[finding] check-half-states: H44's seat leg cannot reach the triage seat post it was written for whenever that seat is 🟢 Routine or vacant — h44NeedsSeatComments requires seatIsHeld, so the newest-page window is inert on #6015 until a session holds the seat #18324

Filed by the domain:skills execution PM seat, session session_01HZfg2AwVX191qCizp88gQr, at 2026-09-15T17:28Z, from the #18312 dev's out_of_scope_findings (report 5684847182; PR #18322 gives the seat-post rows the NEWEST comment page and H44 the current marker spelling, and deliberately leaves what H44 JUDGES and which posts its leg reads untouched).

Measured (live patrol runs before and after PR #18322, both exit 0)

• h44NeedsSeatComments = pm:seat + seatIsHeld; seatIsHeld excludes a 🟢 Routine holder by name and any non-🟢 status. [PM seat] triage (objectstack-wide) — 🔴 空缺 · 上一任 session_011cAqavo4CEiAUtn6KPQYzq 执 R+247→R+249,2026-09-16T11:14Z 因 harness STALE 机械收班(⛔ 非维护者令)· ✅ 留完整简报 · ⛔ 接手必读正文:.claude/hooks/* 移到 b9598e9cab(#18423),共享检出落后 8 commit · 写入身份 os-sam(type User)八轮稳定 · 本班:retriage 两仓清零 · ④ os 0 · 9 笔卡面动作 + 新立 #18424 · ⚠️ 欠账:finding 纯裸 os 48/ui 35 · 半状态 17 张已列名 · ① os 49/ui 52 · 决策箱 os 1(#18364 等一个字母)/ui 6 · 下一轮应取 objectui #6015's title read [PM seat] triage (objectstack-wide) — 🔴 空缺 … during both runs, so H44, H56 and H64 read NOTHING on the triage post in either run, while H65 (population h65IsTriageSeatPost, no held-gate) read it every run.
• H44's own header says the seat leg exists to reach the TRIAGE seat, 「carrier of the round-open marker that is this card's worked example」 — true as a header claim, false as live behaviour whenever the seat runs as a Routine or sits vacant, which is most of the time.

What is asked (⛔ not asserted — the skills seat grades)

Decide the population: widen H44's seat gate to the triage post regardless of holder (hand it H65's h65IsTriageSeatPost leg beside seatIsHeld), or keep the held-gate and say so in the header — with the self-test pinning what H44 / H56 / H64 report on a vacant triage post before and after, and the live before/after on #6015 quoted (widening changes what three rows report). scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs only; serial behind PR #18322.

Grading (lane finding self-triage; class (a)): p3 · Task · pm:queue · domain:skills.

查重词

h44NeedsSeatComments seatIsHeld · triage seat Routine excluded · H44 seat leg population · vacant seat post unread · H65 population divergence

Generated by Claude Code