Jump to content

Sunnyside Yard

Coordinates: 40°44′59″N 73°55′37.37″W / 40.74972°N 73.9270472°W / 40.74972; -73.9270472
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

40°44′59″N 73°55′37.37″W / 40.74972°N 73.9270472°W / 40.74972; -73.9270472

Aerial view of dozens of parallel railroad tracks filled with parked passenger train cars, with low-rise industrial buildings on either side
Southern part of Sunnyside Yard looking east from Queens Boulevard overpass

Sunnyside Yard is a large coach yard in the Sunnyside neighborhood of Queens, New York City. Owned by Amtrak and also used by New Jersey Transit and the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR), the yard was built by the Pennsylvania Railroad (PRR) and completed in 1910 with an as-built footprint of 192 acres (0.78 km2) and 25.7 miles (41.4 km) of track.[1] The yard served as the principal storage and servicing facility for PRR trains using Pennsylvania Station in Manhattan, to which it is connected by the East River Tunnels.

The yard incorporates Harold Interlocking, described as of 2012 as one of the busiest rail junctions in the United States,[2][3] where Amtrak's Northeast Corridor crosses the LIRR Main Line and the Hell Gate Line. A balloon track at the yard's eastern end is used to turn Amtrak and NJ Transit trains terminating at Penn Station. Following the Penn Central merger of 1968 and that company's bankruptcy, the yard passed to Conrail and then to Amtrak in 1976; Amtrak continues to own and operate the facility.[4]

Since the opening of Grand Central Madison in January 2023, some LIRR trains pass through tunnels beneath the yard as part of the East Side Access project. The MTA's Penn Station Access project, which will bring Metro-North Railroad service into Penn Station via the Hell Gate Line with four new stations in the eastern Bronx, is expected to further increase rail traffic through Harold Interlocking; full completion was rescheduled in 2025 to 2030.[5]

Decades of railroad operations left soil, sewer, and groundwater contamination at the yard, which was listed in the 1980s as a Class 2 site in the New York State Registry of Inactive Hazardous Waste Disposal Sites and has been remediated under NYSDEC oversight across six operable units.[4][6] Amtrak and the LIRR are also among the potentially responsible parties named for the adjacent Newtown Creek Superfund site.[7]

Beginning in 2017, the New York City Economic Development Corporation (NYCEDC) studied constructing a deck over the rail yard to support affordable housing. A 2020 master plan envisioned 12,000 affordable housing units alongside 60 acres (24 ha) of parks and public space, but the proposal lay dormant during the COVID-19 pandemic.[8] In February 2026, Mayor Zohran Mamdani revived the proposal, asking the federal government for $21 billion to build the deck and 12,000 affordable homes after meeting with President Donald Trump in Washington, D.C.; reactions among Queens elected officials and community groups have been mixed.[9][10][11]

Site and layout

[edit]
Black-and-white architectural drawing showing a long elongated rail yard with multiple parallel tracks, loop tracks at one end, and surrounding street grid
"General Plan of Sunnyside Yard," prepared by resident engineer Louis H. Barker in 1906 and submitted to the New York City Board of Estimate
Tall, narrow brick industrial building with multiple windows and a chimney, set against a clear sky
Former boiler house and substation, part of the yard's original electrification infrastructure

Sunnyside Yard occupies a roughly triangular site in western Queens, bounded approximately by Northern Boulevard to the north, Honeywell Street and the Long Island Expressway to the east, Queens Boulevard and Skillman Avenue to the south, and the East River Tunnels portal area to the west. As built in 1910, the yard had an overall length of 8,815 feet (2,687 m), a maximum width of 1,625 feet (495 m), and an initial footprint of 192 acres (0.78 km2) with 25.7 miles (41.4 km) of track.[1][12] At completion, the yard was divided into a North Yard and a South Yard. The North Yard initially contained 42 tracks with capacity for 526 passenger cars; the South Yard contained 45 tracks with a 552-car capacity, with provision to expand the South Yard by 32 additional tracks for a further 309 cars.[12] Although the yard is "stub-end" in geographic terms (sitting at the end of the division), it functions as "double-end" in terms of train movements, served by two loop tracks running from the East River Tunnels around the yard to its eastern end.[13] The NYCEDC has used a working figure of 180 acres (73 ha) for the modern rail-yard footprint considered for air-rights development.[14]

The shared tracks of the LIRR Main Line and Amtrak's Northeast Corridor adjoin the yard.[14] The adjacent Sunnyside Gardens Historic District (north of the yard) was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1984 and the Hunters Point Historic District (west of the yard) was designated by the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission in 1968.[15] Northeast of the yard, the balloon track is used to turn Amtrak and NJ Transit trains that terminate at Penn Station, returning them to the East River Tunnels via the yard.[13] Harold Interlocking, located at the yard's eastern end, governs movements among the Northeast Corridor, the Hell Gate Line, and the LIRR Main Line.[3]

History

[edit]
Multi-story brick interlocking tower with a sloped roof, located trackside at a railway junction
Harold Tower, from which the main line alongside the yard was formerly controlled
Black-and-white photograph showing two parallel bridges, a road bridge in the foreground and an elevated subway bridge behind, crossing a wide rail yard
Honeywell Street Bridge and elevated subway bridge crossing Sunnyside Yard, photographed by Jack E. Boucher in 1977 as part of the Historic American Engineering Record's Northeast Railroad Corridor survey (HAER NY-121)[16]

Site before 1903

[edit]

The Sunnyside Yard footprint lies within the historic settlement area of Dutch Kills in western Queens. Burger Brocard (or Bragaw), a French Huguenot exile from Mannheim in the Rhenish Palatinate who had emigrated to Manhattan in 1675, in 1690 acquired about 87 acres at Dutch Kills on the site where Burger Jorissen had built a grist mill a century earlier; the property descended through several generations of the Brocard/Bragaw family.[17][18] Richard Bragaw built a gambrel-roofed house in the English style atop Sunnyside Hill in 1790, on the line of present-day 32nd Place halfway between Northern Boulevard and Skillman Avenue, within what would become the yard footprint.[19] The area takes its name from "Sunnyside Hill," the Bragaw family estate at Dutch Kills established with that 1690 purchase and consolidated under Brocard's son Isaac in 1713;[18][20] a "Sunnyside" roadhouse built along Jackson Avenue in the 1850s for visitors to the Fashion Course in nearby Corona has also been cited as the source of the neighborhood name.[21] The surrounding area was annexed to Long Island City when that city was incorporated in 1870 and consolidated into the City of Greater New York in 1898.[22]

Beginning in September 1902, agents of the Pennsylvania Railroad quietly purchased the houses and land between Skillman Avenue and Northern Boulevard from 21st Street east to 43rd Street near Woodside. The railroad's plan for a yard at the site became public on June 2, 1903, after its protest the previous day against a proposed Sunnyside street that would have cut through the planned yards within 200 feet of the East River Tunnel portal. Long Island Rail Road president William H. Baldwin Jr. confirmed the broad outlines of the scheme to The New York Times, which described the planned terminal yards as "to be the greatest in size in the world."[23][24] The broader Pennsylvania Railroad landholding in the area eventually amounted to about 600 acres (240 ha), of which the yard's as-built 192-acre (78 ha) footprint occupied a portion.[25] Most of the colonial farmhouses on the site were demolished in 1903, including the Richard Bragaw house in July of that year.[23] In 1907–1908, the railroad leveled an approximately 200-acre (81 ha) hill (50 to 60 feet (15 to 18 m) high) at 34th–35th Streets and used the spoil to fill more than 250 acres (100 ha) of tidal marshland at the headwaters of Dutch Kills, a tributary of Newtown Creek, to a depth of 10 to 30 feet (3.0 to 9.1 m); an estimated 2,500,000 cubic yards (1,900,000 m3) of earth had been moved for the leveling and fill operation by 1909.[23][12]

Construction (1903–1910)

[edit]
Sepia-toned photograph of an empty newly-built railroad yard with rows of parallel tracks stretching to the horizon
View east across the South Yard about 1910, shortly after opening

The Pennsylvania Railroad acquired the Sunnyside site as part of the New York Tunnel Extension, the broader initiative through which the PRR built Pennsylvania Station and the East River Tunnels to bring its Long Island and New England trains directly into Manhattan.[26] The PRR's subsidiary, the Pennsylvania Tunnel and Terminal Railroad Company, was incorporated for the project.[4] Part of the site already lay along an existing Long Island Rail Road right-of-way to the north shore, which was temporarily shifted southward during construction.[12]

A Board of Engineers organized in January 1902 oversaw the New York Tunnel Extension; Alfred Noble served as chief engineer for the East River Division, with Louis H. Barker as resident engineer for Sunnyside Yard.[27][12] The New York City Board of Estimate formally approved the yard plan on February 15, 1907, alongside the contract authorizing the New York Connecting Railroad;[28] The New York Times described the project that May as "the largest electric car yard in the world."[29] Excavation, contracted to the Degnon Realty and Terminal Improvement Company under resident engineer Waldo C. Briggs, began in December 1906 and was completed in late 1909; track laying was finished about a year later.[12] Approximately 3,000,000 cubic yards (2,300,000 m3) of earth were moved using steam shovels and construction trains, with six street viaducts, two under-grade crossings, and seven concrete-and-steel railroad bridges constructed within the yard.[12]

The yard was built from the start as an electric facility, served by a power station in Long Island City opposite 34th Street that had been in operation since 1905, when the Long Island Rail Road electrified its Atlantic Avenue branch.[30] All electric generation, substation equipment, and locomotive and multiple-unit motive power for the New York Tunnel Extension was supplied by the Westinghouse Electric & Manufacturing Company.[31] Every yard track was third-rail equipped to allow trains to be moved by electric locomotives without steam, and concrete trenches between alternate tracks carried air, water, steam, and battery-charging conduits to each car on each track.[13] Throughout the yard and the connecting tunnel approaches, switches, automatic stops, and semaphore signals were operated by an electro-pneumatic system supplied by the Union Switch & Signal Company and controlled from eleven cabins housing 516 working levers, four of them within Sunnyside Yard.[32] Service buildings, designed by the Pennsylvania Tunnel and Terminal Railroad Company's engineering staff under Noble and George Gibbs and constructed by the John W. Ferguson Company of Paterson, New Jersey, included an Inspection Building and Machine Shop (160 by 71 ft (49 by 22 m)), a Boiler House and Sub-station (153 by 50 ft (47 by 15 m)), a Stores and Commissary Building (358 by 67 ft (109 by 20 m)) for Pullman and dining-car supplies, a Battery Repair Building, an Oil and Lamp House, and additional storage and Pullman cleaning sheds.[33] Track laying was completed about a year after the December 1909 finish of excavation,[12] in time for the September 8, 1910 opening of the East River Tunnels for Long Island Rail Road service into Pennsylvania Station;[34] through service via the Hudson River Tunnels followed at midnight on the night of November 26–27, 1910, when the first regular train departed at 12:02 A.M.[35]

Factories surrounded the yard. On the south side, the Degnon Terminal industrial district included businesses served by rail siding, among them the American Chicle Company chewing gum factory, the Eveready Battery Company battery factory, and the Loose-Wiles Biscuit Company (Sunshine Biscuits) factory.[36] Adjacent to the Degnon district, the Swingline stapler factory occupied a 160,000-square-foot (15,000 m2) building at 32-01 Queens Boulevard from 1951 until production was relocated to Mexico in 1999.[37] To the immediate south of the yard, the City Housing Corporation purchased a 77-acre (31 ha) tract from the Pennsylvania Railroad in 1924 to develop the Sunnyside Gardens planned community (1924–1928), one of the earliest American garden suburbs.[15] The City Housing Corporation, founded by Alexander M. Bing and modeled on England's Letchworth and Welwyn Garden City limited-dividend companies, opened the first 128-unit phase in November 1924 with Clarence Stein as chief architect; The New York Times reported the corporation had acquired 1,100 lots projected to house roughly 700 families.[38]

Pennsylvania Railroad era (1910–1968)

[edit]
Black-and-white photograph of the rounded rear end of a streamlined passenger railcar with "The Jeffersonian" sign, parked in a coach yard
Observation car of the Pennsylvania Railroad's Jeffersonian at Sunnyside Yard, May 1948

After completion, Sunnyside Yard served as the principal storage and servicing facility for Pennsylvania Railroad trains operating into and out of Pennsylvania Station via the East River Tunnels.[13][12] The yard accommodated cleaning, inspection, and turning of long-distance trains between runs; in its early years, Pullman cars accounted for about 40 percent of the equipment handled.[39] As built, the 33rd Street tubes of the East River Tunnels were assigned to LIRR trains and the 32nd Street tubes to PRR moves to and from Sunnyside.[13] Other carriers also worked into the yard via Penn Station: by 1940, Lehigh Valley Railroad trains were operating through the East River Tunnels to Sunnyside, a practice that became the subject of a National Railroad Adjustment Board ruling on crew pay.[40] In 1928, the Pennsylvania Railroad established a training school and dietetical kitchen at the yard for its dining car stewards, cooks, and waiters, the third such school after similar facilities in Columbus and Chicago.[41]

The yard saw recurring labor unrest in its early decades, much of it concentrated at the Honeywell Street viaduct overlooking the tracks. In January 1911, just two months after the yard opened, more than 100 strikers raided the grounds in a heavy fog, firing into the air to frighten the "several hundred porters and car cleaners" at work; about fifteen were arrested at the viaduct on rioting charges.[42] A strike by the yard's car cleaners turned violent in November 1915, when about fifty male and female strikers clashed with police at the same viaduct over the arrest of a striker who had tried to prevent a strikebreaker from returning to work; seven were arrested, and a Pennsylvania Railroad special patrolman had been killed by a westbound electric train earlier in the strike.[43] During the nationwide 1922 railroad shopmen's strike, pickets stoned buildings and Pullman cars from the overhead viaducts; after women were reported smuggling stones onto the viaducts in baby carriages, police barred carriages from the walkways and required pedestrians to keep to the road's center. The Pennsylvania Railroad housed Black workers brought in as strikebreakers in yard buildings, where they overhauled Pullman cars.[44]

Both railroads shared the yard from its opening, with the LIRR using a portion for midday equipment storage and servicing.[45] The LIRR's trackage agreement with the PRR over the Sunnyside Yard tracks and East River Tunnels was the subject of an unsuccessful challenge by the New York Transit Commission and the State of New York; in Transit Commission v. United States, the Supreme Court affirmed in April 1933 that such joint-use arrangements fell under federal Interstate Commerce Commission jurisdiction rather than state regulation.[46] The LIRR sold its ownership share of the yard on September 29, 1961; New York State purchased the LIRR itself from the Pennsylvania Railroad in 1966. The LIRR continues to maintain a right-of-way through the yard.[4]

In the predawn hours of April 14, 1945, Franklin D. Roosevelt's funeral train passed through Sunnyside Yard en route from Pennsylvania Station to Hyde Park via the Hell Gate Bridge. Robert Klara's history of the funeral train describes the wartime yard as "alive with activity," with the Pennsylvania Railroad having "marshaled virtually anything that rolled," including coaches, troop sleepers, and freight cars converted to passenger use, to accommodate the 109 million passengers who passed through Pennsylvania Station in 1945.[47]

Penn Central, Conrail, and Amtrak (1968–present)

[edit]

The Pennsylvania Railroad merged with the New York Central Railroad on February 1, 1968, to form Penn Central. Following Penn Central's bankruptcy, the United States Railway Association's 1975 Final System Plan identified Sunnyside Yard, in conjunction with Penn Station, as a major passenger shop facility for "running repairs to 'G' locomotives, Metroliner coaches and commuter cars," and proposed a new shop to handle existing equipment and Amtrak's then-planned turbo trains.[48] Under the 3R Act, Amtrak assumed the maintenance-of-equipment workforce at Penn Station and Sunnyside Yard on February 11, 1976, as part of a phased takeover of former Penn Central passenger operations.[49] Property ownership of the yard passed to Conrail on April 1, 1976; the same day, Conrail conveyed Sunnyside as part of the broader Northeast Corridor designation to Amtrak for $87 million payable over eight years.[4][49] NJ Transit and the LIRR remain the principal additional operators using the yard.[14]

In April 2017, an NJ Transit derailment caused by a weakened wooden tie at Penn Station's "A" Interlocking, west of Sunnyside Yard, initiated an emergency Amtrak track-replacement program that disrupted service through Penn Station for several months.[50] The MTA cancelled or diverted 26 LIRR PM-rush trains away from Penn Station to Hunterspoint Avenue (on the southern edge of Sunnyside Yard) and to Atlantic Terminal in Brooklyn.[51]

Operations

[edit]
Wide rail yard photographed at dusk with rows of parked passenger trains and a tall blue-glass office tower visible in the distant background
The yard at dusk from the east; One Court Square (formerly the Citigroup Building) in background at left

The yard is used principally for the storage, servicing, cleaning, and turning of long-distance and commuter passenger trains operating into Pennsylvania Station.[14] Amtrak operates the yard for its Northeast Corridor and other intercity services; New Jersey Transit uses it for trainsets that terminate at Penn Station, deadheading them through the East River Tunnels between revenue runs; and the Long Island Rail Road uses portions of the area for selected operations, accessing it through Harold Interlocking.[14][3]

Harold Interlocking

[edit]
Main article: Harold Interlocking

Harold Interlocking, a 14-track junction located at the yard's eastern end, was created in 1910 to handle East River Tunnel traffic at the opening of Pennsylvania Station and was named that year for Harold Avenue, since renamed 39th Avenue after Long Island City was absorbed into New York City at the end of the 19th century.[3] As of 2012, it was the busiest rail junction in the United States,[2] handling roughly 600 commuter trains and 48 Amtrak trains daily, all directed since the mid-1990s from a centralized computer control post in Pennsylvania Station.[3] The interlocking governs movements among Amtrak's Northeast Corridor (continuing east via the Hell Gate Line toward New England), the LIRR Main Line (continuing east into Long Island), and trains entering or leaving the yard. The interlocking's complexity and high traffic volume have produced frequent delays and occasional accidents. On July 23, 1984, two Amtrak trains traveling on the same northbound track collided head-on at about 10:45 a.m. on the Hell Gate Line viaduct in Astoria, just east of Harold Interlocking, after the southbound track had been temporarily closed for catenary maintenance; one passenger was killed and 125 were injured.[52] On March 19, 1990, a freight tank car carrying 33,000 gallons of liquid propane derailed inside the yard where the tracks pass under Queens Boulevard and the IRT Flushing Line viaduct; out of concern that the cargo could ignite, the Fire Department ordered electrical power to nearby subway and railroad tracks shut off for several hours, halting service on the 7, E, F, N, R, and G subway lines and stranding tens of thousands of commuters; service was restored shortly after midnight, with no leaks or injuries reported.[53] Weeks later, on the first night of Passover in 1990, a power surge left thousands of LIRR commuters stranded at Harold; the LIRR subsequently replaced the switching system at the interlocking over the summer of 1990.[3][54]

In May 2011, a $294.7 million federal grant was awarded to address congestion at Harold Interlocking. The reconstruction provided dedicated tracks to the Hell Gate Line for Amtrak trains arriving from or bound for New England, allowing them to bypass NJ Transit and LIRR traffic.[55][56] The work also replaced relay-based interlocking logic with a microprocessor-based system.[55][56] Cost overruns attributed to coordination problems between the MTA and Amtrak pushed the price of the broader East Side Access work at Harold to nearly $1 billion by April 2018.[57] By early 2023, some of the interlocking improvements were complete, with remaining work scheduled for late 2025.[58]

East Side Access

[edit]
Main article: East Side Access

As part of the East Side Access project, which created a new LIRR terminal at Grand Central Madison (opened January 25, 2023), some LIRR trains diverge from the Main Line and travel through the 63rd Street Tunnel and four bored tunnels beneath Sunnyside Yard to reach Grand Central Madison.[59] Queens-side construction included extending the 63rd Street tunnel under Northern Boulevard and boring four tunnels beneath the yard.[59] The project also constructed a 33-acre (13 ha) Mid Day Storage Yard immediately northwest of Sunnyside Yard, with 24 storage tracks for LIRR trainsets, under a $351 million prime construction contract awarded to Tutor Perini.[60][61]

Penn Station Access

[edit]
Main article: Penn Station Access

Penn Station Access is an MTA project to extend Metro-North Railroad service from the Bronx into Penn Station via the Hell Gate Line, with four new ADA-accessible stations in the eastern Bronx (Hunts Point, Parkchester/Van Nest, Morris Park, and Co-op City).[62] Governor Kathy Hochul led a groundbreaking ceremony on December 9, 2022; the design-build contract was awarded to a Halmar International–RailWorks joint venture in December 2021, and the MTA projected the total project cost at $3.18 billion (following a 2022 capital-plan amendment that included expansion of the New Rochelle Yard), with a $500 million Amtrak contribution and an originally planned 2027 service date.[63] The project requires substantial work at Harold Interlocking, including a Westbound Bypass routing Metro-North trains through the yard area,[64] plus 3 miles (4.8 km) of new third rail and two new DC substations at Gate and Woodside, since Metro-North's M8 cars cannot operate under Amtrak's 25-Hz traction power.[65]

In October 2025, the MTA reported that Amtrak had delivered only 7 of 48 promised track outages, pushing full completion of Penn Station Access to 2030, with three of the four Bronx stations potentially still opening in 2027.[5][66] The New York Times reported in 2026 that city officials had considered creating a new passenger rail station at the yard since at least 2018, but the MTA had opposed the proposal in recent years on cost grounds.[9]

Environmental remediation

[edit]

Decades of railroad operations at Sunnyside Yard left contamination including polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), semivolatile organic compounds (SVOCs), polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), lead, and petroleum hydrocarbons. PCB contamination has been attributed in part to losses from train-mounted transformers, while the petroleum plume in the yard's north-central area has been linked to nine former underground fuel-oil storage tanks at the site of the former Engine House (Operable Unit 3), excavated as part of remediation.[6] The yard was added to the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC) Registry of Inactive Hazardous Waste Disposal Sites as a Class 2 site in the 1980s; under NYSDEC oversight, the site (#241006) has been divided into six operable units covering soil, separate-phase petroleum hydrocarbons, and the yard's sewer system. A 1996 cleanup program removed PCB-contaminated sediment from impacted sewer manholes, with later remedial actions targeting the 8-acre (3.2 ha) petroleum plume in the yard's north-central area through recovery wells.[4][6][67]

Amtrak and the Long Island Rail Road have also been named among 27 potentially responsible parties for the Newtown Creek Superfund site, whose final addition to the National Priorities List was announced by the EPA on September 27, 2010.[68][69][7] City Limits reported in March 2020 that the yard's hazardous-waste status was among the concerns raised by community groups during NYCEDC's master-planning process; the Justice for All Coalition criticized the engagement process for marginalizing residents of the adjacent Queensbridge Houses NYCHA development.[67]

Air-rights and development proposals

[edit]

A series of proposals dating to the 1920s have envisioned constructing a deck over Sunnyside Yard to support residential, commercial, and open-space development; none had advanced to construction as of 2026. According to the New York City Economic Development Corporation, Amtrak completed a major infrastructure upgrade of the yard in 2014, which the agency cited as creating an opportunity to consider extending neighborhoods over the rail facility.[14] Such proposals have been compared with the analogous Hudson Yards development built over Manhattan's West Side Yard.[70]

Earlier proposals (1925–2015)

[edit]

In October 1925, the State Transit Commission's chief executive officer Philip Mathews and Commissioner LeRoy Harkness proposed building a new suburban railroad terminal in Sunnyside Yard to relieve congestion at Pennsylvania Station and Grand Central Terminal. The plan would have diverted a portion of Long Island Rail Road, New Haven, and Westchester & Boston commuter trains to the new terminal, routing New England trains in via the Hell Gate Bridge and the New York Connecting Railroad and connecting the terminal to the BMT and IRT elevated lines at Queensboro Plaza by a 0.4-mile (0.64 km) spur. Mathews estimated the project would cost about $7 million, take twelve months to build, and add 22,000 rush-hour seats. The plan envisioned an office building above the terminal to offset costs, but the New Haven and Westchester railroads objected to the Hell Gate Bridge diversion; in November 1925 the commission agreed to proceed with an LIRR-only version of the terminal with engineering led by the city's Board of Transportation, but this compromise plan was also never built.[71][72][73] A few years later, the Regional Plan Association's First Regional Plan of 1931 envisioned a similar Sunnyside-Yard terminal, calling for "the construction of a new transportation terminal and office building... of a size that would dominate all this part of the Borough of Queens."[74] In 1971, the New York State Urban Development Corporation reportedly developed a plan featuring 20-story apartment buildings and a shopping mall over the yard, though the plan was not advanced.[75] In 1973, Governor Nelson Rockefeller proposed a development above the yard that would have included two racetracks and a football stadium; that proposal was likewise not advanced.[75]

In January 1984, the New York State Urban Development Corporation (UDC) created a Sportsplex Corporation subsidiary to study sites for a professional sports complex in New York City, with developer Donald Trump (then owner of the USFL's New Jersey Generals) named to the new agency's board; Trump had already been privately scouting sites and was reported by The New York Times to be focused on three locations, including the Penn Central rail yards in Sunnyside.[76] By March 1984, the proposed dome at Sunnyside was being criticized in the Times for the added construction cost of building on a raised platform above the rail yard and for relying on the 59th Street Bridge as the only direct car access, which would require new highways through Astoria, Maspeth, and Sunnyside.[77] Trump's stadium ambitions subsequently shifted to other locations.[75]

During the Bloomberg administration, the concept resurfaced again. In his 2006 State of the City address Bloomberg promised a citywide strategic land-use plan that evolved into PlaNYC;[78] Deputy Mayor Daniel Doctoroff commissioned a then-unreleased report that recommended decking over Sunnyside Yard among other large-scale interventions.[79] In November 2014, Doctoroff (by then CEO of Bloomberg L.P.) published a New York Times opinion piece proposing relocation of the Jacob K. Javits Convention Center to Sunnyside Yard. The Doctoroff plan called for a 3.1-million-square-foot convention center on a deck over the rail yard, paired with roughly 14,000 housing units (about half affordable), more than two million square feet of office and retail space, hotels, public open space, and a new transit center, at an estimated cost of $8 billion based on analysis prepared for him by SHoP Architects and HR&A Advisors. Doctoroff proposed financing the platform and convention center largely through the sale of the existing Javits site, which he valued at about $4 billion, with the difference covered by incremental tax revenue from the new development.[80] In his February 2015 State of the City address, Mayor Bill de Blasio proposed building a platform over the yard to accommodate up to 11,250 affordable housing units;[81] within hours, Governor Andrew Cuomo's communications director Melissa DeRosa rejected the proposal, stating that the MTA used Sunnyside as "an important facility for our transportation system, and it is not available for any other use in the near term."[82][83]

2017 feasibility study and 2020 master plan

[edit]

In February 2017, the NYCEDC and Amtrak released a feasibility study, prepared by FX FOWLE Architects, examining three full-yard development scenarios accommodating 14,000 to 24,000 housing units (4,200 to 7,200 affordable), and a more refined "Core Yard" scenario covering roughly 70 acres (28 ha) with 11,000 to 15,000 units (3,300 to 4,500 affordable).[84][85] In May 2018, Deputy Mayor Alicia Glen led a revival of the overbuild concept following the study, convening a 41-member steering committee of public officials, business representatives, and community leaders to develop a master plan over 18 months. The architectural firm led by Vishaan Chakrabarti was engaged to oversee the planning process.[70] Amtrak, which owns roughly 142 of the yard's 180 acres, supported the planning effort; chairman Tony Coscia told The New York Times that the topographical challenges of the site were significant but tractable.[70] The proposal generated significant local opposition focused on density, displacement, the affordability of units, pedestrian and road connections, open space, and proximity to a Superfund site;[86][87] Melissa Orlando of the local advocacy group Access Queens, who served on the steering committee, said she had not encountered any Queens residents who supported the plan, citing concerns about housing displacement, overcrowded subway service, an overtaxed utility grid, and sewage overflow into the Newtown Creek Superfund site.[70] A September 2019 public meeting was interrupted by protesters chanting "We Don't Trust this Process!"[87] The Justice for All Coalition, a community group focused on environmental justice, criticized NYCEDC's outreach for marginalizing residents of the adjacent Queensbridge Houses NYCHA development and argued that the plan would not meet community needs.[67] In January 2020, U.S. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Council Member Jimmy Van Bramer jointly opposed the project, and Ocasio-Cortez resigned from the project's steering committee, citing concerns about the planning process and community input.[88]

In March 2020, NYCEDC and Amtrak released the Sunnyside Yard Master Plan, calling for a deck over the yard supporting 12,000 housing units (all designated as affordable housing), 60 acres (24 ha) of parks and public plazas, and a proposed regional rail station.[89][90] NY1 reported the plan as a roughly $14 billion proposal.[91] The plan went largely dormant during the pandemic and the de Blasio administration's final years; Gotham Gazette reported in September 2022 that progress had stalled.[8]

Mamdani revival (2026)

[edit]

On February 26, 2026, Mayor Zohran Mamdani met with President Donald Trump at the White House to seek federal investment in the Sunnyside Yard project; during the Oval Office meeting, Mamdani presented Trump with two Daily News front pages, an authentic reproduction of the 1975 "Ford to City: Drop Dead" cover and a mock-up bearing the headline "Trump to City: Let's Build" announcing a "New Era of Housing." Mamdani's tweet of the event drew 28.5 million views.[9][10][92][93] The revived proposal called for roughly $21 billion in federal funds to build the deck and 12,000 affordable homes, of which 6,000 would be modeled on the Mitchell-Lama Housing Program as cooperative and subsidized ownership units.[10][89] Mamdani estimated the development would create 30,000 union jobs and described the project at a February 27, 2026 news conference as "the largest rail deck the world has ever seen."[9] AmNewYork framed his federal pitch in opposition to the Ford-era "Drop Dead" period of federal disinvestment from New York.[94] A spokeswoman for Governor Kathy Hochul signaled tentative support; an Amtrak spokesman declined to comment, and the White House declined The New York Times 's requests for comment.[9]

Reactions to the revived proposal were mixed. Council Member Julie Won, who represents the area, called the proposal "a failed housing project" and convened an April 2026 town hall at Sunnyside Community Services that drew nearly 200 residents; attendee responses at the town hall were roughly divided among support, opposition, and those wanting more information.[95][96] Queens Community Board 2 chair Anatole Ashraf told the Queens Daily Eagle the proposal "came out of left field" with no prior community-board presentations.[97] Queens Borough President Donovan Richards said he was "excited about the proposition" of restarting the project but called for a "robust community engagement process" before it advanced.[9] Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso expressed reservations about relying on Trump-administration commitments, citing the long-stalled Gateway tunnel project.[95]

Supporters included Ocasio-Cortez, whose spokeswoman characterized the federal investment as potentially "transformational" while reserving judgment on plan details.[9][95] Carlo Scissura, president of the New York Building Congress and a former member of the de Blasio-era Sunnyside Yard task force, said he was "over the moon" at Trump's apparent receptivity.[9] Alicia Glen, who had led the 2018 master-planning effort as Deputy Mayor, called the announcement "directionally positive" but warned that requirements for fully affordable housing and union construction would make the financing "untenable unless [federal funders] throw the entire budget at it."[9] Crain's New York Business described the deck plan as gaining "steam under Mamdani."[98] Writing in The Nation, columnist D. D. Guttenplan argued that Mamdani's "theatrics" had backfired by reinforcing Trump's image as a strongman commanding deference.[93] In a City Limits op-ed, planners Cali Williams and Jack Robbins argued for smaller, terra-firma development on adjacent sites such as the Skillman Avenue and Arch Street Yards as a faster, less costly alternative to constructing a multibillion-dollar deck.[99]

[edit]

Sunnyside Yard appears as a setting in director James Gray's 2000 crime drama The Yards.[100] The yard also figures in Jack Houghteling's 2023 novel Sunnyside, set in western Queens.[101]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ a b Couper 1912, p. 76.
  2. ^ a b Bibel 2012, p. 83.
  3. ^ a b c d e f McGeehan, Patrick (May 22, 2012). "Guiding Hundreds of Trains, a Junction Named Harold". City Room. The New York Times. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
  4. ^ a b c d e f Record of Decision, Amtrak Sunnyside Yard, Operable Unit 5 (PDF) (Report). New York State Department of Environmental Conservation. March 2012. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  5. ^ a b Martinez, Jose (October 27, 2025). "MTA Rails Against Amtrak for Delays to Metro-North Penn Station Connection". The City. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  6. ^ a b c Amtrak Sunnyside Yard Draft Upland Site Summary (PDF) (Report). Amtrak. May 2012. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  7. ^ a b "About the Superfund Site". Newtown Creek Community Advisory Group. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  8. ^ a b Khurshid, Samar (September 13, 2022). "What Happened to the Sunnyside Yard Master Plan?". Gotham Gazette. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  9. ^ a b c d e f g h i Rubinstein, Dana; Zaveri, Mihir; Chen, Stefanos (February 27, 2026). "Can Mamdani (and Trump) Build a Neighborhood Over a Queens Rail Yard?". The New York Times. Retrieved May 5, 2026.
  10. ^ a b c Maldonado, Samantha (February 27, 2026). "Mamdani Seeks to Restart Sunnyside Housing Plan, But Needs Billions From Feds". The City. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  11. ^ Kim, Seung Min (February 26, 2026). "Mamdani pitches Trump on housing with mock newspaper in latest White House visit". PIX11. Associated Press. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
  12. ^ a b c d e f g h i Couper 1912, p. 92.
  13. ^ a b c d e Couper 1912, p. 70.
  14. ^ a b c d e f "Sunnyside Yard". New York City Economic Development Corporation. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  15. ^ a b Sunnyside Gardens Historic District Designation Report (PDF) (Report). New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission. June 26, 2007. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  16. ^ "Northeast Railroad Corridor, Amtrak Route between New Jersey/New York and New York/Connecticut State Lines (HAER No. NY-121)". Historic American Engineering Record, National Park Service. April 1977. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
  17. ^ Seyfried 1984, p. 79.
  18. ^ a b Hazelton 1925, p. 946.
  19. ^ Seyfried 1984, pp. 79–80.
  20. ^ Morrison 2016, p. 59.
  21. ^ Jackson 2010, p. 1266.
  22. ^ Haller, Vera (March 18, 2015). "Sunnyside, Queens: A Bit of Tradition Among the Trendiness". The New York Times. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  23. ^ a b c Seyfried 1984, p. 82.
  24. ^ "Tunnel Terminal in Long Island City; Is to be Greatest in Size in the World. William H. Baldwin, Jr., Gives the Broad Outlines of the Scheme — Switch Yard for Motor Cars". The New York Times. June 3, 1903. p. 16. Retrieved May 15, 2026.
  25. ^ Hazelton 1925, p. 943.
  26. ^ Couper 1912, pp. 10–11.
  27. ^ Couper 1912, p. 10.
  28. ^ "Connecting Road Wins; Coler's the Only Vote Against the Contract with the City". The New York Times. February 16, 1907. p. 8. Retrieved May 13, 2026.
  29. ^ "Pennsylvania Tube Work; Contracts Let for Approaches to Tunnels in Long Island City". The New York Times. May 19, 1907. p. 3. Retrieved May 13, 2026.
  30. ^ Couper 1912, p. 73.
  31. ^ Couper 1912, p. 107.
  32. ^ Couper 1912, p. 104.
  33. ^ Couper 1912, pp. 115–116.
  34. ^ "Excursions Speed Through New Tubes; Pennsylvania and Long Island Companies Entertain Officials with Trips Under the City". The New York Times. August 31, 1910. p. 4. Retrieved May 13, 2026.
  35. ^ "OPEN PENNSYLVANIA STATION TO-NIGHT; First Regular Train to Use the Hudson River Tubes Starts at 12:02 A.M. Sunday". The New York Times. November 26, 1910. p. 5. Retrieved May 5, 2026.
  36. ^ "The Degnon Terminal Industrial Area". Queens Public Library Digital Archives. Retrieved July 15, 2023.
  37. ^ Marzlock, Ron (November 25, 2015). "Swingline was part of the Long Island City skyline". Queens Chronicle. Archived from the original on October 19, 2018. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
  38. ^ "Housing for Wage Earners". The New York Times. November 16, 1924. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
  39. ^ Couper 1912, p. 14.
  40. ^ Gnaedinger, L. B. N. (September 29, 1940). "Railroads Protest Methods of Board; National Adjustment Agency in Chicago Attacked in Brief on Labor Disputes". The New York Times. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
  41. ^ "Training School for P.R.R. Stewards". The New York Times. October 27, 1928. p. 32. Retrieved May 15, 2026.
  42. ^ "Strikers Fight in the Fog; Several Hurt In Attempt to Force Pennsylvania's Laborers to Quit". The New York Times. January 14, 1911. p. 2. Retrieved May 15, 2026.
  43. ^ "Women Stone Policemen; Striking Car Cleaners in Pennsylvania Sunnyside Yards Riot". The New York Times. November 12, 1915. p. 6. Retrieved May 15, 2026.
  44. ^ "All Rail Strikers Dropped by Roads; Can Return Only as New Workers, Managers Decide at Conference". The New York Times. July 4, 1922. p. 1. Retrieved May 15, 2026.
  45. ^ Morrison 2016.
  46. ^ Transit Commission v. United States, 289 U.S. 121 (April 10, 1933).
  47. ^ Klara 2010.
  48. ^ United States Railway Association (September 18, 1975). Final System Plan for Restructuring Railroads in the Northeast and Midwest Region Pursuant to the Regional Rail Reorganization Act of 1973: September 1975 Supplemental Report (PDF) (Report). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office. p. 61. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
  49. ^ a b Baer, Christopher T. "A General Chronology of the Pennsylvania Railroad Company, Its Predecessors and Successors and Its Historical Context: 1976" (PDF) (April 2015 ed.). Pennsylvania Railroad Technical & Historical Society / Hagley Museum and Library. p. 4. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
  50. ^ "Amtrak: Weakened Wooden Railroad Tie Caused Derailment". WAMC. Associated Press. April 6, 2017. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
  51. ^ "26 PM Rush Hour LIRR Trains From Penn Station to Be Cancelled or Diverted as Amtrak Crews Continue Work on Tracks Damaged in Monday's NJ Transit Derailment" (Press release). Metropolitan Transportation Authority. April 4, 2017. Archived from the original on April 5, 2017. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
  52. ^ Prial, Frank J. (July 24, 1984). "Amtrak Crash in Queens Kills 1 and Injures 125". The New York Times. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
  53. ^ McQuiston, John T. (March 20, 1990). "Derailed Car Stops Transit To Queens". The New York Times. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
  54. ^ Lyall, Sarah (July 3, 1990). "'Waiting for Harold,' a L.I.R.R. Saga". The New York Times. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  55. ^ a b "Maloney Hails Federal Grant to Ease Amtrak Delays in NYC, Spur High-Speed Rail in NE Corridor". Office of Congresswoman Carolyn B. Maloney. May 9, 2011. Archived from the original on September 28, 2011. Retrieved May 13, 2011.
  56. ^ a b Colvin, Jill (May 9, 2011). "New York Awarded $350 Million for High-Speed Rail Projects". DNAinfo.com. Archived from the original on May 13, 2011. Retrieved May 13, 2011.
  57. ^ Castillo, Alfonso A. (April 15, 2018). "East Side Access price tag now stands at $11.2B". Newsday.
  58. ^ Milestone Report; Network Expansion—Regional Investments (Report). New York: Metropolitan Transportation Authority. Retrieved February 8, 2023.
  59. ^ a b "East Side Access". Metropolitan Transportation Authority. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  60. ^ "ESA CQ033 Mid Day Storage Yard". Tutor Perini Corporation. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  61. ^ "MTA awards Sunnyside Yard contract". Railway Age. Simmons-Boardman. n.d. Retrieved May 7, 2026.
  62. ^ "Penn Station Access". Metropolitan Transportation Authority. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  63. ^ "Governor Hochul Announces Groundbreaking of Metro-North Penn Station Access Project" (Press release). Office of the Governor of New York. December 9, 2022. Archived from the original on December 9, 2022. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
  64. ^ "Contract CH057A2: Design Build Services for Westbound Bypass Part 2, Harold Regional Investments Project". Metropolitan Transportation Authority Construction and Development. November 30, 2023. Retrieved May 7, 2026.
  65. ^ "Amtrak / Metro-North Penn Station Access Project". GFT, Inc. September 26, 2024. Retrieved May 7, 2026.
  66. ^ Colon, Dave (October 28, 2025). "Amtrak's Dithering Means Penn Access Won't Be Done Until 2030, MTA Says". Streetsblog NYC. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  67. ^ a b c Kully, Sadef Ali (March 10, 2020). "Immediate Steps Seen for Sunnyside Development Plan". City Limits. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  68. ^ "Newtown Creek Site Profile". United States Environmental Protection Agency. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  69. ^ "EPA Makes Final Decision: Newtown Creek is Added to Superfund List" (Press release). U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. September 27, 2010. Retrieved May 7, 2026.
  70. ^ a b c d Stapinski, Helene (August 16, 2018). "Is a Rail Yard in Queens the Site of New York's Next Mega-Development?". The New York Times. Retrieved March 7, 2020.
  71. ^ "Ask Queens Station as Commuter Base; Harkness Suggests Terminal for Westchester Travelers in Long Island City". The New York Times. October 1, 1925. p. 1. Retrieved May 15, 2026.
  72. ^ Duffus, R. L. (October 11, 1925). "Commuter Burden on City Traffic Increases; Harkness's Proposed $7,000,000 Station in Queensborough for Relieving Strain of Suburban Travel Brings to Fore Various Solutions of Complicated Problem". The New York Times. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
  73. ^ "Commuter Terminal Plan Is Agreed On; Harkness Says Commission Is Ready to Build Station for the Long Island Alone". The New York Times. November 13, 1925. p. 21. Retrieved May 13, 2026.
  74. ^ "A Vision for Sunnyside Yards, 86 Years Ago". Regional Plan Association. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  75. ^ a b c Cuza, Bobby (March 4, 2026). "Where Mamdani wants housing, Trump once imagined a stadium". NY1. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  76. ^ Gottlieb, Martin (January 20, 1984). "U.D.C. to Survey Need for Professional Sports Complex in City". The New York Times. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
  77. ^ Bartosiewicz, Tom (March 25, 1984). "Why Brooklyn Needs a Dome...and How to Get It". The New York Times. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
  78. ^ "How Mayor Michael Bloomberg Thought Big on Climate". Scientific American. Retrieved May 7, 2026.
  79. ^ Sokol, David (October 2006). "Nine Million Stories in the Naked City?". The Architect's Newspaper. Archived from the original on August 20, 2019. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
  80. ^ Doctoroff, Daniel L. (November 30, 2014). "New York's Next Big Thing". The New York Times. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
  81. ^ "State of the City: Mayor de Blasio Puts Affordable Housing at the Center of 2015 Agenda" (Press release). Office of the Mayor of New York City. February 3, 2015. Archived from the original on February 6, 2015. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
  82. ^ Hawkins, Andrew J. (February 3, 2015). "Cuomo throws cold water on two de Blasio plans". Crain's New York Business. Retrieved May 7, 2026.
  83. ^ Hawkins, Andrew J.; Anuta, Joe (February 7, 2015). "Sunnyside on track for major land grab". Crain's New York Business. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
  84. ^ New York City Economic Development Corporation; Amtrak (February 6, 2017). Sunnyside Yard Feasibility Study: Executive Summary (PDF) (Report). City of New York. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
  85. ^ Parry, Bill (February 6, 2017). "City releases Sunnyside Yard feasibility study". QNS. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
  86. ^ Ludovici, Derek (June 5, 2019). "The Dark Side of Sunnyside Yards". The Indypendent. Retrieved July 22, 2019.
  87. ^ a b Shapiro, Gideon Fink (February 1, 2020). "Sunnyside Up". New York Review of Architecture. Retrieved January 19, 2023.
  88. ^ Kromrei, Georgia (January 24, 2020). "Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Resigns from Sunnyside Committee". The Real Deal. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
  89. ^ a b "City and Amtrak Release Long-Term Sunnyside Yard Master Plan With New Model: Transit-First, All-Affordable" (Press release). New York City Economic Development Corporation. March 3, 2020. Archived from the original on April 7, 2020. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
  90. ^ Parry, Bill (March 3, 2020). "City releases long-term Sunnyside Yard Master Plan promising new public transit and 100 percent affordable housing". amNewYork. Archived from the original on March 4, 2020. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
  91. ^ McGowan, Clodagh (March 5, 2020). "City Unveils $14 Billion Master Plan to Develop 180 Acres of Sunnyside Yards". NY1. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
  92. ^ "Mayor Mamdani Meets With President Donald Trump to Advance Federal Investment in Affordable Housing" (Press release). Office of the Mayor of New York City. February 27, 2026. Archived from the original on February 27, 2026. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
  93. ^ a b Guttenplan, D. D. (March 5, 2026). "How the Theatrics of Mamdani's Trump Meeting Backfired". The Nation. Archived from the original on March 5, 2026. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
  94. ^ Daly, Adam (February 26, 2026). "From 'Drop Dead' to 'Let's Build': Mamdani pitches Queens housing development to Trump during surprise Washington trip". amNewYork. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
  95. ^ a b c O'Brien, Shane (March 6, 2026). "Mamdani's plans to revive Sunnyside Yards draws mixed reaction from local community". QNS. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  96. ^ O'Brien, Shane (April 8, 2026). "Nearly 200 residents attend Sunnyside Yard information session after Mamdani revives plans". QNS. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  97. ^ Schwach, Ryan (February 27, 2026). "'Trump Yard': Locals worry they'll be cut out of Mamdani, Trump Sunnyside Yard housing plan". Queens Daily Eagle. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  98. ^ Grieve, Jack (March 4, 2026). "What is the Sunnyside Yard deck plan – and why has it not yet been built?". Crain's New York Business. Archived from the original on March 8, 2026. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
  99. ^ Williams, Cali; Robbins, Jack (March 23, 2026). "Opinion: Turning Headlines Into Housing at Sunnyside Yard". City Limits. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
  100. ^ Gray, James (director) (2000). The Yards. Miramax.
  101. ^ Houghteling, Jack (2023). Sunnyside. Buddha Alien. ISBN 979-8375222400.

Sources

[edit]
[edit]
Wikimedia Commons logo
Wikimedia Commons has media related to Sunnyside Yard.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Sunnyside_Yard&oldid=1354389988"