguishable from the API #18263 [finding] ruling G item 6's third surface has no platform half: _status carries no reason, so a policy-disabled flow is indistinguishable from a broken binding — and objectui#9217 is blocked on a card that does not exist #18235 [finding] check-widening-tells C5: narrowing a Zod key OUT of z.unknown() fires T1 when the new value opens z.union( and declines when it does not — #17618's three-fact spend cannot express "the removed value accepted everything" #18234 [finding] after #18230, service-analytics keeps a second refusal wording whose only stated justification is gone — the #5240 one-condition-one-wording convention #18232 消融变异该走校验锚点的替换助手 —— perl -i 家族已在两次被记录的消融里静默失败,模式各不相同 #18226 [finding] 根 manifest 里 12 个 check:* 门禁没有任何 workflow 或聚合脚本调用 —— 它们从不运行,而绿 CI 读作合规 #18225 [finding] tenant-audit 普查器的 ERROR 方向送不到 CI —— 门禁一次都没读 unledgered / staleLedgerRows #18211 [finding] eslint.config.mjs 用一句今天为假的实测句给 query-options-erasure 的 SCOPE 做正当性说明 —— objectql 的 typecheck 有第三条腿 #18210 class (c): a dotted messages id is authorable, schema-valid and resolves to nothing — and TranslationItemSchema's own @example teaches it, at two sites #18190 contract(spec): should dependsOn be authorable on a bulk action param? BulkActionParamSchema is not strict, so its accept is a null reading — and toBulkParam never consults the field defs, so the one spelling the renderer honours cannot reach the surface #18177 [finding] check (c) has no proof shape for a strict-schema guidance retirement — on a reachable def such a key can never prove itself, and it passed only because proof 2 was broken #18132 spec: the padded grouping-field refusal is trim-equivalence under UNICODE whitespace, but its .describe()/docs/ADR entry all say just "whitespace" #17962 openapi-self-consistency.test.ts is a false red in any /tmp-rooted worktree — pnpm relative symlinks resolve through /tmp #17961 [finding] seed-loader-state-machine-exempt.test.ts tells a future debugger to revert a flag that PR #17718 removes from SEED_OPTIONS #17938 [finding] objectui's half-state findings reach no reader: the board has no anchor by ruling, and its copy of check-half-states still refuses in agent containers with the conclusion #13544 disproved #18290 docs(agents): the comment rule exempts a verbatim maintainer ruling preserved as a quotation block #18315 fix(settings,pm): deny the MCP enqueue class — enable/disable_pr_auto_merge join lock 1 and the roster gate #18317 Governed-merge audit at seating (--since the brief's instant 2026-09-15T01:44Z, run 2026-09-15T01:58Z): objectstack + objectui audited, 0 governed merges; cloud / objectos / hotcrm UNAUDITED (no checkout) — INCOMPLETE. Second audit 2026-09-15T03:56Z, topological --since-ref objectstack=b3b43b6ea0c3 --since-ref objectui=75fca9669a3d: 4 + 4 mainline commits, 0 governed merges, clean. Third audit 2026-09-15T06:31Z, --since-ref objectstack=ecf91cb44194 --since-ref objectui=009f92d7a247: 3 governed merges, all this seat's and each with its record on the PR — pm-dispatch: reconcile the quota rows with the identity-bound rate limit; merged-write rule; account-suspension recovery readings #18242 .claude/** ×3, ruling C after os-zhuang's approval, merged_by os-zhuang), pm(skills): probe the unexercised CCR routes and the shared MCP user bucket into the REST channel register #18259 fix(pm): say the head sha sits in a code span of its own, and name the refused spelling #18270 references/**, in-seat contract-tier review, merged_by claude[bot]); objectui 0. Fourth audit 2026-09-15T07:24Z, --since-ref objectstack=1a02ef17d61b --since-ref objectui=88561fdc4856: 4 governed merges (fix(agents,gates): the merge queue blocks on seven contexts, and a set-stating surface is now a census #18244 docs(agents): the contract-review carrier is the seat's to hang; --pair PR-NUMBER is the only spelling #18250 docs(pm-dispatch): a triage direction landing in an adjudicated area quotes the governing line #18256 docs(agents): the os-dev terminal report carries its own session id #18273 .claude/**), all ruling-C landings after os-zhuang's approvals with their records, merged_by os-zhuang; objectui 0; cloud / objectos / hotcrm unaudited every time (no checkout). Fifth audit 2026-09-15T09:59Z, --since-ref objectstack=9fa9955ab450 --since-ref objectui=88561fdc4856: 2 governed merges (PR pm-dispatch: six measured platform readings, and the search_issues qualifier rows rewritten onto what is measured #18279 pm-dispatch: three measured readings — the statesTheSet census, the enqueue instant, and the battery's cap-sized runtime #18287 references/**, in-seat contract-tier reviews with their records, merged_by claude[bot]), objectui 0; cloud / objectos / hotcrm unaudited every time (no checkout). Sixth audit 2026-09-15T11:04Z, --since-ref objectstack=0865f4144354 --since-ref objectui=88561fdc4856: 0 governed merges (the two mainline commits since are scripts/pm/** only); cloud / objectos / hotcrm unaudited every time (no checkout). Seventh and eighth audits are in the previous body revisions. Ninth audit 2026-09-15T17:53Z , --since-ref objectstack=827cacbf4b79 --since-ref objectui=88561fdc4856 with the three attached repos on the date window: 3 governed merges, all this seat's with their records — PR fix(settings,pm-dispatch): deny mcp__github__update_pull_request and route the ready flip through the CCR routes #18276 .claude/** ×3, ruling C, merged_by os-zhuang), PR docs(pm): platform-readings retires the rows that still describe MCP update_pull_request as a live channel #18307 docs(pm): platform-readings reads the denied MCP wrapper's footer rows as history #18316 references/**, in-seat contract-tier reviews, merged_by claude[bot]); objectui 0 of 3 mainline commits (its main moved to 4a94c38b); cloud 0 of 2; objectos 0 of 0; hotcrm 0 of 11 (tip 975676dd1). Next, exactly: --since-ref objectstack=82b3032c475c --since-ref objectui=4a94c38b0bb7 --since-ref cloud=cb8ee7ff60c0 --since-ref objectos=cb0c1467b040 --since-ref hotcrm=975676dd1e83 (objectstack's tip has since moved to a46cd8c4, a scripts/pm/**-only landing — the window from 82b3032c covers it). Coverage extended 2026-09-15T13:16Z : read-only checkouts at /home/user/cloud (attached), /home/user/objectstack-ai/objectos and /home/user/objectstack-ai/hotcrm (anonymous public reads; no API credentials, so merged_by attribution on those two returns 403 on every channel — an attach with push access is the maintainer's call, not this seat's). Baseline sweep --since 7d over the three (boundary 2026-09-08T13:16Z, backed off 3600 s): 9 governed merges, none of them this seat's, for the maintainer to recognise — cloud PR Epic: External Datasource Runtime — implement ADR-0062 (auto-connect, credentials, analytics, cleanup) #2163 docs/adr/** ×2, merged by os-zhuang at 2026-09-10T09:10Z) · objectos PR 🔗 Broken links detected in documentation #283 [objectos] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17164 fix(deps): pin esbuild ≥0.28.1 via pnpm-workspace overrides (GHSA-gv7w-rqvm-qjhr) #1910 [P0] build-time vs runtime validation parity: objectstack build accepts metadata the runtime rejects #1876 chore(changeset): backfill changesets for post-9.3 changes #1830 feat(service-ai): visualize_data tool — return charts from AI data queries #1820 docs(adr): revise ADR-0048 — package-scoped identity over per-item collision detection #1809 docs(showcase+skill): ADR-0047 UX round 2 — tabs XOR dropdowns, no auto-derive #1798 docs(adr): ADR-0041 — flow trigger family: taxonomy, naming, open-source core set #1746 AGENTS.md / CLAUDE.md / docs surfaces; attribution UNAVAILABLE). The pair (objectstack, objectui) reads history-horizon under the 7-day DATE window on these shallow clones and is covered by the topological windows above instead — not a gap. From here on every round audits all five topologically from the tips named in the refresh clause.Half-state anchor [Half-state patrol] check-half-states live sweep — generated view (please pin) #9857 (swept 2026-09-15T13:48Z, next by 19:37Z): the sweep's one H38 row names [PM seat] domain:devx @ objectstack — 🟢 os-project-manager · session_017ef78bLdybu3AffehKkhfk · R1 wave 2 · 继承落地债 4/4 已清 · PR #18162 #18165 已入队 · 2 在飞(#17330 #17739)· 1 等人工合 #18096 · 新立 3 卡 #6023 fix(pm): H44's timestamp leg accepts an ISO instant whose hour follows a T — the ruled minute spelling no longer reads as untimestamped #18326 fix(pm): the half-state patrol's seat legs read the triage post and the newest page — H44 reaches a vacant or Routine seat, H32 / H38 take their marker from the last page #18332 [PM seat] triage (objectstack-wide) — 🟢 在席 session_01WDxrLMPs5TyKB45RPiJuLo · R+244 · harness **CURRENT** · 写入身份 os-sam(User)六轮稳定 · ⭐ **pm:retriage 两仓清零** · 本轮:objectui#6653 改造为先测量 · #7997 关 completed → 残余立 #9593 · 更正本席 #18362 的行号漂移 · 欠账:objectui ①50/④34/finding 39 · objectstack ①31/③7+16/finding 35 · 决策箱 1(#18364 待一个字母)· ⚠️ #18172 仍是唯一 p1 · ⚠️ objectui domain:ui 席 #5560 因同一 harness STALE 于 04:45Z 收班 #6015 [finding] REST 写侧强制头 Content-Type 的规则只住在 platform-readings.md —— 「动手前查一行」的 rest-channel.md 写侧段零提及、零交叉引用,一个班次内三席踩中 #18339 ADR-0135 的两处过期物随 #14361 的 Fixes 一起消失:Consequences 的 Until then 前件已过,:63 的 grep 配方读起来像通用总体筛而两个方向各错(本席自己误用两次) #18345
Hot-file serial queue
.claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md (812/812) + references/core-rules.md (151/151): PRs pm-dispatch: reconcile the quota rows with the identity-bound rate limit; merged-write rule; account-suspension recovery readings #18242 1a02ef17, docs(agents): the contract-review carrier is the seat's to hang; --pair PR-NUMBER is the only spelling #18250 41ff021c, docs(pm-dispatch): a triage direction landing in an adjudicated area quotes the governing line #18256 681317c3, fix(settings,pm-dispatch): deny mcp__github__update_pull_request and route the ready flip through the CCR routes #18276 53dd5aaa LANDED → PR fix(pm): the charter latest-touch reading is taken depth-independently — a shallow clone's git log names a commit that never touched the path #18327 On a shallow checkout git log -1 -- <path> names a commit that never touched the path — measured: the seating charter reading returned a real sha from an unrelated driver-test commit #18180 [finding] the enqueue bar 「每一个 check 全绿」 is unsatisfiable as written — every landing carries 7-10 skipped checks, and nothing distinguishes an expected skip from a path-filter miss #18308 .claude/agents/os-dev.md (403/403): PR docs(agents): the os-dev terminal report carries its own session id #18273 9fa9955a — free. references/platform-readings.md (463 on main after PR docs(pm): platform-readings reads the denied MCP wrapper's footer rows as history #18316 ruledRaises ×17): PRs docs(pm): platform-readings retires the rows that still describe MCP update_pull_request as a live channel #18307 6ef33128 + docs(pm): platform-readings reads the denied MCP wrapper's footer rows as history #18316 82b3032c LANDED → [finding] platform-readings: four rows describe MCP enable_pr_auto_merge / disable_pr_auto_merge behaviour a seat can no longer reach once lock 1 denies the enqueue class (:41 · :49 · :58 · :60) #18320 fix(settings,pm): deny the MCP enqueue class — enable/disable_pr_auto_merge join lock 1 and the roster gate #18317 references/rest-channel.md (82/82): PR fix(settings,pm-dispatch): deny mcp__github__update_pull_request and route the ready flip through the CCR routes #18276 fix(settings,pm): deny the MCP enqueue class — enable/disable_pr_auto_merge join lock 1 and the roster gate #18317 [Decision] permissions.deny: extend declared = enforced to the enqueue class — deny mcp__github__enable_pr_auto_merge too, or keep it hook-guarded only? #18282 .claude/settings.json: PR fix(settings,pm-dispatch): deny mcp__github__update_pull_request and route the ready flip through the CCR routes #18276 fix(settings,pm): deny the MCP enqueue class — enable/disable_pr_auto_merge join lock 1 and the roster gate #18317 main, 17 = 17 on its head. scripts/pm/check-settings-deny-roster.mjs + package.json + lint.yml: PR feat(pm): a gate pins permissions.deny to the charter's content-write roster #18285 52c1a8c4 — free. scripts/pm/post-stamped.mjs: PRs fix(pm): post-stamped counts a same-second later comment as after the acknowledged one #18297 99d20cfd + fix(pm): post-stamped names the platform's known read-back normalisations and locates a real mutation #18298 827cacbf LANDED — free. scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs: PRs feat(pm): the half-state patrol reads the tier a triage round artefact names #18311 10a7b9fa (H65), fix(pm): the half-state patrol reads a seat post's NEWEST comment page, and H44 knows the current marker spelling #18322 a46cd8c4 (the NEWEST-page memo) and fix(pm): H44's timestamp leg accepts an ISO instant whose hour follows a T — the ruled minute spelling no longer reads as untimestamped #18326 de9c319a (the timestamp anchor) and fix(pm): the half-state patrol's seat legs read the triage post and the newest page — H44 reaches a vacant or Routine seat, H32 / H38 take their marker from the last page #18332 a09725dd (the seat legs' population and window) LANDED — free. AGENTS.md (1075/1075): PR fix(agents,gates): the merge queue blocks on seven contexts, and a set-stating surface is now a census #18244 1297178e → PR docs(agents): the comment rule exempts a verbatim maintainer ruling preserved as a quotation block #18315 [Decision] AGENTS.md's comment rule vs preserved verbatim maintainer rulings that contain a model identifier — carve out quotations (A), treat them as violations (B), or leave it undecided (C) #18092 docs(agents): write down the shape a --self-test must have to be capable of failing #18227 AGENTS.md §3 criterion ③ tests the branch's WHOLE ancestry, so --force-with-lease is dead letter for every branch cut from main (measured: 33 pairs vs 1 scoped; control: main itself reads 32) #18178 docs(agents): the comment rule exempts a verbatim maintainer ruling preserved as a quotation block #18315 skills/objectstack-formula/SKILL.md + skills/objectstack-data/references/data-hooks.md (published catalog, token ratchet 5367 / 6002 and 9884 / 12611 on the head): → PR docs(skills): before* hooks on a predicate write dispatch per row — the two published skills stop teaching a batch dispatch and a retired guard #18328 [finding] 两份已发布 skills 仍教 before* 钩子整批触发,并推销一个没有生产者的诊断(HookConditionLimitation) #18221 .claude/hooks/**: free → [finding] guard-governed-enqueue.selftest.sh: the case 「an exception-row path in a repo this container cannot resolve」 is not hermetic — it reads 54 passed / 1 failed on any box with a sibling /home/user/cloud checkout, green in CI only because CI has none #18321 scripts/pm/git-history.mjs: → PR fix(pm): the charter latest-touch reading is taken depth-independently — a shallow clone's git log names a commit that never touched the path #18327 On a shallow checkout git log -1 -- <path> names a commit that never touched the path — measured: the seating charter reading returned a real sha from an unrelated driver-test commit #18180 touch mode, awaiting approval) → [finding] check-harness-current.mjs prints the graft boundary as a harness path's latest touch on a shallow checkout — the CURRENT / STALE verdict holds by construction, but the printed sha is not a reading of the path #18330 scripts/pm/check-harness-current.mjs, consumes its exports) SERIAL behind it. scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs · check-clause2-carriers.mjs · check-dispatch-gates.mjs · board-snapshot.mjs · check-skill-line-ratchet.mjs · check-required-contexts.mjs · references/review-checklist.md (77/77) · references/contract-review.md (60/60): free. Frame block :734–:755 md5 3327d02c56f8a0eca88569dad2270f32 (unchanged on 82b3032c, verified 2026-09-15T17:34Z).objectui: scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs (objectui copy): objectui#9395 (pm:retriage, the maintainer's answer). AGENTS.md (objectui): free.
Notes
Job description: references/lanes/skills.md. Standing facts carried forward (unchanged): value gate + reject authority from #13597 ; scripts/pm/** pure-code PRs land by in-seat contract-tier review → ready → queue, any governed .md in the diff ⇒ draft at the governed terminal (four-piece, an authorized approval, then ruling C); path face via check-governed-merges.mjs --test (objectui: scripts/check-governed-queue-guard.mjs --test); read the PR's event log before touching a governed draft. Publication register: none of objectstack / objectui / hotcrm / objectos is registered here as deploying on a default-branch push ⇒ landing criterion = MERGED through the queue, its instant read from merged_at (#18274 ). Tier policy: dispatch-gates.mjs --tier is the single source; skills/**, pm-dispatch SKILL.md and os-dev.md build at the contract-review tier; references/**, other .claude/skills/**, docs/adr/** and AGENTS.md build at the default tier with the seat's contract-tier review. Channel facts: content writes go through the REST proxy only (⛔ no MCP write tool); labels / assignees / issue types through scripts/pm/label-write.mjs and a REST PATCH for type; seat artefacts through scripts/pm/post-stamped.mjs (the NOW token for this act's clock, the WAS token for a quoted instant, nothing else; a body refresh names the newest comment with --ack-through; a 1-byte read-back delta is the trailing newline, not the sanitizer); POST /issues/N/labels and every other write need Content-Type: application/json; the search endpoint is not reachable through this proxy — dedupe by listing + grep with a control; job logs through MCP get_job_logs; the auto_merge REST field reads null on a merge-queue repository — read the added_to_merge_queue timeline event or the merge_group workflow runs (GET /actions/runs?event=merge_group, whose head_branch names the chain). Checkouts: /home/user/objectstack on the session branch, fast-forwarded to origin/main as it moves (b57671ed at this refresh; shallow, graft boundary 9b00f9f9 — and see #18180 : the lanes/skills.md touch sha this seat's own marker recorded IS that boundary, not a reading of the path; the seat's two other claims about that marker were wrong and are corrected on the card); /home/user/objectui at 88561fd (its origin/main moved to 4a94c38b, fetched 2026-09-15T17:45Z — audited in the ninth audit at 17:53Z — 3 mainline commits, 0 governed; no node_modules). Corrections the previous seat recorded on itself (kept as pointers; the full text is in the previous body revision): budget against the ratchet before dispatching; every instant is exact and goes through the quoted-stamp form; title PATCH after the body write succeeds; declare the payment section, not a line range, at a file's ceiling; read a card's newest comments before recording a ruling; a --pair reading's stamp is the measuring command's own date. Corrections this seat recorded on itself this shift: count_check.verdict = surplus is the archive's destruction signature, not health (#18137 ); #18249 / #18254 were graded before the register was read; a landing instant is merged_at, never the squash commit's date (#18274 ); a ruledRaises record is one per INCREMENT sized at its rows, not one per row (PR #18279 's record); the dispatch's gate spellings check:pm-skill-line-ratchet / --test (real: check:pm-skill-ratchet, check:pm-governed-merges). Patrol timer: Routine trig_01W822gWwQ64s2HfHUfkfKUN (self-bound, hourly at :02); an accelerator is armed only while devs are in flight.
Generated by Claude Code
This post is the single authoritative registration of the skills seat. Four-section template; the job description is versioned at
.claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/lanes/skills.md— ⛔ not copied here.Current PM
⏳ vacant — the previous holder,
session_01HZfg2AwVX191qCizp88gQr(skills seat R1, seated 2026-09-15T01:37Z; GitHub account os-zhuang — its content writes read backclaude[bot]through 2026-09-15T20:04Z andos-zhuangfrom 2026-09-16T01:53Z, the account swap recorded on #18334), SIGNED OFF at 2026-09-16T04:32Z on the maintainer's order on the direct channel (「当前任务处理完,合并后就下班」, given after PR #18359 landed); the 收班简报 is the newest comment on this post and is the release marker — a successor seats immediately by/pm-dispatch 接手after reading this post.接任台账 (hand-off ledger, written at sign-off)
needs-user-decision, reviewerhotlong— os-zhuang is the author of all four under the previous seat's write identity and can neither be requested nor approve): AGENTS.md §3 criterion ③ tests the branch's WHOLE ancestry, so --force-with-lease is dead letter for every branch cut from main (measured: 33 pairs vs 1 scoped; control: main itself reads 32) #18178 → PR docs(agents): criterion ③'s test is scoped to the branch's own commits — the unranged git log walked all of main and made force-with-lease dead letter #18351 (headec9ef17b, AGENTS.md :473–:474; record 5691146373, ACCEPT 5691146817) · [finding] the enqueue bar 「每一个 check 全绿」 is unsatisfiable as written — every landing carries 7-10 skipped checks, and nothing distinguishes an expected skip from a path-filter miss #18308 → PR fix(pm): the enqueue bar names expected skips — a path-filtered job's skip is not a failure, and a check reports the skips outside the declared roster #18357 (head7a1f99ea, SKILL.md :629 +scripts/pm/check-expected-skips.mjs+package.json; record 5691464077, ACCEPT 5691461390; head green 42 / 42) · [finding] Clause-②: yes on a non-spec, non-skills lane — the protocol says the contract-review-tier review is the spec seat's, but spells no handoff (who is asked, by which artefact), so a lane seat reaches for an in-seat PASS the harness classifier then refuses as self-approval #18349 → PR docs(pm): the clause-② contract review is tier-bound — the dispatching seat reviews in-seat at CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER, no seat list #18363 (heada0f37dda, SKILL.md :513 / :523 / :641 + contract-review.md :26 / :41 / :51 / :52 + one platform-readings row; record 5692045480, ACCEPT 5692045887; Lint & Repo Gates still running at sign-off) · [finding] guard-governed-enqueue.selftest.sh: the case 「an exception-row path in a repo this container cannot resolve」 is not hermetic — it reads 54 passed / 1 failed on any box with a sibling/home/user/cloudcheckout, green in CI only because CI has none #18321 → PR fix(hooks): guard-governed-enqueue's sibling-checkout lookup is injectable, so its self-test is hermetic on a box that carries the sibling #18365 (head5391e5c0, the twoguard-governed-enqueuehook files; record 5692046150, ACCEPT 5692046598; Lint & Repo Gates still running at sign-off; the redTypeScript Type Checkis on the superseded commit68d26af5, noted at 5691988381). On an APPROVED: ruling C by the seat holder of that moment (record on the current head,--pair0, every check success or a rostered skip — read withcheck-expected-skips.mjson PR fix(pm): the enqueue bar names expected skips — a path-filtered job's skip is not a failure, and a check reports the skips outside the declared roster #18357's branch until it lands — clearneeds-user-decision, ready through the CCR route, auto-merge SQUASH, provenance, three readings, residue, landing record); the approver may also flip ready + enqueue directly. The previous session keeps its PR subscriptions on the four and, if woken by an approval, performs that landing itself (留守 on exactly these four; nothing else).pm:queue, this lane, unassigned) at sign-off, in total order — 13: p2 · Bug — [finding] guard-governed-enqueue's slug reader keeps a.gitsuffix — a sibling cloned with the conventional URL never resolves, and a baregh pr merge Non such a clone derives a slug the API 404s on, so the guard fails OPEN #18366 (the hook'sslug_ofkeeps a.gitsuffix: a conventional-URL sibling never resolves, and the baregh pr merge Nslug 404s the guard OPEN; hooks, rules layer; SERIAL behind PR fix(hooks): guard-governed-enqueue's sibling-checkout lookup is injectable, so its self-test is hermetic on a box that carries the sibling #18365) · p3 — [cloud] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17163 (cloud's CLAUDE.md → pointer; needs a push toobjectstack-ai/cloud) · [finding] objectui's half-state findings reach no reader: the board has no anchor by ruling, and its copy of check-half-states still refuses in agent containers with the conclusion #13544 disproved #18290 (objectui'scheck-half-states.mjscopy; waits on the maintainer's objectui#9395 A / B / C) · [finding]post-stamped | tail -N && label-writesilently breaks the comment-before-label pairing — the pipeline returns tail's 0, so a REFUSED comment still lets the label land #18337 + [finding] REST 写侧强制头 Content-Type 的规则只住在 platform-readings.md —— 「动手前查一行」的 rest-channel.md 写侧段零提及、零交叉引用,一个班次内三席踩中 #18339 + [finding] rest-channel :54 still says the REST actor is 「按会话」claude[bot]or a user — the token class follows the Claude Code account and flipped inside one session twice; one in-place re-key pointing at the fact table #18360 (rest-channel.md's write side: the pipeline-exit trap + the tool's header, theContent-Typecross-reference, :54's 「按会话」 re-key — a three-card FOLD on one file, 82 / 82 in place; the previous seat drafted its claims and dispatch text but did NOT dispatch — start from the three cards' bodies and gradings 5691531819 / 5691532336 / [finding] rest-channel :54 still says the REST actor is 「按会话」claude[bot]or a user — the token class follows the Claude Code account and flipped inside one session twice; one in-place re-key pointing at the fact table #18360's body) · ADR-0135 的两处过期物随 #14361 的 Fixes 一起消失:Consequences 的 Until then 前件已过,:63 的 grep 配方读起来像通用总体筛而两个方向各错(本席自己误用两次) #18345 (ADR-0135'sUntil thenpassage and the :63 recipe's scope;docs/adr/**, rules layer; SERIAL behind PR docs(adr): ADR-0135's two prose citations of the code name what the code now says #18344's landing, then close-as-completed or dispatch) · [finding] git-history.mjstouchIsProvablereportsboundary: falsefor a registered graft boundary whose parent has since been fetched — the refusal is right, the flag and the reason text are wrong #18355 (touchIsProvableboundary flag false negative;scripts/pm/git-history.mjs, non-governed) · Wirecheck-harness-current.mjs --self-test(PR #18352) into lint.yml's shallow-history self-test collector — a self-test nobody runs is the injurycheck-self-test-wiredexists for #18356 (wirecheck-harness-current.mjs --self-testinto lint.yml's shallow-history collector; dispatchable now; region-parallel with Wirepnpm check:pm-expected-skips(PR #18357) into lint.yml beside the othercheck:pm-*steps — a self-test no workflow names is outsidecheck-self-test-wired's population #18358) · Wirepnpm check:pm-expected-skips(PR #18357) into lint.yml beside the othercheck:pm-*steps — a self-test no workflow names is outsidecheck-self-test-wired's population #18358 (wirepnpm check:pm-expected-skipsinto lint.yml; SERIAL behind PR fix(pm): the enqueue bar names expected skips — a path-filtered job's skip is not a failure, and a check reports the skips outside the declared roster #18357) · [finding] platform-readings :134 / :143 list the draft flip and the auto-merge mount as GraphQL-only and stand a seat down for them in a rate-limit window — both have live ccr routes, the only routes since lock 1 #18361 (platform-readings :134 / :143 GraphQL-only list vs the live ccr routes — a judgment re-key, in place only: the ceiling reads 466 / 466 once PR docs(pm): the clause-② contract review is tier-bound — the dispatching seat reviews in-seat at CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER, no seat list #18363's row lands) · platform-readings 的 detach 处方没说 pid 从哪来 —— 用 pgrep -f 重新推导会自匹配到包装器自己,监视器永远等自己 #18362 (platform-readings' detach recipe names no pid source — filed and graded p3 by another seat at 04:0xZ; same file, in place only) · [finding] guard-governed-enqueue's 「no checkout available」 fail-open is pinned by no self-test case in any environment — the case that claimed it never reaches it; one hermetic case with the injected empty root #18367 (the hook's 「no checkout available」 fail-open is pinned by no self-test case; SERIAL behind PR fix(hooks): guard-governed-enqueue's sibling-checkout lookup is injectable, so its self-test is hermetic on a box that carries the sibling #18365; fold candidate with [finding] guard-governed-enqueue's slug reader keeps a.gitsuffix — a sibling cloned with the conventional URL never resolves, and a baregh pr merge Non such a clone derives a slug the API 404s on, so the guard fails OPEN #18366). Held elsewhere:hotcrmhas no half-state patrol anchor, so thepm:dispatched+ assignee residue after aFixesauto-close has now been repaired by hand seven rounds running #14881 / The M9.1 / M9.2 expression phases — including "astbecomes required in build output" — are asserted in six files and one published docs page, and defined in no ADR #17323 / skills: evaluate whether the published security/platform guidance must teach the app-capability vs system-permission distinction and theisDefault→everyonebinding rule (after #17189) #17359pm:blocked, [www.objectos.ai] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17165 / [Decision] 22 pure-objectui defect cards live in objectstack underrepo:objectui, but objectui IS reachable — the seam fallback is being used where its precondition does not hold #17250pm:awaiting-maintainer, Published-skills factual sweep: verify every behavioral claim in skills/** against the implementation — program anchor #13658 / Skills catalog optimization program (maintainer-directed): audit every skill on both roots, then optimize — program anchor #14292 / [program] CLAUDE.md is a pointer to AGENTS.md in every repo — no second instruction set to maintain (maintainer 2026-09-09) #17161 tracking, PM corpus audit (maintainer-directed): classify every instruction line — keep / duplicate / demote / delete — then rewrite and re-lock every ratchet #13597 the maintainer's ownpm:dispatched.origin/main; platform-readings.md — PR docs(pm): the clause-② contract review is tier-bound — the dispatching seat reviews in-seat at CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER, no seat list #18363 adds :429 (464 → 466 / 466 with PR docs(pm): platform-readings retires the denied enqueue tool's rows and reads the REST token class per write, not per session #18359 landed), so [finding] platform-readings :134 / :143 list the draft flip and the auto-merge mount as GraphQL-only and stand a seat down for them in a rate-limit window — both have live ccr routes, the only routes since lock 1 #18361 / platform-readings 的 detach 处方没说 pid 从哪来 —— 用 pgrep -f 重新推导会自匹配到包装器自己,监视器永远等自己 #18362 are in-place-only; contract-review.md — PR docs(pm): the clause-② contract review is tier-bound — the dispatching seat reviews in-seat at CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER, no seat list #18363 (60 / 60); rest-channel.md — the [finding]post-stamped | tail -N && label-writesilently breaks the comment-before-label pairing — the pipeline returns tail's 0, so a REFUSED comment still lets the label land #18337 / [finding] REST 写侧强制头 Content-Type 的规则只住在 platform-readings.md —— 「动手前查一行」的 rest-channel.md 写侧段零提及、零交叉引用,一个班次内三席踩中 #18339 / [finding] rest-channel :54 still says the REST actor is 「按会话」claude[bot]or a user — the token class follows the Claude Code account and flipped inside one session twice; one in-place re-key pointing at the fact table #18360 fold (82 / 82, in place); lint.yml — Wirecheck-harness-current.mjs --self-test(PR #18352) into lint.yml's shallow-history self-test collector — a self-test nobody runs is the injurycheck-self-test-wiredexists for #18356 ∥ Wirepnpm check:pm-expected-skips(PR #18357) into lint.yml beside the othercheck:pm-*steps — a self-test no workflow names is outsidecheck-self-test-wired's population #18358;.claude/hooks/guard-governed-enqueue*— PR fix(hooks): guard-governed-enqueue's sibling-checkout lookup is injectable, so its self-test is hermetic on a box that carries the sibling #18365 → [finding] guard-governed-enqueue's slug reader keeps a.gitsuffix — a sibling cloned with the conventional URL never resolves, and a baregh pr merge Non such a clone derives a slug the API 404s on, so the guard fails OPEN #18366 → [finding] guard-governed-enqueue's 「no checkout available」 fail-open is pinned by no self-test case in any environment — the case that claimed it never reaches it; one hermetic case with the injected empty root #18367; AGENTS.md — PR docs(agents): criterion ③'s test is scoped to the branch's own commits — the unranged git log walked all of main and made force-with-lease dead letter #18351 (:473–:474).gen-sdui-manifest.shhardcodes port 5180 and one log path, so two concurrent runs in a container can dump the OTHER run's server #9578's contract-review record could not be relayed (the attachment never reached the container) — the ui seat posts it through the REST proxy channel, or the maintainer pastes it · objectui fix(tooling): error-status gate names the real cause when a code leaves the ungraded set (#9563) #9577 (the ui seat's hand-over of askills/**review to this lane) — the previous seat recommended returning it to the ui seat under the [finding] Clause-②: yes on a non-spec, non-skills lane — the protocol says the contract-review-tier review is the spec seat's, but spells no handoff (who is asked, by which artefact), so a lane seat reaches for an in-seat PASS the harness classifier then refuses as self-approval #18349 ruling (in-seat review at the tier; PR docs(pm): the clause-② contract review is tier-bound — the dispatching seat reviews in-seat at CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER, no seat list #18363 is that ruling's text), pending the maintainer's word · objectui#9586 (lock-1 mirror) filed · triage seat [PM seat] triage (objectstack-wide) — 🟢 在席session_01WDxrLMPs5TyKB45RPiJuLo· R+244 · harness **CURRENT** · 写入身份os-sam(User)六轮稳定 · ⭐ **pm:retriage两仓清零** · 本轮:objectui#6653 改造为先测量 · #7997 关 completed → 残余立 #9593 · 更正本席 #18362 的行号漂移 · 欠账:objectui ①50/④34/finding 39 · objectstack ①31/③7+16/finding 35 · 决策箱 1(#18364 待一个字母)· ⚠️ #18172 仍是唯一 p1 · ⚠️ objectui domain:ui 席 #5560 因同一 harness STALE 于 04:45Z 收班 #6015 VACANT since 2026-09-16T02:58Z; its R+240 canonical exception (governed-face cards routed to this lane without pm state are graded by this seat) stands.board-snapshotrun 46 RED); the runbook ceiling; objectui#9395; [cloud] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17163's cloud push attach.trig_01W822gWwQ64s2HfHUfkfKUN) and the accelerator (trig_01EAuFgusXR8J3FSCBWd9Bdr) were deleted at sign-off; the only standing wake is the previous session's PR subscriptions on the four hung PRs.claude/relaxed-rubin-a3ffs8is atorigin/mainb57671edand pushed. · sessionsession_01HZfg2AwVX191qCizp88gQr· seated 2026-09-15T02:02Z on the maintainer's/pm-dispatch skillssummon · R1 · this session serves at the contract-review tier (CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER), the mandated floor for theSKILL.mdchain · body refreshed 2026-09-16T04:32Z at the SHIFT END (wave 39 — the previous session signed off; the wave-38 events follow for the record: the [finding] check-harness-current.mjs prints the graft boundary as a harness path's latest touch on a shallow checkout — the CURRENT / STALE verdict holds by construction, but the printed sha is not a reading of the path #18330 dev's PR fix(pm): check-harness-current prints boundary, not a fabricated sha, when a harness path's latest touch is not provable on the shallow checkout #18352 LANDED1411cf2cat 2026-09-16T03:12Z; the [finding] the enqueue bar 「每一个 check 全绿」 is unsatisfiable as written — every landing carries 7-10 skipped checks, and nothing distinguishes an expected skip from a path-filter miss #18308 dev's PR fix(pm): the enqueue bar names expected skips — a path-filtered job's skip is not a failure, and a check reports the skips outside the declared roster #18357 reviewed PASS at the review tier and its four-piece hung for hotlong; the AGENTS.md §3 criterion ③ tests the branch's WHOLE ancestry, so --force-with-lease is dead letter for every branch cut from main (measured: 33 pairs vs 1 scoped; control: main itself reads 32) #18178 dev's PR docs(agents): criterion ③'s test is scoped to the branch's own commits — the unranged git log walked all of main and made force-with-lease dead letter #18351 four-piece hung for hotlong (os-zhuang cannot be requested — the PR's author under the seat's write identity); four bare cards graded by lane self-triage ([finding] the seat's REST writes now land as a USER account, notclaude[bot]— the durability premise in platform-readings, #6015 and every Routine prompt is falsified #18334 / [finding]post-stamped | tail -N && label-writesilently breaks the comment-before-label pairing — the pipeline returns tail's 0, so a REFUSED comment still lets the label land #18337 / [finding] REST 写侧强制头 Content-Type 的规则只住在 platform-readings.md —— 「动手前查一行」的 rest-channel.md 写侧段零提及、零交叉引用,一个班次内三席踩中 #18339 / ADR-0135 的两处过期物随 #14361 的 Fixes 一起消失:Consequences 的 Until then 前件已过,:63 的 grep 配方读起来像通用总体筛而两个方向各错(本席自己误用两次) #18345), [finding] platform-readings: the REST proxy's write identity changed mid-shift with no seat action — content writes read backclaude[bot](installation) until 2026-09-15T20:04Z andos-zhuang/Uservia appclaude(user-to-server) from 2026-09-16T01:53Z — the register has no row saying the token class is re-read, not assumed #18350 closed as [finding] the seat's REST writes now land as a USER account, notclaude[bot]— the durability premise in platform-readings, #6015 and every Routine prompt is falsified #18334's duplicate, Wirepnpm check:pm-expected-skips(PR #18357) into lint.yml beside the othercheck:pm-*steps — a self-test no workflow names is outsidecheck-self-test-wired's population #18358 filed; one dev dispatched on the fold [finding] platform-readings: four rows describe MCPenable_pr_auto_merge/disable_pr_auto_mergebehaviour a seat can no longer reach once lock 1 denies the enqueue class (:41 · :49 · :58 · :60) #18320 + [finding] the seat's REST writes now land as a USER account, notclaude[bot]— the durability premise in platform-readings, #6015 and every Routine prompt is falsified #18334; two of this seat's own evidence claims on On a shallow checkoutgit log -1 -- <path>names a commit that never touched the path — measured: the seating charter reading returned a real sha from an unrelated driver-test commit #18180 were wrong and are corrected on the card; three cards filed ([finding] measure-self-test-floor.mjs refuses to print any census on current main — its recogniser reads two landed handshake spellings as absent, so the instrument cannot answer the floor question anyone runs it for #18329, [finding] check-harness-current.mjs prints the graft boundary as a harness path's latest touch on a shallow checkout — the CURRENT / STALE verdict holds by construction, but the printed sha is not a reading of the path #18330, [finding] objectql hook-wrappers.ts: two docblocks still state the retired batch model for the before* dispatch of a predicate write in the present tense, while the code beneath binds per row #18331); [cloud] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17163 in the queue behind a push-attach decision; the triage seatsession_01VxjMEAhT53WHUCtP9WMrSUseated at 2026-09-15T13:45Z and STOOD DOWN at 2026-09-15T15:54Z — [PM seat] triage (objectstack-wide) — 🟢 在席session_01WDxrLMPs5TyKB45RPiJuLo· R+244 · harness **CURRENT** · 写入身份os-sam(User)六轮稳定 · ⭐ **pm:retriage两仓清零** · 本轮:objectui#6653 改造为先测量 · #7997 关 completed → 残余立 #9593 · 更正本席 #18362 的行号漂移 · 欠账:objectui ①50/④34/finding 39 · objectstack ①31/③7+16/finding 35 · 决策箱 1(#18364 待一个字母)· ⚠️ #18172 仍是唯一 p1 · ⚠️ objectui domain:ui 席 #5560 因同一 harness STALE 于 04:45Z 收班 #6015 VACANT again, this seat's stand-in triage resumed per SKILL.md :226 and stops the moment a triage seat sits; PR fix(settings,pm-dispatch): deny mcp__github__update_pull_request and route the ready flip through the CCR routes #18276 LANDED by ruling C at 2026-09-15T15:14Z; two follow-up cards filed, both serial; the eighth governed-merge audit at 2026-09-15T13:16Z covers ALL FIVE governed repos for the first time this shift — the seat attachedcloud(read-only) and clonedobjectos+hotcrmanonymously, deepened each to 400 first-parent commits; topological window clean on the pair, and a 7-day date-window baseline over the three newly attached repos lists 9 governed merges for the maintainer's recognition (see the audit line below); next tipsobjectstack=827cacbf4b79·objectui=88561fdc4856·cloud=cb8ee7ff60c0·objectos=cb0c1467b040·hotcrm=9f13c77eb493; PR fix(settings,pm-dispatch): deny mcp__github__update_pull_request and route the ready flip through the CCR routes #18276 still awaits an authorized approval — requested at 2026-09-15T07:16Z; PR feat(pm): a gate pins permissions.deny to the charter's content-write roster #18285 serial behind it; [finding] platform-readings: four rows describe MCPupdate_pull_requestas a live channel after lock 1 denies it (:43 · :46 · :47 · :338), plus the PR-body second-footer reading #18280 serial behind it too).os-zhuangis aGOVERNED_APPROVERSaccount: this seat writes no approving review under any account (red line); reported to the maintainer in the round report. Takeover compression: the previous body (os-project-manager ·session_01DAcomhvR9kKizeYgg89Vo8; brief 5673402511 is the release) is restated below; older history lives in this post's edit history and in that brief. Round-open marker 5673548571 carries the four mutex readings, the charter re-read atb3b43b6(8c657f7/9b00f9f), the harness reading (CURRENT) and the REST probe.Maintainer rulings in force (verbatim on their cards, ⛔ not restated): tier policy (#17285 → PR #17294) · card-home (#17288) · review-of-record (#17302) · #17189 rider → #17359 (blocked) · forced-takeover (#17033) · #17323 ruled B (batch #123 item 1, 5644710461) · #17624 ruled B · #17942 Q1 = A / Q2 = three-class table; Q3 WITHDRAWN by triage ruling ③ (5652544529: grading, routing, dedupe, shadow check are triage's; the skills lane's
findingself-triage exception stands perlanes/skills.md; while #6015 is VACANT this seat routes bare cards as stand-in triage — 代扫 — and stops the moment a triage seat sits) · #17934 = shape 1 · governed-surface tiering (#17950): rules layer waits for an authorized approval, onlyreferences/**lands through the queue after in-seat contract-tier review · ruling C (#17971, 5652306063; 「C. approve 后不管后续改动都由席位落地:」): once an authorized APPROVED review (os-zhuang / hotlong, not dismissed) exists on a governed PR, the OWNING seat lands it — record on the current head,--pairexit 0, all checks green, clearneeds-user-decision, ready, auto-merge SQUASH ·batchdefault 3 (#18125 → PR #18128) · write identity follows the CHANNEL (#18205 → PR #18216): REST-proxy-only content writes,user.loginnames the token, the session ID is the attribution; the ACCEPT refuses a report whosemcp_callsnames a write tool.Inherited + running ledger (hand-off)
/home/user/cloudcheckout, green in CI only because CI has none #18321, the hook's sibling lookup made injectable, self-test 56 / 0 in three injection states on a box carrying the real sibling). Retained for the record — On a shallow checkoutgit log -1 -- <path>names a commit that never touched the path — measured: the seating charter reading returned a real sha from an unrelated driver-test commit #18180 → PR fix(pm): the charter latest-touch reading is taken depth-independently — a shallow clone's git log names a commit that never touched the path #18327 (headd977c7a5; design (B) —git-history.mjsgains atouchmode that prints a last-touch sha only when every parent the commit object names is present locally ANDdiff-treetouches the path, elsefetch --deependoubling from 64,--unshallow, then exit 2 with EMPTY stdout; SKILL.md :89 re-keyed in place to 「…最新触碰 sha 走git-history.mjs touch」, 119 → 117 B, 812 / 812; self-test 37 → 54, 17-case battery; the mechanism ESTABLISHED on a constructed repo at two depths — the boundary object still names a parent the clone lacks, git diffs it against the empty tree; the seat's live probes on the shared shallow checkout: lanes/skills.md REFUSED naming boundary9b00f9f9, SKILL.md answered53dd5aaawithout a fetch, both agreeing with REST; record 5685889073 PASS, 速读终稿 5685889666, ACCEPT 5685890066,needs-user-decision, reviewersos-zhuang+hotlongrequested 2026-09-15T18:33Z) · [finding] 两份已发布 skills 仍教before*钩子整批触发,并推销一个没有生产者的诊断(HookConditionLimitation) #18221 → PR docs(skills): before* hooks on a predicate write dispatch per row — the two published skills stop teaching a batch dispatch and a retired guard #18328 (head96718735; the two PUBLISHED skills corrected at eight sites to the contract's per-rowbefore*dispatch — D1 / D2, the payload rule D3 withMULTI_UPDATE_HOOK_KEY_DIVERGENCE, the D6 ceiling — the four true table rows byte-identical tomain, the false family 0 inside both files, the skills token ratchet in headroom; the dev's one-off engine probe measured the per-row shape; built at the review tier by theskills/**mandate; record 5685957577 PASS, 速读终稿 5685958192, ACCEPT 5685958748,needs-user-decision, reviewers requested 2026-09-15T18:37Z) · [Decision] permissions.deny: extend declared = enforced to the enqueue class — denymcp__github__enable_pr_auto_mergetoo, or keep it hook-guarded only? #18282 → PR fix(settings,pm): deny the MCP enqueue class — enable/disable_pr_auto_merge join lock 1 and the roster gate #18317 (headad7a3da5; ruling 5682626575 A —enable_pr_auto_merge+disable_pr_auto_mergeinpermissions.deny15 → 17, the roster gate 17 = 17 with 36 cases, rest-channel :53 「auto-merge MCP 锁 1 同拒」; hooks untouched; record 5684320675 PASS, 速读终稿 5684321187, ACCEPT 5684321543,needs-user-decision, reviewersos-zhuang+hotlongrequested 2026-09-15T16:49Z; the objectui mirror of lock 1 gets its own card after the landing, per the ruling) · [Decision] AGENTS.md's comment rule vs preserved verbatim maintainer rulings that contain a model identifier — carve out quotations (A), treat them as violations (B), or leave it undecided (C) #18092 → PR docs(agents): the comment rule exempts a verbatim maintainer ruling preserved as a quotation block #18315 (headb671f83b; AGENTS.md :441–:444 — 「Two exemptions: a harness-writtenCo-Authored-Bytrailer … and a verbatim maintainer ruling preserved as a quotation block」, 1075 / 1075 paid by the restated clause 「the pair stays model-free」; the probe half measured EMPTY — no repository code reads prose for model identifiers, the counts the card feared were seat hand-greps; record 5684207107 PASS, 速读终稿 5684216809, ACCEPT 5684217387,needs-user-decision, reviewersos-zhuang+hotlongrequested 2026-09-15T16:42Z); all four land by ruling C after their approvals;Check Changesetfailure from 16:42Z, beforeskip-changesetwas applied — the two later runs of the same check readskipped, the platform counts the newest, and a REST re-run is 403 for the installation;update-branchis the fallback if the enqueue is refused. ACCEPTED, landing in-seat: 0 · ENQUEUED: 0 (PR docs(pm): platform-readings retires the denied enqueue tool's rows and reads the REST token class per write, not per session #18359 landed — see LANDED; nothing in the queue at sign-off). [finding] platform-readings: a phrase that only exists after joining (string concatenation, markdown emphasis, a wrapped line) reads 0 under a single-line grep in both directions — the instrument row PR #18194 could not fit into the rules layer #18195 (anchor; the report lands there only) · [finding] platform-readings: write identity is a per-session credential shape — installation →claude[bot], user-to-server → the human login withperformed_via_github_app: claude;GET /useranswers the human login in BOTH, so it is not the probe #18158 · [finding] MCPsearch_issuesDID honour GitHub qualifiers (repo:is:label:) in two exact readings — the ledger's "qualifier form returns total_count 0" rule needs a second session before it stands or falls #16762 · [finding] issue 的 comments 字段可读出 1 而 list 与 timeline 两条通道都读 0 —— 可复现,带四张对照 #18219 · [finding] platform-readings: a suspended account's EVENTS are erased with its content (labels stay, thelabeledactor is gone) — and the one variable shared by the two suspended triage accounts is the hourly periodic-burst shape, not volume #18147 · [finding] a PCRE negative lookahead followed by a character class silently loses its through the GitHub comment API — the published command then errors to stderr and prints 0, which reads as a clean absence #18258 · [finding] objectui CI concurrency is keyed on the PR number, so re-running a superseded head cancels the current head — a re-run is a write, not a read #18262, seven claims 5675724812 / 5675725089 / 5675725359 / 5675725683 / 5675725956 / 5675726367 / 5675726731, branchclaude/issue-18195-platform-readings-fold, default tier (--tiernames no mandate forreferences/**), dispatched 2026-09-15T06:25Z; the [finding] MCPsearch_issuesDID honour GitHub qualifiers (repo:is:label:) in two exact readings — the ledger's "qualifier form returns total_count 0" rule needs a second session before it stands or falls #16762 rewrite rests on two readings — MCPsearch_issuestotal_count: 208/incomplete_results: falsefor the qualifier-shaped query and the seat's REST controlGET /issues?labels=pm:queue&state=open= 208 at 2026-09-15T06:25Z (qualifiers ARE honoured; the register's「limited-form total_count: 0」row is false). Governed PRs awaiting an authorized approval: 0 — PR fix(settings,pm-dispatch): deny mcp__github__update_pull_request and route the ready flip through the CCR routes #18276 landed by ruling C (see LANDED). LANDED this shift ×36 (instants aremerged_at, the group's fast-forward — see [finding] platform-readings: in a merge-queue repository the squash commit's committer date is the ENQUEUE instant, not the landing —merged_atand themergedevent carry the fast-forward #18274; earlier rows of this body and the eight landing records cited the squash commit's committer date, which is the ENQUEUE instant, 15–26 min early): [finding] half-state H31 binds a PR to a card by itsPart ofline, so every correctly-gated epic tracker gets a row telling a seat to hang a gate nothing will clear #18229 → PR fix(pm): bind H31's carrier pair through the closing keyword #18243 →ecf91cb44194107bcb8be8f20ea3fd97562f18d7at 2026-09-15T03:44Z · [finding] check-clause2-carriers: an unreadable or off-tierServed-tier:line is refused only beside a gate clear (C7) — a non-gated pair with the same record passes exit 0, against contract-review.md :29 「无此行不成裁决」 #18174 → PR fix(pm): judge a review of record'sServed-tier:line on every pair that has one #18251 →fd1247142a4beac65f9016de78f70caf7bb976b3at 2026-09-15T04:51Z · class (a):pnpm check:pm-dispatch-gatescannot complete inside the container's ~10-minute foreground cap — measured 9m0s then exit 124, twice; the wall-clock twin of #17708 #18201 → PR perf(pm): discover each tree once per process — the dispatch-gates self-test now reaches a verdict inside the foreground cap #18255 →47bfcd090c809cf219e4fa497fe363bb94a22388at 2026-09-15T05:15Z · [finding] H64 fires on REST writes that #18205 made correct — itsREST implies claude[bot]premise was superseded, and its remedy cannot clear it #18237 → PR fix(pm): H64 keys on the session id in the text, not on the author account #18257 →e592b4b6b7fe62e465a3eead0c6f9a8e94838585at 2026-09-15T05:18Z · [finding] platform-readings: the session proxy serves CCR routes on api.github.com for ready-for-review, auto-merge, review threads and resolve — every seat landing action now has a REST spelling authored claude[bot] #18130 → PR pm(skills): probe the unexercised CCR routes and the shared MCP user bucket into the REST channel register #18259 →c053f748b68c6b877b0462d491b47dff27915692at 2026-09-15T05:48Z · [finding] board-snapshot: the archive holds nothing above #17726 — the delta walk sits two days behind the live board while the per-run budget goes to history, so the 2026-09-14 suspension's cards were never captured #18137 → PR fix(pm): red the board-snapshot run when the archive has gone stale #18266 →e9091487f5adeb74b580b927921ee83e32550a84at 2026-09-15T06:02Z (landing record 5675544938) · [finding] check-clause2-carriers: a contract-review record whose head sha shares one code span with its key names NO head (H51_SHA_SPAN), so C6 reads 「no review of record」 where one exists — contract-review.md :28 never says the span holds the sha alone #18141 → PR fix(pm): say the head sha sits in a code span of its own, and name the refused spelling #18270 →48a93fb6824ca0804bae4b0b1c4eb2fa24ded0ebat 2026-09-15T06:20Z (landing record 5675706948) · 共享身份的限流纪律不存在：一次限流信号约束的是「身份」不是「客户端」，而规矩只说了不要重试 —— 2026-09-10 全 fleet 停摆事故 #17374 → PR pm-dispatch: reconcile the quota rows with the identity-bound rate limit; merged-write rule; account-suspension recovery readings #18242 →1a02ef17d61b00dcf1658d0ac99e35d0a706200eat 2026-09-15T06:20Z (governed; APPROVED by os-zhuang, ruling-C provenance 5675577662, landing record 5675706748) · [finding] AGENTS.md states the merge queue's required set as six contexts and calls the rest advisory — it is seven, and no gate reds on the stale sentence #17798 → PR fix(agents,gates): the merge queue blocks on seven contexts, and a set-stating surface is now a census #18244 →1297178e968bbfa0bed51de24ed3d596d63dd0ddat 2026-09-15T06:32Z (governed; APPROVED by os-zhuang, ruling-C provenance 5675577896; landing record posted 2026-09-15T06:40Z) · finding(agents):.claude/agents/os-dev.md:288orders the dev seat to hangneeds:contract-reviewon the PR, and the dev's container forbids label writes — measured on two independent runs today #18181 → PR docs(agents): the contract-review carrier is the seat's to hang;--pair PR-NUMBERis the only spelling #18250 →41ff021ca77930b13c167274857d2b689a91220eat 2026-09-15T06:32Z (governed; APPROVED ×2, provenance 5675627247; landing record posted 2026-09-15T06:40Z) · [finding] Two triage gradings named a target the governing ADR itself rejects — the grading quotes no line of the adjudication it routes against #17497 → PR docs(pm-dispatch): a triage direction landing in an adjudicated area quotes the governing line #18256 →681317c3acbb80290a02c7d093c1be53fdb346a7at 2026-09-15T06:35Z (governed; APPROVED, provenance 5675627549; landing record posted 2026-09-15T06:40Z); the three were one queue chain —merged_at06:32:45Z ×2 then 06:35:29Z · [finding] check-dispatch-gates: a cap-killed battery exits 2 from the wrapper's signal branch, so--ranaccounts the kill as a RUN with a failing code rather than NOT MEASURED #18267 → PR fix(pm): the dispatch-gates gate kill branch exits 3, so its code says what its text says #18271 →842fa040f87aafb2b6a88d1c04bb996466d90999at 2026-09-15T06:45Z (record 5675514576 PASS, ACCEPT 5675514784, provenance 5675614849; landing record posted 2026-09-15T06:46Z) · [finding] os-dev.md: theos-dev-reportcomment carries no session id by contract, so the re-keyed H64 files every dev report as unattributed seat content #18264 → PR docs(agents): the os-dev terminal report carries its own session id #18273 →9fa9955ab450a8ecfdfa6512d4b6a56e4f3547f7at 2026-09-15T07:18Z (governed; APPROVED by os-zhuang 5206596891, ruling-C provenance at 2026-09-15T06:59Z; landing record posted 2026-09-15T07:23Z) · the platform-readings fold [finding] platform-readings: a phrase that only exists after joining (string concatenation, markdown emphasis, a wrapped line) reads 0 under a single-line grep in both directions — the instrument row PR #18194 could not fit into the rules layer #18195 · [finding] platform-readings: write identity is a per-session credential shape — installation →claude[bot], user-to-server → the human login withperformed_via_github_app: claude;GET /useranswers the human login in BOTH, so it is not the probe #18158 · [finding] MCPsearch_issuesDID honour GitHub qualifiers (repo:is:label:) in two exact readings — the ledger's "qualifier form returns total_count 0" rule needs a second session before it stands or falls #16762 · [finding] issue 的 comments 字段可读出 1 而 list 与 timeline 两条通道都读 0 —— 可复现,带四张对照 #18219 · [finding] platform-readings: a suspended account's EVENTS are erased with its content (labels stay, thelabeledactor is gone) — and the one variable shared by the two suspended triage accounts is the hourly periodic-burst shape, not volume #18147 · [finding] a PCRE negative lookahead followed by a character class silently loses its through the GitHub comment API — the published command then errors to stderr and prints 0, which reads as a clean absence #18258 · [finding] objectui CI concurrency is keyed on the PR number, so re-running a superseded head cancels the current head — a re-run is a write, not a read #18262 → PR pm-dispatch: six measured platform readings, and the search_issues qualifier rows rewritten onto what is measured #18279 →9ed3f167bc28eb12131851b8b9e32e8ecc59bf99at 2026-09-15T08:07Z (references tier +scripts/pm/**, in-seat; record 5676604220, ACCEPT 5676604957 after patch round 1, provenance 5676662783; landing record 5676916965 on the anchor, one-line records on the six members; the squash closed all seven byFixes) · [finding] post-stamped: a malformedWAStoken (non-timestamp payload) is neither rendered nor refused — the raw token and its payload are stored verbatim #18284 → PR fix(pm): post-stamped refuses a token it cannot render #18286 →499f7f9e9766f264db7eddbb0ca197805b2fa7d0at 2026-09-15T09:06Z (non-governed; record 5677397822, ACCEPT, provenance; three landing readings — the log, the queue ref gone under the register's spelling, themerged_atevent; landing record posted 2026-09-15T09:07Z) · the second platform-readings fold [finding] platform-readings :385–:386 say the ledger'smustNameis not exclusive and the count line can only be hand-followed — false once PR #18244 (thestatesTheSetcensus for #17798) lands #18248 · [finding] platform-readings: in a merge-queue repository the squash commit's committer date is the ENQUEUE instant, not the landing —merged_atand themergedevent carry the fast-forward #18274 · [finding] platform-readings: the row sayingcheck:pm-dispatch-gatesEXCEEDS the 600 s foreground cap was measured under it three times (432–436 s) on one box — the basis is conditional, the detach prescription stands #18283 → PR pm-dispatch: three measured readings — the statesTheSet census, the enqueue instant, and the battery's cap-sized runtime #18287 →bda3a60c2b7bd4618cb978476eb31e5893f31aeaat 2026-09-15T09:20Z (references tier +scripts/pm/**, in-seat; record 5677334553, ACCEPT 5677335133, provenance; three readings; landing record 5677808667 on the chain head, one-line records on the members; the squash closed all three byFixes) · [finding] dispatch-gates.mjs header still says the battery runs longer than the container's foreground cap — the sibling header corrected its basis, this one did not #18288 → PR docs(pm): dispatch-gates header states the battery's cap basis as its sibling does #18291 →0865f4144354cdb229e46c8aeb892a113ac7ad6aat 2026-09-15T09:44Z (non-governed, comment-only; record 5677599609, ACCEPT, provenance; three readings; landing record posted 2026-09-15T09:46Z) · [finding] post-stamped: a quoted stamp that matches the digit shape but names an impossible instant (month 13, day 45, 99:99) is rendered verbatim — the direction rule reads a NaN date as 「not future」 #18289 → PR fix(pm): post-stamped refuses a quoted stamp that names no real instant #18292 →3964efb2e3081fed7aa9321f95d3e36a15becb4dat 2026-09-15T10:20Z (non-governed; record 5678109551, ACCEPT, provenance; three readings; landing record posted 2026-09-15T10:21Z) · [finding] post-stamped: the unread-knock check'slastWriteStampparses a rolled-over stamp to a LATER instant, so a knock inside the gap reads 「none-newer」 and the refresh voids it — the header's 「lower bound, never fewer」 promise is broken #18293 → PR fix(pm): post-stamped's unread-knock check never narrows on a stamp that names no instant #18294 →5a18f32e6a48573b3fb3feb7f47c0ce40518b4baat 2026-09-15T11:15Z (non-governed; record 5678972520, ACCEPT, provenance; three readings; landing record posted 2026-09-15T11:16Z) · [finding] post-stamped: theack-not-newestrefusal counts 「0 comment(s) landed after」 the acknowledged id when two comments share onecreated_at— the count contradicts its own refusal #18295 → PR fix(pm): post-stamped counts a same-second later comment as after the acknowledged one #18297 →99d20cfdb63a3b098a86ba3f132be2feb82b683aat 2026-09-15T12:08Z (non-governed; record 5679503885, ACCEPT 5679504453, provenance; ready + auto-merge SQUASH through the CCR route at 2026-09-15T11:51Z,merged_at17 min later; three readings; landing record 5679917857 posted 2026-09-15T12:09Z) · [finding] post-stamped:readBackVerdictcompares stored to sent byte-for-byte, so the platform's trailing-newline strip (and the footer append on comments) reads as 「the platform MUTATED the body」 on nearly every write — the one warning meant for the sanitizer is now noise #18296 → PR fix(pm): post-stamped names the platform's known read-back normalisations and locates a real mutation #18298 →827cacbf4b79088926f98bba25cccfb0f369ebbcat 2026-09-15T13:13Z (non-governed; the dev verified the seat's three mechanism readings — comment POST verbatim + 58-byte footer TRUE with a refinement (a sent body already carrying the footer reads back as the strip), body-mode strip confirmed on the adjacent PR-create channel, the footer-less issue-body cell UNMEASURED and therefore comment-only in the classifier; record 5680375613 PASS (edited once, see the harness reading below), ACCEPT 5680376047, provenance 5680468820; ready + auto-merge SQUASH at 2026-09-15T12:51Z,merged_at21 min later; three readings; landing record 5680764289 posted 2026-09-15T13:13Z — the first artefact this seat wrote with the landed tool, whose own read-back line read 「clean — the platform appended its footer (sent 1442, stored 1500)」 where every earlier write of the shift read 「MUTATED」) · finding(settings): permissions.deny omits mcp__github__update_pull_request — an MCP content write (title/body/draft) the charter now declares closed, and the seat's ready-flip fallback names the same tool #18218 → PR fix(settings,pm-dispatch): deny mcp__github__update_pull_request and route the ready flip through the CCR routes #18276 →53dd5aaaafbe877a1cc72aef26511bd15c927ecfat 2026-09-15T15:14Z (governed rules layer —.claude/settings.jsondeny ofmcp__github__update_pull_request+ SKILL.md :622 + rest-channel :53; APPROVED by os-zhuang 5211697198 at 2026-09-15T14:54Z, who flipped it ready and enqueued it in the same stroke; the seat clearedneeds-user-decision, read--pair 182760 and the checks 18 / 16, ruling-C provenance 5682476754; three readings; landing record 5682817960 posted 2026-09-15T15:16Z) · [finding] settings lock 1: no gate pinspermissions.denyto the MCP write-tool roster the charter's ACCEPT refusal names — declared vs enforced is reconciled by hand #18281 → PR feat(pm): a gate pins permissions.deny to the charter's content-write roster #18285 →52c1a8c4af411ce759158bd938474903d42dc6b2at 2026-09-15T16:07Z (non-governed; the deny-roster gatecheck-settings-deny-roster.mjs+package.json+lint.yml; record 5676984841, ACCEPT 2026-09-15T08:15Z; serial behind PR fix(settings,pm-dispatch): deny mcp__github__update_pull_request and route the ready flip through the CCR routes #18276,origin/maintaken in throughupdate-branchat 2026-09-15T15:16Z, ready + auto-merge SQUASH at 2026-09-15T15:42Z, provenance 5683278669; three readings; landing record 5683696518 posted 2026-09-15T16:08Z; the gate reads 15 = 15 onmain) · [finding] platform-readings: four rows describe MCPupdate_pull_requestas a live channel after lock 1 denies it (:43 · :46 · :47 · :338), plus the PR-body second-footer reading #18280 → PR docs(pm): platform-readings retires the rows that still describe MCP update_pull_request as a live channel #18307 →6ef331280b1b847ed333aed7ee41b97173ffe337at 2026-09-15T16:12Z (references tier; rows :43 / :44 / :46 / :47 / :345 of platform-readings retired or re-keyed as facts about a denied tool, 466 → 465; record 5683210811, ACCEPT 5683211255, provenance 5683429173; three readings; landing record 5683777652 posted 2026-09-15T16:13Z) · finding(pm): 「简报写明本轮跑的层」is declared in SKILL.md and read by nothing — enforce-or-remove #18302 → PR feat(pm): the half-state patrol reads the tier a triage round artefact names #18311 →10a7b9faa286c39d63500b32f0f45da357123686at 2026-09-15T16:24Z (non-governed; H65 incheck-half-states.mjs— a triage round artefact naming noTier:is a report-only half-state, judged on the triage post's NEWEST comment page; self-test 4196; record 5683456149, ACCEPT 5683456688, provenance 5683607305; three readings; landing record 5683963000 posted 2026-09-15T16:25Z; the triage seat clears the row by oneTier:line per round artefact) · [finding] platform-readings: three rows of the PR-body footer block still read the denied MCPupdate_pull_requestwrapper as a live edit channel (:347 · :348 · :354 on the PR #18307 head) #18310 → PR docs(pm): platform-readings reads the denied MCP wrapper's footer rows as history #18316 →82b3032c475cfe9fab9dd6238d1cc8d7aa93e4a7at 2026-09-15T17:14Z (references tier; platform-readings :347 / :348 retired, :354 re-keyed, 465 → 463; record 5684245590, ACCEPT 5684246093, provenance 5684419649; ready + auto-merge SQUASH at 2026-09-15T16:55Z; three readings; landing record 5684707250 posted 2026-09-15T17:15Z) · [finding] check-half-states: H44's seat leg is blind on the triage seat post it was written for — its corpus is the thread's FIRST comment page (oldest-first, five weeks stale on #6015) andH44_ROUND_OPEN_MARKERno longer matches the marker spelling; H56 / H64 share the corpus #18312 → PR fix(pm): the half-state patrol reads a seat post's NEWEST comment page, and H44 knows the current marker spelling #18322 →a46cd8c4a6592ef2f0790f7adfab8eabcd3b33a5at 2026-09-15T17:55Z (non-governed; the seat-post NEWEST-page memoseatPostRowsFor+ H44's marker spelling through H65's shapes; record 5684896900, ACCEPT 5684897383, provenance 5685011685; ready + auto-merge SQUASH at 2026-09-15T17:34Z,merged_at21 min later; three readings; landing record 5685322122 posted 2026-09-15T17:57Z) · [finding] check-half-states:H44_READING_TIMESTAMPrejects a minute-precision ISO stamp — theTbefore the hour is a word character, so the word-boundary anchor fails and the ruled spelling2026-03T00:21Zitself reads false #18323 → PR fix(pm): H44's timestamp leg accepts an ISO instant whose hour follows a T — the ruled minute spelling no longer reads as untimestamped #18326 →de9c319aed53d20af915560374e6af598c1c6946at 2026-09-15T18:56Z (non-governed;H44_READING_TIMESTAMPadmits the ISOTby a non-consuming look-behind, self-test 4235 → 4243; record 5685923189, ACCEPT 5685923716, provenance 5685956635; ready + auto-merge SQUASH at 2026-09-15T18:35Z,merged_at21 min later; three readings; landing record 5686346797 posted 2026-09-15T18:57Z) · the fold [finding] check-half-states: H44's seat leg cannot reach the triage seat post it was written for whenever that seat is🟢 Routineor vacant —h44NeedsSeatCommentsrequiresseatIsHeld, so the newest-page window is inert on #6015 until a session holds the seat #18324 · [finding] check-half-states: H32 and H38 read a seat post's OLDEST comment page for the one reading that must be the newest —latestSeatMarkerreturns the newest row OF THE FIRST PAGE, which on a 225-comment post is an August comment, and that is H32's idle clock and H38'sT_seat#18325 → PR fix(pm): the half-state patrol's seat legs read the triage post and the newest page — H44 reaches a vacant or Routine seat, H32 / H38 take their marker from the last page #18332 →a09725ddef3c60b92fff87d3633046da8de1f48eat 2026-09-15T20:04Z (non-governed; H44's seat leg reaches the triage post whatever its holder throughh65IsTriageSeatPostbeside the held leg — option A, zero added requests; H32 / H38 take their seat marker andT_seatfrom the NEWEST page through the shared memo; self-test 4243 → 4270; record 5687020469, ACCEPT 5687020859 on the chain head, member record 5687021250, provenance 5687138688; ready + auto-merge SQUASH at 2026-09-15T19:46Z,merged_at17 min later; three readings; landing records 5687342171 / 5687342442 posted 2026-09-15T20:04Z) · [Decision] AGENTS.md's comment rule vs preserved verbatim maintainer rulings that contain a model identifier — carve out quotations (A), treat them as violations (B), or leave it undecided (C) #18092 → PR docs(agents): the comment rule exempts a verbatim maintainer ruling preserved as a quotation block #18315 →a23035c3a9c66fb236493d52580b40c370d8e852at 2026-09-16T02:08Z (governed AGENTS.md :441–:444; APPROVED by os-zhuang 5217668792 at 2026-09-16T01:52Z, who flipped it ready and enqueued it; the seat clearedneeds-user-decision, ruling-C provenance 5690836932; three readings; landing record 5690953559 posted 2026-09-16T02:09Z) · [finding] 两份已发布 skills 仍教before*钩子整批触发,并推销一个没有生产者的诊断(HookConditionLimitation) #18221 → PR docs(skills): before* hooks on a predicate write dispatch per row — the two published skills stop teaching a batch dispatch and a retired guard #18328 →fae612a5a5a999292c17b8cc1f5442edee701d8fat 2026-09-16T02:13Z (governedskills/**×2 — the published skills teach per-rowbefore*; APPROVED 5217676382; provenance 5690856540; landing record 5690988804 posted 2026-09-16T02:14Z) · On a shallow checkoutgit log -1 -- <path>names a commit that never touched the path — measured: the seating charter reading returned a real sha from an unrelated driver-test commit #18180 → PR fix(pm): the charter latest-touch reading is taken depth-independently — a shallow clone's git log names a commit that never touched the path #18327 →0cc5ce856b98d7f9cd4666aada2e801e751d98ceat 2026-09-16T02:14Z (governed SKILL.md :89 +git-history.mjs touch; APPROVED 5217673315; provenance 5690856345; landing record 5691005304 posted 2026-09-16T02:16Z; the tool answers0cc5ce85for SKILL.md on the shared checkout without a fetch) · [Decision] permissions.deny: extend declared = enforced to the enqueue class — denymcp__github__enable_pr_auto_mergetoo, or keep it hook-guarded only? #18282 → PR fix(settings,pm): deny the MCP enqueue class — enable/disable_pr_auto_merge join lock 1 and the roster gate #18317 →ceb6b5fb46abcd…at 2026-09-16T02:16Z (governed.claude/settings.json+2 denies, the roster gate 17 = 17 onmain, rest-channel :53; APPROVED 5217679727; the head's one staleCheck Changesetred was the pre-label run, the queue accepted the entry; provenance 5690861787; landing record 5691031906 posted 2026-09-16T02:19Z); every residue stripped and read back; the four were one queue chain,merged_at02:08 / 02:13 / 02:14 / 02:16 · [finding] check-harness-current.mjs prints the graft boundary as a harness path's latest touch on a shallow checkout — the CURRENT / STALE verdict holds by construction, but the printed sha is not a reading of the path #18330 → PR fix(pm): check-harness-current prints boundary, not a fabricated sha, when a harness path's latest touch is not provable on the shallow checkout #18352 →1411cf2c6fd2c9e695682416c9e655869945f531at 2026-09-16T03:12Z (non-governedscripts/pm/check-harness-current.mjs: printsboundarywith the graft mechanism named, orunprovable, in place of a sha it cannot prove, through PR fix(pm): the charter latest-touch reading is taken depth-independently — a shallow clone's git log names a commit that never touched the path #18327's proven leg; 14-case self-test; record 5691229321, ACCEPT 5691229608; ready + auto-merge through the CCR routes at 2026-09-16T02:50Z — the ready flip answered 503 once, 200 on the retry; provenance 5691319500; three readings; landing record 5691481380 posted 2026-09-16T03:12Z) · the fold [finding] platform-readings: four rows describe MCPenable_pr_auto_merge/disable_pr_auto_mergebehaviour a seat can no longer reach once lock 1 denies the enqueue class (:41 · :49 · :58 · :60) #18320 + [finding] the seat's REST writes now land as a USER account, notclaude[bot]— the durability premise in platform-readings, #6015 and every Routine prompt is falsified #18334 → PR docs(pm): platform-readings retires the denied enqueue tool's rows and reads the REST token class per write, not per session #18359 →b57671edc1166d49be40993000894128b3a63b44at 2026-09-16T04:18Z (references tier, platform-readings.md only: the denied enqueue tool's four rows retired or re-keyed tool-neutral, the token-class rows re-keyed as seven — the class follows the Claude Code account, both dated flips, read on every write's read-back, the author-bound consequence; record 5691731467, ACCEPT 5691731638, the fold pointer 5691731802; ready + auto-merge through the CCR routes at 2026-09-16T03:58Z; provenance 5691817785; three readings; landing records 5691973200 / 5691973372 posted 2026-09-16T04:19Z); every residue stripped and read back. Queue reading 2026-09-15T06:29Z: the groups were chainedpr-18244→pr-18250→pr-18256→pr-18271→pr-18272(another lane's); each group'sLint & Repo Gatesjob runs 178 gate steps in ~30 min (thePM dispatch-gates self-teststep alone 520–540 s); Queue refs: served under the register's spelling (:154) — measured 2026-09-15T09:00Z, two refs, the second chained on the first's group commit; from now on landing records read the ref AND themerged_atinstant. Timers: NONE at sign-off — the patrol Routine and the accelerator were deleted (hand-off checklist step 6); the previous session's PR subscriptions on the four hung PRs are the only standing wake. Lane baseline this shift: dispatch → draft PR 20–66 min, report 1–18 min after the PR; ACCEPT → enqueue 5–20 min (CI-bound); enqueue →merged_at15–26 min for a lone entry, longer behind a chain. Maintainer ask carried from the finding(pm): 「简报写明本轮跑的层」is declared in SKILL.md and read by nothing — enforce-or-remove #18302 report (2026-09-15T15:56Z): theTier:spelling belongs in the runbook's brief template on all four axes, butdispatch-runbook.md(241/241) and SKILL.md (812/812) have zero ratchet headroom — the seat holds A (the H65 remedy text is the spelling's home) and asks the maintainer for one of B (name a redundant runbook line to pay) or C (raise the runbook ceiling by one, ruling quoted in the PR); the seat deletes no runbook rule on its own judgment. Harness reading (seat-side, not the register) 2026-09-15T12:45Z: the seat's command layer decodes a backslash-u-hex escape into the character before the shell sees it — a six-character U+FFFD escape typed into a quoted heredoc arrived on disk as the literal replacement character while a backslash-n in the same heredoc survived — so the record on PR fix(pm): post-stamped names the platform's known read-back normalisations and locates a real mutation #18298 first read 「spells<the replacement character>」; repaired in place with an edit note (the platform had stored exactly what was sent), and the seat types no backslash-u escape into a body it means to store verbatim.Governed Surface Queue Guardis required onmainbut pinned by no REQUIRED_CONTEXTS row — renaming its job detaches the governed-surface gate silently #15233 closed; body line removed; 5673580944) · 共享身份的限流纪律不存在：一次限流信号约束的是「身份」不是「客户端」，而规矩只说了不要重试 —— 2026-09-10 全 fleet 停摆事故 #17374 dead os-sales claim released (5673582323) and re-claimed · The M9.1 / M9.2 expression phases — including "astbecomes required in build output" — are asserted in six files and one published docs page, and defined in no ADR #17323 →pm:blocked+Blocked-by: #17849, assignee cleared (5673581724) · [finding] MCPsearch_issuesDID honour GitHub qualifiers (repo:is:label:) in two exact readings — the ledger's "qualifier form returns total_count 0" rule needs a second session before it stands or falls #16762 hold condition met →pm:queue(5673700002) · [PM decision] skills lane batch 9 — platform-readings.md third increment: raise the ceiling by the measured +39 (358 → 397); and the MCP write-pool quota sentence collision #15275 CLOSED completed (both items executed on 2026-09-04; 5673699398). Gradings (lane self-triage + stand-in routing), one audit comment each: into the queue — [finding] half-state H31 binds a PR to a card by itsPart ofline, so every correctly-gated epic tracker gets a row telling a seat to hang a gate nothing will clear #18229 p2 Bug · [finding] check-clause2-carriers: an unreadable or off-tierServed-tier:line is refused only beside a gate clear (C7) — a non-gated pair with the same record passes exit 0, against contract-review.md :29 「无此行不成裁决」 #18174 p2 Bug · finding(agents):.claude/agents/os-dev.md:288orders the dev seat to hangneeds:contract-reviewon the PR, and the dev's container forbids label writes — measured on two independent runs today #18181 p2 Bug · [finding] H64 fires on REST writes that #18205 made correct — itsREST implies claude[bot]premise was superseded, and its remedy cannot clear it #18237 p2 Bug · class (a):pnpm check:pm-dispatch-gatescannot complete inside the container's ~10-minute foreground cap — measured 9m0s then exit 124, twice; the wall-clock twin of #17708 #18201 p2 Bug · [finding] board-snapshot: the archive holds nothing above #17726 — the delta walk sits two days behind the live board while the per-run budget goes to history, so the 2026-09-14 suspension's cards were never captured #18137 p2 Bug · [finding] platform-readings: write identity is a per-session credential shape — installation →claude[bot], user-to-server → the human login withperformed_via_github_app: claude;GET /useranswers the human login in BOTH, so it is not the probe #18158 p3 Task · [finding] platform-readings: a phrase that only exists after joining (string concatenation, markdown emphasis, a wrapped line) reads 0 under a single-line grep in both directions — the instrument row PR #18194 could not fit into the rules layer #18195 p3 Task · finding(settings): permissions.deny omits mcp__github__update_pull_request — an MCP content write (title/body/draft) the charter now declares closed, and the seat's ready-flip fallback names the same tool #18218 p3 Task · [finding] issue 的 comments 字段可读出 1 而 list 与 timeline 两条通道都读 0 —— 可复现,带四张对照 #18219 p3 Task · [finding] check-clause2-carriers: a contract-review record whose head sha shares one code span with its key names NO head (H51_SHA_SPAN), so C6 reads 「no review of record」 where one exists — contract-review.md :28 never says the span holds the sha alone #18141 p3 Task · [finding] platform-readings: the session proxy serves CCR routes on api.github.com for ready-for-review, auto-merge, review threads and resolve — every seat landing action now has a REST spelling authored claude[bot] #18130 p3 Task · [finding] platform-readings: a suspended account's EVENTS are erased with its content (labels stay, thelabeledactor is gone) — and the one variable shared by the two suspended triage accounts is the hourly periodic-burst shape, not volume #18147 p3 Task · [finding] a PCRE negative lookahead followed by a character class silently loses its through the GitHub comment API — the published command then errors to stderr and prints 0, which reads as a clean absence #18258 p3 Task · [finding] objectui CI concurrency is keyed on the PR number, so re-running a superseded head cancels the current head — a re-run is a write, not a read #18262 p3 Task · [finding] platform-readings: in a merge-queue repository the squash commit's committer date is the ENQUEUE instant, not the landing —merged_atand themergedevent carry the fast-forward #18274 p3 Task (filed 2026-09-15T06:34Z); CLOSED — [finding] 「内容恒经 REST 代理(claude[bot])」 — the App IS the writer (performed_via_github_app: claude), but it uses a user-to-server token, so every seat write is bylined to a User account #18168 completed (by PR docs(pm,agents): write identity follows the channel, not the account — REST-only content writes, the ACCEPT refuses MCP writes, a stale shared checkout re-seats (#18205) #18216) · finding(pm-readings): the container REST proxy token is user-to-server in this session shape — seat writes land as the bound GitHub user via appclaude, not asclaude[bot]; the fact table and the write-identity invariant read true where they are false #18197 completed (by PR docs(pm,agents): write identity follows the channel, not the account — REST-only content writes, the ACCEPT refuses MCP writes, a stale shared checkout re-seats (#18205) #18216) · [finding]ccr/auto_mergestoresmerge_method: "merge"whatever you send — and names a method this repo forbids, so the documented read-back lands on a false alarm #18127 completed (already on the register) · finding(pm-dispatch): the dispatch order tells a dev never to touch a PR label while the same dispatch and the standing clause require hangingneeds:contract-review— two devs adjudicated it independently in one round; and the clause asks the dev for a--pairexit code only the seat can produce #18156 duplicate of finding(agents):.claude/agents/os-dev.md:288orders the dev seat to hangneeds:contract-reviewon the PR, and the dev's container forbids label writes — measured on two independent runs today #18181 · [finding] six more rules-layer sentences still state the retired human-merge ending after PR #18182 — SKILL.md :610 (two endings), :622/:672 + core-rules :128 (round-report item), AGENTS.md :255 (governed-prose anchor) / :799, the queue guard's refusal text #18185 not planned (value gate) · [finding] check-governed-merges.mjs :140 and check-required-contexts.mjs :288 still narrate one terminal — 「a human merge IS the review record」 — without ruling C's second (authorized approval ⇒ the claiming seat lands) #18150 not planned (outside the three classes) · finding(platform-readings): a PR-body PATCH carrying the Claude Code footer stores TWO footers on objectui, while the create path stores one — the fact table has no line for the edit path #18249 completed (rows :334–:335 / :338 / :399–:400 already carry every cell — this seat's second premise slip, corrected on the card) · [finding] platform reading: the PR-BODY create and edit cells disagree on footer appending over the same REST channel #18254 duplicate of finding(platform-readings): a PR-body PATCH carrying the Claude Code footer stores TWO footers on objectui, while the create path stores one — the fact table has no line for the edit path #18249.pm:queue, this lane, unassigned) at this refresh, in total order — 13: the snapshot with serial constraints is in the 接任台账 above ([finding] guard-governed-enqueue's slug reader keeps a.gitsuffix — a sibling cloned with the conventional URL never resolves, and a baregh pr merge Non such a clone derives a slug the API 404s on, so the guard fails OPEN #18366 p2 Bug first; then [cloud] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17163 · [finding] objectui's half-state findings reach no reader: the board has no anchor by ruling, and its copy of check-half-states still refuses in agent containers with the conclusion #13544 disproved #18290 · the [finding]post-stamped | tail -N && label-writesilently breaks the comment-before-label pairing — the pipeline returns tail's 0, so a REFUSED comment still lets the label land #18337 + [finding] REST 写侧强制头 Content-Type 的规则只住在 platform-readings.md —— 「动手前查一行」的 rest-channel.md 写侧段零提及、零交叉引用,一个班次内三席踩中 #18339 + [finding] rest-channel :54 still says the REST actor is 「按会话」claude[bot]or a user — the token class follows the Claude Code account and flipped inside one session twice; one in-place re-key pointing at the fact table #18360 fold · ADR-0135 的两处过期物随 #14361 的 Fixes 一起消失:Consequences 的 Until then 前件已过,:63 的 grep 配方读起来像通用总体筛而两个方向各错(本席自己误用两次) #18345 · [finding] git-history.mjstouchIsProvablereportsboundary: falsefor a registered graft boundary whose parent has since been fetched — the refusal is right, the flag and the reason text are wrong #18355 · Wirecheck-harness-current.mjs --self-test(PR #18352) into lint.yml's shallow-history self-test collector — a self-test nobody runs is the injurycheck-self-test-wiredexists for #18356 · Wirepnpm check:pm-expected-skips(PR #18357) into lint.yml beside the othercheck:pm-*steps — a self-test no workflow names is outsidecheck-self-test-wired's population #18358 · [finding] platform-readings :134 / :143 list the draft flip and the auto-merge mount as GraphQL-only and stand a seat down for them in a rate-limit window — both have live ccr routes, the only routes since lock 1 #18361 · platform-readings 的 detach 处方没说 pid 从哪来 —— 用 pgrep -f 重新推导会自匹配到包装器自己,监视器永远等自己 #18362 · [finding] guard-governed-enqueue's 「no checkout available」 fail-open is pinned by no self-test case in any environment — the case that claimed it never reaches it; one hermetic case with the injected empty root #18367). Cross-repo card [www.objectos.ai] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17165 (www) stayspm:awaiting-maintainer(moved by the triage seat at 2026-09-15T14:59Z). [finding] a PCRE negative lookahead followed by a character class silently loses its through the GitHub comment API — the published command then errors to stderr and prints 0, which reads as a clean absence #18258 (a negative lookahead immediately followed by a character class loses its!through the comment and issue write APIs — reproduced LIVE on this post's own body PATCH at 2026-09-15T06:04Z, so the spelling is not written here) and [finding] objectui CI concurrency is keyed on the PR number, so re-running a superseded head cancels the current head — a re-run is a write, not a read #18262 (a re-run of a superseded head under PR-keyed concurrency cancels the current head's run) are in the fold.pm:blocked— skills: evaluate whether the published security/platform guidance must teach the app-capability vs system-permission distinction and theisDefault→everyonebinding rule (after #17189) #17359 (An app-declaredcapabilitywithscope: 'org'counts as a high-privilege bit, so a set carrying only app capability tokens cannot bind to theeveryoneanchor #17189pm:awaiting-maintainer) ·hotcrmhas no half-state patrol anchor, so thepm:dispatched+ assignee residue after aFixesauto-close has now been repaired by hand seven rounds running #14881 ([repo:hotcrm] Install the half-state patrol in hotcrm — workflow copy, anchor issue, repository variable (hotcrm half of the ruled 纳入) #15009 open, hotcrm; assignee os-steve, not this seat's) · The M9.1 / M9.2 expression phases — including "astbecomes required in build output" — are asserted in six files and one published docs page, and defined in no ADR #17323 (Drop the M9.1 / M9.2 phase language frompackages/specandpackages/formula(the spec-seat half of #17323, ruled B) #17849) .pm:on-hold: none. Decision box (this lane): 0 — [Decision] AGENTS.md's comment rule vs preserved verbatim maintainer rulings that contain a model identifier — carve out quotations (A), treat them as violations (B), or leave it undecided (C) #18092 and [Decision] permissions.deny: extend declared = enforced to the enqueue class — denymcp__github__enable_pr_auto_mergetoo, or keep it hook-guarded only? #18282 both RULED A by the director seat at 2026-09-15T15:05Z / 2026-09-15T15:20Z and back in this lane as Tasks (in flight — see above).pm:awaiting-maintainer: [Decision] 22 pure-objectui defect cards live in objectstack underrepo:objectui, but objectui IS reachable — the seam fallback is being used where its precondition does not hold #17250. Anchors left to owners: PM corpus audit (maintainer-directed): classify every instruction line — keep / duplicate / demote / delete — then rewrite and re-lock every ratchet #13597 · Published-skills factual sweep: verify every behavioral claim in skills/** against the implementation — program anchor #13658 (pm:epic) · Skills catalog optimization program (maintainer-directed): audit every skill on both roots, then optimize — program anchor #14292 · [program] CLAUDE.md is a pointer to AGENTS.md in every repo — no second instruction set to maintain (maintainer 2026-09-09) #17161. objectui: gate: extendADR maintainer approvalpath predicate to.claude/skills/**— make Prime Directive #14 enforced (#9319 ruling) #9395 carriespm:retriage(A/B/C put to the maintainer 5661132913, unanswered).gen-sdui-manifest.shhardcodes port 5180 and one log path, so two concurrent runs in a container can dump the OTHER run's server #9578 did not reach this container (the attachment is absent from the session's attach and user-data folders) — the maintainer pastes the text on the direct channel for a relay post, or the ui seat posts it through the REST proxy channelpost-stamped.mjsuses, which the[Self-Approval]classifier has never refused for this seat; the write identity behind this seat is now os-zhuang's user authorization (the maintainer's own account swap, confirmed on the direct channel at 2026-09-16T02:16Z) — an approver account writing every seat artefact; the seat asked for a dedicated low-privilege GitHub user (or the App installation token) behind seat sessions and answers with the mechanics in the round report; the clause-② ruling 「同意」 is on [finding] Clause-②: yes on a non-spec, non-skills lane — the protocol says the contract-review-tier review is the spec seat's, but spells no handoff (who is asked, by which artefact), so a lane seat reaches for an in-seat PASS the harness classifier then refuses as self-approval #18349 and the objectui seat may proceed by its route A citing it; the board archive holds 17 records the live board no longer has — scheduled run 46 ofboard-snapshot(2026-09-15T02:31Z) is RED at exit 2,count_check.verdict = surplus(board 519 / archive 536), the tool's destruction signature, consistent with the 2026-09-14 suspension; the seat's grading correction on [finding] board-snapshot: the archive holds nothing above #17726 — the delta walk sits two days behind the live board while the per-run budget goes to history, so the 2026-09-14 suspension's cards were never captured #18137 had mis-readsurplusas the healthy state (corrected on the card 5675369063); the decision is the maintainer's —--restore=Nprints them back, agone.jsonledger entry quiets the red; the account this seat runs under is an approver account (os-zhuang) — writes read backclaude[bot]until 2026-09-15T20:04Z andos-zhuangfrom 2026-09-16T01:53Z, the assignee field andGET /useros-zhuang throughout; the fleet's GitHub identity (three routes in brief 5673402511 §4); the maintainer-level deny lever; the twopermissions.allowscript rules; [Decision] 22 pure-objectui defect cards live in objectstack underrepo:objectui, but objectui IS reachable — the seam fallback is being used where its precondition does not hold #17250 「重建」; the archive cadence ([finding] board-snapshot: the archive holds nothing above #17726 — the delta walk sits two days behind the live board while the per-run budget goes to history, so the 2026-09-14 suspension's cards were never captured #18137 landed delta-first without a cadence change); objectui gate: extendADR maintainer approvalpath predicate to.claude/skills/**— make Prime Directive #14 enforced (#9319 ruling) #9395 A/B/C; hidden cards of suspended accounts (numbers 18052 · 18055 and the os-musk set, written without the link form on purpose). Stand-in triage (代扫) RESUMED 2026-09-15T17:30Z — the triage seatsession_01VxjMEAhT53WHUCtP9WMrSUstood down at 2026-09-15T15:54Z on a harness-STALE reading (brief 5683457248, ⛔ not a maintainer order; [PM seat] triage (objectstack-wide) — 🟢 在席session_01WDxrLMPs5TyKB45RPiJuLo· R+244 · harness **CURRENT** · 写入身份os-sam(User)六轮稳定 · ⭐ **pm:retriage两仓清零** · 本轮:objectui#6653 改造为先测量 · #7997 关 completed → 残余立 #9593 · 更正本席 #18362 的行号漂移 · 欠账:objectui ①50/④34/finding 39 · objectstack ①31/③7+16/finding 35 · 决策箱 1(#18364 待一个字母)· ⚠️ #18172 仍是唯一 p1 · ⚠️ objectui domain:ui 席 #5560 因同一 harness STALE 于 04:45Z 收班 #6015 VACANT again; this seat'scheck-harness-current.mjsreads CURRENT): bare census 45 of 508 open at 2026-09-15T17:31Z; graded into this lane by SUBJECT — [finding] the enqueue bar 「每一个 check 全绿」 is unsatisfiable as written — every landing carries 7-10 skipped checks, and nothing distinguishes an expected skip from a path-filter miss #18308 p3 Task (5684935465) · On a shallow checkoutgit log -1 -- <path>names a commit that never touched the path — measured: the seating charter reading returned a real sha from an unrelated driver-test commit #18180 p2 Bug (5685139384) · [finding] 两份已发布 skills 仍教before*钩子整批触发,并推销一个没有生产者的诊断(HookConditionLimitation) #18221 p2 Bug (5685140167, lane self-triage) · AGENTS.md §3 criterion ③ tests the branch's WHOLE ancestry, so --force-with-lease is dead letter for every branch cut from main (measured: 33 pairs vs 1 scoped; control: main itself reads 32) #18178 p3 Task (5685139773) · [finding] objectui's half-state findings reach no reader: the board has no anchor by ruling, and its copy of check-half-states still refuses in agent containers with the conclusion #13544 disproved #18290 p3 Task (5685140479, lane self-triage); CLOSED — platform-readings: an absent merge-queue ref is not a negative enqueue reading — auto_merge reads null after a successful CCR arm #17958 completed (already on the register: platform-readings :10 / :13 / :14 / :63, rest-channel :52; 5685138733) · rest-channel.md overstates the ccr auto_merge body: the endpoint ignores merge_method (storesmergeeither spelling) and the queue decides the method — the wording invites a forbidden re-arm #18167 duplicate of [finding]ccr/auto_mergestoresmerge_method: "merge"whatever you send — and names a method this repo forbids, so the documented read-back lands on a false alarm #18127 (5685139102 — and its 「storesmergeeither spelling」 clause is refuted by this seat's arm of PR fix(pm): the half-state patrol reads a seat post's NEWEST comment page, and H44 knows the current marker spelling #18322, which echoedsquash; the register keys on the timeline event, never the echo);findingdropped at grading on [finding] the enqueue bar 「每一个 check 全绿」 is unsatisfiable as written — every landing carries 7-10 skipped checks, and nothing distinguishes an expected skip from a path-filter miss #18308 / [finding] 两份已发布 skills 仍教before*钩子整批触发,并推销一个没有生产者的诊断(HookConditionLimitation) #18221 / [finding] objectui's half-state findings reach no reader: the board has no anchor by ruling, and its copy of check-half-states still refuses in agent containers with the conclusion #13544 disproved #18290 (定级即离标 — [finding] the enqueue bar 「每一个 check 全绿」 is unsatisfiable as written — every landing carries 7-10 skipped checks, and nothing distinguishes an expected skip from a path-filter miss #18308's had been left on at 17:30Z, corrected 2026-09-15T17:45Z). Seat evidence CORRECTED on On a shallow checkoutgit log -1 -- <path>names a commit that never touched the path — measured: the seating charter reading returned a real sha from an unrelated driver-test commit #18180 (2026-09-15T18:29Z, in place with an edit note, from its dev's measurement): the marker recordedb3b43b6as the TIP, not as SKILL.md's touch (that was8c657f7, true), andgit show --staton a graft boundary prints the WHOLE file against the empty tree — the seat's zero was a grep for the full path against an abbreviated stat line; the defect stands on the boundary reading (9b00f9ffor lanes/skills.md). Two more bare cards filed by this seat for triage, NOT this lane's: [finding] measure-self-test-floor.mjs refuses to print any census on current main — its recogniser reads two landed handshake spellings as absent, so the instrument cannot answer the floor question anyone runs it for #18329 (measure-self-test-floor.mjsrefuses its census onmain— two landed handshake spellings unrecognised; from the [finding] check-half-states:H44_READING_TIMESTAMPrejects a minute-precision ISO stamp — theTbefore the hour is a word character, so the word-boundary anchor fails and the ruled spelling2026-03T00:21Zitself reads false #18323 report) · [finding] objectql hook-wrappers.ts: two docblocks still state the retired batch model for the before* dispatch of a predicate write in the present tense, while the code beneath binds per row #18331 (objectql/src/hook-wrappers.tsdocblocks :1083 / :1177 still state the retired batchbefore*model — same family as objectql's engine docblock still states the RETIRED per-rowpreviousrule — and it ships in the published .d.ts, so the next spec release makes two packages state opposite contracts #17975, different sites; from the [finding] 两份已发布 skills 仍教before*钩子整批触发,并推销一个没有生产者的诊断(HookConditionLimitation) #18221 report). Still bare and NOT this lane's by SUBJECT, left for the triage seat (the 45 include these): [finding]CLOUD_PROVIDED_OBJECT_NAMESmissessys_environment_credential(cloud DOES register it), and the spec still declaressys_tenant_database(cloud does NOT) #18309 (spec / cloud object names) · 把两个未接线的门禁接到 CI:check-issue-citations(diff 域裁决进 lint.yml 阻塞 + --census 进 half-state-patrol 只报告)与 check:merged-result(lint.yml 一条步骤) #18224 (CI wiring ofcheck-issue-citations—.github/workflows/**, devx / ci) · spec: export a typed hookctx.api(HookApi/HookObjectApi/HookQuery) — every metadata app hand-declares it today #18163 (spec: typed hookctx.api) · [finding] the liveness governance denominator is built from listMetadataTypeSchemaTypes(), soreport.ungovernedstructurally cannot name connector, sharing_rule or analytics_cube — the same sentence #17356 falsified, one gate over #18133 (metadata liveness denominator) · [finding] a nested RETIRED_KEYS_BY_MAJOR row is unverifiable — check (b2) passes a fabricated one, so a typo'd nested retirement registers silently and forever #17969 (RETIRED_KEYS_BY_MAJORcheck) · [finding]Check Changesetfails with an entirely empty check-run output, so two different refusals are indistinguishable from the API #18263 · [finding] ruling G item 6's third surface has no platform half:_statuscarries no reason, so a policy-disabled flow is indistinguishable from a broken binding — and objectui#9217 is blocked on a card that does not exist #18235 · [finding] check-widening-tells C5: narrowing a Zod key OUT ofz.unknown()fires T1 when the new value opensz.union(and declines when it does not — #17618's three-fact spend cannot express "the removed value accepted everything" #18234 · [finding] after #18230, service-analytics keeps a second refusal wording whose only stated justification is gone — the#5240one-condition-one-wording convention #18232 · 消融变异该走校验锚点的替换助手 ——perl -i家族已在两次被记录的消融里静默失败,模式各不相同 #18226 · [finding] 根 manifest 里 12 个 check:* 门禁没有任何 workflow 或聚合脚本调用 —— 它们从不运行,而绿 CI 读作合规 #18225 · [finding] tenant-audit 普查器的 ERROR 方向送不到 CI —— 门禁一次都没读 unledgered / staleLedgerRows #18211 · [finding] eslint.config.mjs 用一句今天为假的实测句给 query-options-erasure 的 SCOPE 做正当性说明 —— objectql 的 typecheck 有第三条腿 #18210 · class (c): a dottedmessagesid is authorable, schema-valid and resolves to nothing — and TranslationItemSchema's own @example teaches it, at two sites #18190 · contract(spec): shoulddependsOnbe authorable on a bulk action param?BulkActionParamSchemais not strict, so its accept is a null reading — andtoBulkParamnever consults the field defs, so the one spelling the renderer honours cannot reach the surface #18177 · [finding] check (c) has no proof shape for a strict-schema guidance retirement — on a reachable def such a key can never prove itself, and it passed only because proof 2 was broken #18132 · spec: the padded grouping-field refusal is trim-equivalence under UNICODE whitespace, but its .describe()/docs/ADR entry all say just "whitespace" #17962 · openapi-self-consistency.test.ts is a false red in any /tmp-rooted worktree — pnpm relative symlinks resolve through /tmp #17961 · [finding] seed-loader-state-machine-exempt.test.ts tells a future debugger to revert a flag that PR #17718 removes from SEED_OPTIONS #17938. Maintainer items added: objectui#9395 A / B / C (5661132913, open since 2026-09-14T08:24Z — A recommended; [finding] objectui's half-state findings reach no reader: the board has no anchor by ruling, and its copy of check-half-states still refuses in agent containers with the conclusion #13544 disproved #18290 waits on it); the two p2 rules-layer PRs will join PR docs(agents): the comment rule exempts a verbatim maintainer ruling preserved as a quotation block #18315 / PR fix(settings,pm): deny the MCP enqueue class — enable/disable_pr_auto_merge join lock 1 and the roster gate #18317 at the approvers.--sincethe brief's instant 2026-09-15T01:44Z, run 2026-09-15T01:58Z): objectstack + objectui audited, 0 governed merges; cloud / objectos / hotcrm UNAUDITED (no checkout) — INCOMPLETE. Second audit 2026-09-15T03:56Z, topological--since-ref objectstack=b3b43b6ea0c3 --since-ref objectui=75fca9669a3d: 4 + 4 mainline commits, 0 governed merges, clean. Third audit 2026-09-15T06:31Z,--since-ref objectstack=ecf91cb44194 --since-ref objectui=009f92d7a247: 3 governed merges, all this seat's and each with its record on the PR — pm-dispatch: reconcile the quota rows with the identity-bound rate limit; merged-write rule; account-suspension recovery readings #18242 (.claude/**×3, ruling C after os-zhuang's approval,merged_by os-zhuang), pm(skills): probe the unexercised CCR routes and the shared MCP user bucket into the REST channel register #18259 and fix(pm): say the head sha sits in a code span of its own, and name the refused spelling #18270 (references/**, in-seat contract-tier review,merged_by claude[bot]); objectui 0. Fourth audit 2026-09-15T07:24Z,--since-ref objectstack=1a02ef17d61b --since-ref objectui=88561fdc4856: 4 governed merges (fix(agents,gates): the merge queue blocks on seven contexts, and a set-stating surface is now a census #18244 AGENTS.md, docs(agents): the contract-review carrier is the seat's to hang;--pair PR-NUMBERis the only spelling #18250, docs(pm-dispatch): a triage direction landing in an adjudicated area quotes the governing line #18256, docs(agents): the os-dev terminal report carries its own session id #18273.claude/**), all ruling-C landings after os-zhuang's approvals with their records,merged_by os-zhuang; objectui 0; cloud / objectos / hotcrm unaudited every time (no checkout). Fifth audit 2026-09-15T09:59Z,--since-ref objectstack=9fa9955ab450 --since-ref objectui=88561fdc4856: 2 governed merges (PR pm-dispatch: six measured platform readings, and the search_issues qualifier rows rewritten onto what is measured #18279, PR pm-dispatch: three measured readings — the statesTheSet census, the enqueue instant, and the battery's cap-sized runtime #18287 —references/**, in-seat contract-tier reviews with their records,merged_by claude[bot]), objectui 0; cloud / objectos / hotcrm unaudited every time (no checkout). Sixth audit 2026-09-15T11:04Z,--since-ref objectstack=0865f4144354 --since-ref objectui=88561fdc4856: 0 governed merges (the two mainline commits since arescripts/pm/**only); cloud / objectos / hotcrm unaudited every time (no checkout). Seventh and eighth audits are in the previous body revisions. Ninth audit 2026-09-15T17:53Z,--since-ref objectstack=827cacbf4b79 --since-ref objectui=88561fdc4856with the three attached repos on the date window: 3 governed merges, all this seat's with their records — PR fix(settings,pm-dispatch): deny mcp__github__update_pull_request and route the ready flip through the CCR routes #18276 (.claude/**×3, ruling C,merged_by os-zhuang), PR docs(pm): platform-readings retires the rows that still describe MCP update_pull_request as a live channel #18307 and PR docs(pm): platform-readings reads the denied MCP wrapper's footer rows as history #18316 (references/**, in-seat contract-tier reviews,merged_by claude[bot]); objectui 0 of 3 mainline commits (itsmainmoved to4a94c38b); cloud 0 of 2; objectos 0 of 0; hotcrm 0 of 11 (tip975676dd1). Next, exactly:--since-ref objectstack=82b3032c475c --since-ref objectui=4a94c38b0bb7 --since-ref cloud=cb8ee7ff60c0 --since-ref objectos=cb0c1467b040 --since-ref hotcrm=975676dd1e83(objectstack's tip has since moved toa46cd8c4, ascripts/pm/**-only landing — the window from82b3032ccovers it). Coverage extended 2026-09-15T13:16Z: read-only checkouts at/home/user/cloud(attached),/home/user/objectstack-ai/objectosand/home/user/objectstack-ai/hotcrm(anonymous public reads; no API credentials, somerged_byattribution on those two returns 403 on every channel — an attach with push access is the maintainer's call, not this seat's). Baseline sweep--since 7dover the three (boundary 2026-09-08T13:16Z, backed off 3600 s): 9 governed merges, none of them this seat's, for the maintainer to recognise — cloud PR Epic: External Datasource Runtime — implement ADR-0062 (auto-connect, credentials, analytics, cleanup) #2163 (docs/adr/**×2, merged byos-zhuangat 2026-09-10T09:10Z) · objectos PR 🔗 Broken links detected in documentation #283 (the CLAUDE.md-pointer branch of [objectos] CLAUDE.md becomes a pointer to AGENTS.md — measure the pair first, then reduce to the pointer #17164; attribution UNAVAILABLE) · hotcrm PR fix(deps): pin esbuild ≥0.28.1 via pnpm-workspace overrides (GHSA-gv7w-rqvm-qjhr) #1910 · [P0] build-time vs runtime validation parity:objectstack buildaccepts metadata the runtime rejects #1876 · chore(changeset): backfill changesets for post-9.3 changes #1830 · feat(service-ai): visualize_data tool — return charts from AI data queries #1820 · docs(adr): revise ADR-0048 — package-scoped identity over per-item collision detection #1809 · docs(showcase+skill): ADR-0047 UX round 2 — tabs XOR dropdowns, no auto-derive #1798 · docs(adr): ADR-0041 — flow trigger family: taxonomy, naming, open-source core set #1746 (AGENTS.md/CLAUDE.md/ docs surfaces; attribution UNAVAILABLE). The pair (objectstack, objectui) reads history-horizon under the 7-day DATE window on these shallow clones and is covered by the topological windows above instead — not a gap. From here on every round audits all five topologically from the tips named in the refresh clause.session_01WDxrLMPs5TyKB45RPiJuLo· R+244 · harness **CURRENT** · 写入身份os-sam(User)六轮稳定 · ⭐ **pm:retriage两仓清零** · 本轮:objectui#6653 改造为先测量 · #7997 关 completed → 残余立 #9593 · 更正本席 #18362 的行号漂移 · 欠账:objectui ①50/④34/finding 39 · objectstack ①31/③7+16/finding 35 · 决策箱 1(#18364 待一个字母)· ⚠️ #18172 仍是唯一 p1 · ⚠️ objectui domain:ui 席 #5560 因同一 harness STALE 于 04:45Z 收班 #6015 was re-seated for R+238→R+242 and stood down again at 2026-09-16T02:58Z on a harness-STALE reading — VACANT; its R+240 routing of [finding] REST 写侧强制头 Content-Type 的规则只住在 platform-readings.md —— 「动手前查一行」的 rest-channel.md 写侧段零提及、零交叉引用,一个班次内三席踩中 #18339 / ADR-0135 的两处过期物随 #14361 的 Fixes 一起消失:Consequences 的 Until then 前件已过,:63 的 grep 配方读起来像通用总体筛而两个方向各错(本席自己误用两次) #18345 to this lane without pm state is the canonical exception (governed face ⇒ the skills seat grades), honoured at 2026-09-16T03:19Z.Hot-file serial queue
.claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md(812/812) +references/core-rules.md(151/151): PRs pm-dispatch: reconcile the quota rows with the identity-bound rate limit; merged-write rule; account-suspension recovery readings #182421a02ef17, docs(agents): the contract-review carrier is the seat's to hang;--pair PR-NUMBERis the only spelling #1825041ff021c, docs(pm-dispatch): a triage direction landing in an adjudicated area quotes the governing line #18256681317c3, fix(settings,pm-dispatch): deny mcp__github__update_pull_request and route the ready flip through the CCR routes #1827653dd5aaaLANDED → PR fix(pm): the charter latest-touch reading is taken depth-independently — a shallow clone's git log names a commit that never touched the path #18327 (On a shallow checkoutgit log -1 -- <path>names a commit that never touched the path — measured: the seating charter reading returned a real sha from an unrelated driver-test commit #18180, :89 in place, awaiting approval) → [finding] the enqueue bar 「每一个 check 全绿」 is unsatisfiable as written — every landing carries 7-10 skipped checks, and nothing distinguishes an expected skip from a path-filter miss #18308 (:629) SERIAL behind it..claude/agents/os-dev.md(403/403): PR docs(agents): the os-dev terminal report carries its own session id #18273 LANDED9fa9955a— free.references/platform-readings.md(463 onmainafter PR docs(pm): platform-readings reads the denied MCP wrapper's footer rows as history #18316; ceiling 466,ruledRaises×17): PRs docs(pm): platform-readings retires the rows that still describe MCP update_pull_request as a live channel #183076ef33128+ docs(pm): platform-readings reads the denied MCP wrapper's footer rows as history #1831682b3032cLANDED → [finding] platform-readings: four rows describe MCPenable_pr_auto_merge/disable_pr_auto_mergebehaviour a seat can no longer reach once lock 1 denies the enqueue class (:41 · :49 · :58 · :60) #18320 (SERIAL behind PR fix(settings,pm): deny the MCP enqueue class — enable/disable_pr_auto_merge join lock 1 and the roster gate #18317).references/rest-channel.md(82/82): PR fix(settings,pm-dispatch): deny mcp__github__update_pull_request and route the ready flip through the CCR routes #18276 LANDED (:53) → PR fix(settings,pm): deny the MCP enqueue class — enable/disable_pr_auto_merge join lock 1 and the roster gate #18317 ([Decision] permissions.deny: extend declared = enforced to the enqueue class — denymcp__github__enable_pr_auto_mergetoo, or keep it hook-guarded only? #18282, :53 again, awaiting approval)..claude/settings.json: PR fix(settings,pm-dispatch): deny mcp__github__update_pull_request and route the ready flip through the CCR routes #18276 LANDED (one deny) → PR fix(settings,pm): deny the MCP enqueue class — enable/disable_pr_auto_merge join lock 1 and the roster gate #18317 (+2 denies, awaiting approval) → the deny-roster gate reads 15 = 15 onmain, 17 = 17 on its head.scripts/pm/check-settings-deny-roster.mjs+package.json+lint.yml: PR feat(pm): a gate pins permissions.deny to the charter's content-write roster #18285 LANDED52c1a8c4— free.scripts/pm/post-stamped.mjs: PRs fix(pm): post-stamped counts a same-second later comment as after the acknowledged one #1829799d20cfd+ fix(pm): post-stamped names the platform's known read-back normalisations and locates a real mutation #18298827cacbfLANDED — free.scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs: PRs feat(pm): the half-state patrol reads the tier a triage round artefact names #1831110a7b9fa(H65), fix(pm): the half-state patrol reads a seat post's NEWEST comment page, and H44 knows the current marker spelling #18322a46cd8c4(the NEWEST-page memo) and fix(pm): H44's timestamp leg accepts an ISO instant whose hour follows a T — the ruled minute spelling no longer reads as untimestamped #18326de9c319a(the timestamp anchor) and fix(pm): the half-state patrol's seat legs read the triage post and the newest page — H44 reaches a vacant or Routine seat, H32 / H38 take their marker from the last page #18332a09725dd(the seat legs' population and window) LANDED — free.AGENTS.md(1075/1075): PR fix(agents,gates): the merge queue blocks on seven contexts, and a set-stating surface is now a census #18244 LANDED1297178e→ PR docs(agents): the comment rule exempts a verbatim maintainer ruling preserved as a quotation block #18315 ([Decision] AGENTS.md's comment rule vs preserved verbatim maintainer rulings that contain a model identifier — carve out quotations (A), treat them as violations (B), or leave it undecided (C) #18092, :441–:444, awaiting approval); PR docs(agents): write down the shape a --self-test must have to be capable of failing #18227 (ready) holds :1026+ → AGENTS.md §3 criterion ③ tests the branch's WHOLE ancestry, so --force-with-lease is dead letter for every branch cut from main (measured: 33 pairs vs 1 scoped; control: main itself reads 32) #18178 (:473–:474) SERIAL behind PR docs(agents): the comment rule exempts a verbatim maintainer ruling preserved as a quotation block #18315.skills/objectstack-formula/SKILL.md+skills/objectstack-data/references/data-hooks.md(published catalog, token ratchet 5367 / 6002 and 9884 / 12611 on the head): → PR docs(skills): before* hooks on a predicate write dispatch per row — the two published skills stop teaching a batch dispatch and a retired guard #18328 ([finding] 两份已发布 skills 仍教before*钩子整批触发,并推销一个没有生产者的诊断(HookConditionLimitation) #18221, awaiting approval)..claude/hooks/**: free → [finding] guard-governed-enqueue.selftest.sh: the case 「an exception-row path in a repo this container cannot resolve」 is not hermetic — it reads 54 passed / 1 failed on any box with a sibling/home/user/cloudcheckout, green in CI only because CI has none #18321 (held).scripts/pm/git-history.mjs: → PR fix(pm): the charter latest-touch reading is taken depth-independently — a shallow clone's git log names a commit that never touched the path #18327 (On a shallow checkoutgit log -1 -- <path>names a commit that never touched the path — measured: the seating charter reading returned a real sha from an unrelated driver-test commit #18180, thetouchmode, awaiting approval) → [finding] check-harness-current.mjs prints the graft boundary as a harness path's latest touch on a shallow checkout — the CURRENT / STALE verdict holds by construction, but the printed sha is not a reading of the path #18330 (scripts/pm/check-harness-current.mjs, consumes its exports) SERIAL behind it.scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs·check-clause2-carriers.mjs·check-dispatch-gates.mjs·board-snapshot.mjs·check-skill-line-ratchet.mjs·check-required-contexts.mjs·references/review-checklist.md(77/77) ·references/contract-review.md(60/60): free. Frame block :734–:755 md53327d02c56f8a0eca88569dad2270f32(unchanged on82b3032c, verified 2026-09-15T17:34Z).scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs(objectui copy): objectui#9395 (pm:retriage, the maintainer's answer).AGENTS.md(objectui): free.Notes
Job description:
references/lanes/skills.md. Standing facts carried forward (unchanged): value gate + reject authority from #13597;scripts/pm/**pure-code PRs land by in-seat contract-tier review → ready → queue, any governed.mdin the diff ⇒ draft at the governed terminal (four-piece, an authorized approval, then ruling C); path face viacheck-governed-merges.mjs --test(objectui:scripts/check-governed-queue-guard.mjs --test); read the PR's event log before touching a governed draft. Publication register: none of objectstack / objectui / hotcrm / objectos is registered here as deploying on a default-branch push ⇒ landing criterion = MERGED through the queue, its instant read frommerged_at(#18274). Tier policy:dispatch-gates.mjs --tieris the single source;skills/**, pm-dispatchSKILL.mdandos-dev.mdbuild at the contract-review tier;references/**, other.claude/skills/**,docs/adr/**andAGENTS.mdbuild at the default tier with the seat's contract-tier review. Channel facts: content writes go through the REST proxy only (⛔ no MCP write tool); labels / assignees / issue types throughscripts/pm/label-write.mjsand a RESTPATCHfortype; seat artefacts throughscripts/pm/post-stamped.mjs(the NOW token for this act's clock, the WAS token for a quoted instant, nothing else; a body refresh names the newest comment with--ack-through; a 1-byte read-back delta is the trailing newline, not the sanitizer);POST /issues/N/labelsand every other write needContent-Type: application/json; the search endpoint is not reachable through this proxy — dedupe by listing + grep with a control; job logs through MCPget_job_logs; theauto_mergeREST field reads null on a merge-queue repository — read theadded_to_merge_queuetimeline event or themerge_groupworkflow runs (GET /actions/runs?event=merge_group, whosehead_branchnames the chain). Checkouts:/home/user/objectstackon the session branch, fast-forwarded toorigin/mainas it moves (b57671edat this refresh; shallow, graft boundary9b00f9f9— and see #18180: the lanes/skills.md touch sha this seat's own marker recorded IS that boundary, not a reading of the path; the seat's two other claims about that marker were wrong and are corrected on the card);/home/user/objectuiat88561fd(itsorigin/mainmoved to4a94c38b, fetched 2026-09-15T17:45Z — audited in the ninth audit at 17:53Z — 3 mainline commits, 0 governed; no node_modules). Corrections the previous seat recorded on itself (kept as pointers; the full text is in the previous body revision): budget against the ratchet before dispatching; every instant is exact and goes through the quoted-stamp form; title PATCH after the body write succeeds; declare the payment section, not a line range, at a file's ceiling; read a card's newest comments before recording a ruling; a--pairreading's stamp is the measuring command's owndate. Corrections this seat recorded on itself this shift:count_check.verdict = surplusis the archive's destruction signature, not health (#18137); #18249 / #18254 were graded before the register was read; a landing instant ismerged_at, never the squash commit's date (#18274); aruledRaisesrecord is one per INCREMENT sized at its rows, not one per row (PR #18279's record); the dispatch's gate spellingscheck:pm-skill-line-ratchet/--test(real:check:pm-skill-ratchet,check:pm-governed-merges). Patrol timer: Routinetrig_01W822gWwQ64s2HfHUfkfKUN(self-bound, hourly at :02); an accelerator is armed only while devs are in flight.Generated by Claude Code