Skip to content

Should Catalan dels be a particle? Joan dels Reis reads middle dels, family Reis #1059

Open

Description

@derek73

What happens today. dels (Catalan, "of the", plural) is in no vocabulary file, so it is read as an ordinary name word:

Maria dels Àngels Puig   →  given 'Maria', middle 'dels Àngels', family 'Puig'
Joan dels Reis           →  given 'Joan', middle 'dels', family 'Reis'

The first reading is right, but only by accident: it holds because dels is not a particle. Its singular del and the other particles chain forward into the family (rules/P2), so Maria de les Neus Puig reads family de les Neus Puig.

Why it was held back, and why that reason is gone. A #704 comment kept dels out of ca.toml, because making it a particle would move Maria dels Àngels Puig into the family, and the marked-word property moved nothing by default. Since #1058, rules/P10 (a given name a particle completes) reads a particle run plus a word marked after_particle as a middle name by default. Measured on master (2026-11-04) with Lexicon.default().add("dels", kind="article").add("àngels", kind="given", after_particle=True):

Maria dels Àngels Puig          →  middle 'dels Àngels', family 'Puig'        (unchanged)
Maria dels Àngels Puig i Vidal  →  middle 'dels Àngels', family 'Puig i Vidal' (unchanged)
Joan dels Reis                  →  family 'dels Reis'                          (moves)

Evidence so far (tools/name_usage.py --boxes, 2026-11-04):

  • dels: ORCID 8 given boxes (Spain 5) and 2 family boxes, over the whole extract; none on the UK PSC register.
  • àngels: ORCID 94 given boxes (Spain 51, Andorra 1) and 4 family boxes.

Both are thin, and the given-box dels records are the dels Àngels given name, not a surname.

To decide:

  • Is there a population of Catalan surnames written with dels (dels Reis?) large enough to measure? Without one, the change protects nothing and moves no realistic name.
  • Which kind dels would take (article, as del does in ca.toml).
  • Whether àngels (and mercè, neus, carme) get after_particle. The ORCID bar decisions/O7 used (≥ 90%, ≥ 10 given records) is met by àngels alone, if at all.

Recorded as Open in decisions/P10. Split out of #704.

Activity

  1. added this to the 3.1 milestone on Nov 4, 2026
  2. added
    vocabularyFixed by a word-list entry: per-word vocabulary and language packs
    on Nov 4, 2026
  3. self-assigned this
    on Nov 5, 2026
  4. added
    particlesParticles and surname prefixes (rules/P)
    and removed on Nov 10, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

particlesParticles and surname prefixes (rules/P)vocabularyFixed by a word-list entry: per-word vocabulary and language packs

Projects

No projects

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions