Repository navigation
Open
Labels
Description
Bug summary
The depth testing of points depends only on their coordinates and doesn't take into account the camera angle.
mpl-3d-depth.mp4
Code for reproduction
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
colors = [
0x010101, 0x050405, 0x080809, 0x0d0b0c, 0x0d101e, 0x110e0f, 0x11192f, 0x151213,
0x161419, 0x171514, 0x18181a, 0x182133, 0x1d191b, 0x1e2741, 0x1f1c1d, 0x214e92,
0x221e11, 0x222121, 0x23539c, 0x264b76, 0x285ba6, 0x2860ae, 0x2866b3, 0x29272c,
0x293551, 0x2a2322, 0x2a6bbb, 0x2b71c0, 0x2b75c3, 0x2c2d2f, 0x2c3544, 0x2d2b23,
0x2d63b0, 0x2e68b4, 0x2f79c8, 0x306ab8, 0x306cbd, 0x3070bf, 0x307ecc, 0x3175c2,
0x3183d0, 0x323031, 0x362e2e, 0x363536, 0x366fbb, 0x3683d0, 0x3773c0, 0x3777c3,
0x3779c8, 0x3880ca, 0x3889d4, 0x3b2920, 0x3b3630, 0x3b3a3c, 0x3b3c43, 0x3b90d8,
0x3c2018, 0x3c2f1f, 0x3c3938, 0x3e7dc3, 0x3e7fc8, 0x3e8cd4, 0x3f84cc, 0x3f86d1,
0x403536, 0x412e2d, 0x4190d7, 0x4194d9, 0x42371f, 0x423828, 0x438fd2, 0x4398db,
0x444242, 0x463e41, 0x464648, 0x473c3c, 0x485064, 0x488ad2, 0x4898dc, 0x4989cb,
0x4a3930, 0x4a4b50, 0x4a93d7, 0x4b3c37, 0x4b8ac6, 0x4b9ede, 0x4c4f59, 0x4e452c,
0x4e91cf, 0x4f453c, 0x504537, 0x505055, 0x534842, 0x534c49, 0x535b69, 0x5398d8,
0x53a2e0, 0x545050, 0x559ddd, 0x566674, 0x5681ab, 0x57a7e1, 0x585959, 0x58a0d8,
0x58a3dd, 0x5995ca, 0x5999d1, 0x5aa6dd, 0x5bace1, 0x5daee4, 0x633f32, 0x63524f,
0x644543, 0x645954, 0x64605e, 0x646263, 0x64656b, 0x64b1e5, 0x655241, 0x657487,
0x659cc9, 0x65a4d2, 0x65aadb, 0x65ace2, 0x6790b3, 0x686a6e, 0x695f53, 0x6a6e73,
0x6a96bd, 0x6ab5e6, 0x6b7479, 0x6b7e8a, 0x6db1e3, 0x6db5e2, 0x6e86a1, 0x6ea4cb,
0x70acd8, 0x73aad2, 0x747477, 0x747f89, 0x74b0da, 0x75b8e6, 0x76574a, 0x774f3a,
0x775b55, 0x776a66, 0x787b7c, 0x78b8e1, 0x7a6955, 0x7a736c, 0x7e8790, 0x7ea6c6,
0x7f97ad, 0x7fb5da, 0x808285, 0x80bbe2, 0x817e7c, 0x81afd0, 0x84bfe2, 0x87888a,
0x88725f, 0x88b7d8, 0x897353, 0x8a7a6c, 0x8abedc, 0x8b959e, 0x8d8379, 0x8e5134,
0x8e8b8b, 0x8e9396, 0x90adc6, 0x90b3ce, 0x91a0aa, 0x91bdd9, 0x92604f, 0x92795f,
0x929291, 0x92b9d1, 0x94806c, 0x95bdd7, 0x96938b, 0x989a9d, 0x999897, 0x9a8779,
0x9b9283, 0x9cbfd8, 0x9d9174, 0x9da4aa, 0x9e9f9f, 0xa1846b, 0xa4a5a7, 0xa57c60,
0xa5abae, 0xa6b9c6, 0xa6bdc9, 0xa7a29d, 0xa99e8f, 0xa9b6c0, 0xaa946f, 0xaaaaaa,
0xac946b, 0xac9773, 0xacafb1, 0xacb2ba, 0xad9a77, 0xad9c84, 0xaf5f25, 0xafaa9e,
0xb09e7d, 0xb0b1b1, 0xb3b8bb, 0xb4bec3, 0xb5b4b2, 0xb77750, 0xb7a68d, 0xb8b8b4,
0xb9a985, 0xbaa246, 0xbbbbbc, 0xbbc4c9, 0xbcaf8f, 0xbcb4ab, 0xbcc1c1, 0xbd732d,
0xbeceda, 0xc1b29c, 0xc1c3c3, 0xc2b9ac, 0xc4beb0, 0xc5c5c4, 0xc6cac8, 0xc6ccce,
0xc7b590, 0xc8bc9d, 0xcbc5bf, 0xcec3ad, 0xceccc6, 0xcfd0cf, 0xd1c09d, 0xd3cec4,
0xd3d2d1, 0xd5d5d6, 0xd6c7ac, 0xd6d0c7, 0xd8d7cf, 0xd9dbda, 0xdbcfb1, 0xdcd1c2,
0xe1d8c8, 0xe2e0db, 0xe5e5e4, 0xe8dfcb, 0xeeece9, 0xf4f5f6, 0xfdfcfb,
]
ax = plt.figure().add_subplot(projection="3d")
for c in colors:
r, g, b = c >> 16 & 0xff, c >> 8 & 0xff, c & 0xff
ax.plot(r/0xff, g/0xff, b/0xff, "o", color=f"#{c:06x}")
plt.show()Actual outcome
Whether we look from an angle or the opposite one, we always have the higher coordinates visible in front (the clear ones, that is the closest to (1,1,1)).
Expected outcome
The darker points ((0,0,0)) should be in front when looking from the "bottom" angle, and the lighter points from the other angle (like currently).
Additional information
No response
Operating system
Arch
Matplotlib Version
3.6.2
Matplotlib Backend
GTK3Agg
Python version
3.10.8
Jupyter version
No response
Installation
Linux package manager
Activity
tacaswell commentedon Dec 18, 2022
I suspect that #23085 addresses this ?
ubitux commentedon Dec 18, 2022
Just tested but unfortunately it doesn't seem to make a difference.
astromancer commentedon Mar 31, 2023
Just FYI, you can use
scatter3Dfor this:ubitux commentedon Mar 31, 2023
Oh that's great, and it even fixes the problem, thank you!
color-quantization: use scatter3D instead of plot for colors in 3d pr…