Object Mentor Blog: Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces

Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces

Dean Wampler — Sun, 22 Jun 2008 16:52:00 -0500

Test driving user interface development has always been a challenge. Recently, I’ve worked with two projects where most of the work has been on the user-interface components.

The first project is using Adobe Flex to create a rich interface. The team decided to adopt FunFX for acceptance testing. You write your tests in Ruby, typically using Test::Unit or RSpec.

FunFX places some constraints on your Flex application. You have to define the GUI objects in MXML, the XML-based file format for Flex applications, rather than ActionScript, and you need to add ids to all elements you want to reference.[1]

These are reasonable constraints and the first constraint promotes better quality, in fact. The MXML format is more succinct (despite the XML “noise”) and declarative than ActionScript code. This is almost always true of UI code in most languages (with notable exceptions…). Declarative vs. imperative code tends to improve quality because less code means fewer bugs, less to maintain, and it frees the implementor of the declarative “language” to pick the best implementation strategies, optimizations, etc. This characteristic is typical of Functional Languages and well-designed Domain Specific Languages, as well.

I don’t think you can underestimate the benefit of writing less code. I see too many teams whose problems would diminish considerably if they just got rid of duplication and learned to be concise.

The second project is a wiki-based application written in Java. To make deployment as simple as possible, the implementors avoided the Servlet API (no need to install Tomcat, etc.) and rolled their own web server and page rendering components. (I’m not sure I would have made these decisions myself, but I don’t think they are bad, either…)

The rendering components are object-oriented and use a number of design patterns, such as page factories with builder objects that reflect the “widgets” in the UI, HTML tags, etc. This approach makes the UI very testable with JUnit and FitNesse. In fact, the development process was a model of test-driven development.

However, the final result is flawed! It is much too difficult to change the look and feel of the application, which is essential for most UI’s, especially web UI’s. The project made the wrong tradeoffs; the design choices met the requirements of TDD very well, but they made maintenance and enhancement expensive and tedious. The application is now several years old and it has become dated, because of the expense of “refreshing” the look and feel.

What should have been done? These days, most dynamic web UI’s are built with templating engines, of which there are many in the most common programming languages. Pages defined in a templating engine are very declarative, except for the special tags where behavior is inserted. The pages are easy to change. It is mostly obvious where a particular visual element is generated, since most of the “tags” in the template look exactly like the tags in the rendered page. “Declarative” templates, like good DSL’s, can be read, understood, and even edited by the stakeholders, in this case the graphical designers.

But how do you test these page templates? When test-driving UI’s it is important to decide what to test and what not to test. The general rule for TDD is to test anything that can break. The corollary, especially relevant for UI’s, is don’t test anything when you don’t care if it changes.

It is usually the dynamic behavior of the UI that can break and should be tested. Templating engines provide special tags for inserting dynamic behavior in the underlying language (Java, Ruby, etc.). This is what you should test. It is usually best to keep the scripts in these tags as small as possible; the scripts just delegate to code, which can be test-driven in the usual way.

I see too many UI tests that compare long strings of HTML. These tests break whenever someone makes a minor look and feel or other inconsequential change. Part of the art of UI TDD is knowing how to test just what can break and nothing more. In the second project, incidental changes to the UI break tests that should be agnostic to such changes.

To conclude, keep your UI’s as declarative as you can. Only test the “declarations” (e.g., templates) in areas where they might break, meaning if it changes, it’s a bug. You’ll get the full benefits of TDD and the freedom to change the UI easily and frequently, as needed.

¹ Disclaimer: my information on FunFX is second hand, so I might not have the details exactly correct; see the FunFX documentation for details.

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by ray ban rb4105

Tue, 15 May 2012 22:57:42 -0500

Persol Sunglasses come in a variety of styles and ray ban rb4105 colors to give you the look that you desire. The ray ban club master flawless finish and excellent craftsmanship are sunglasses what make people across the globe crave Persol Sunglasses.

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by Group golf holidays

Tue, 01 May 2012 12:26:17 -0500

Your article is extremely impressive. I never considered that it was feasible to accomplish something like that until after I looked over your post . Please visit our website for more information .

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by medical billing georgia

Thu, 08 Mar 2012 06:28:26 -0600

Test driven development is one of the central techniques in Extreme Programming.. and Test-driven development of GUIs is currently very difficult… Test Driven Development is a software development technique in which programmers writing failed test that will define the functionality before writing the actual code… medical billing georgia

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by Backup iPhone sms

Fri, 10 Feb 2012 03:03:14 -0600

well. your article is very useful for all the programmer and it can help me have a better code.

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by snow-http://www.timeadmin.org

Fri, 06 Jan 2012 23:54:31 -0600

Tissot Classic Dream Watch will be a happy life style. Do not hesitate to choose tissot ladies watches and tissot gents watches to add your charming and beauty everytime.

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by Breguet watches

Fri, 23 Dec 2011 21:22:19 -0600

you go to bed

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by tv show

Sun, 27 Nov 2011 04:29:38 -0600

thanks a lot for sharing. great stuff as always!

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by Bantningsmetoder

Mon, 31 Oct 2011 13:01:32 -0500

Seems great! Thanks. Observations of interfaces are very good.

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by ysbearing

Wed, 19 Oct 2011 03:41:16 -0500

Slewing bearing called slewing ring bearings, is a comprehensive load to bear a large bearing, can bear large axial, radial load and overturning moment.

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by seo

Thu, 22 Sep 2011 03:13:56 -0500

building rich interfaces which are supported by lighter code is good practice, no more sluggish flash stuff

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by Windows 8

Mon, 22 Aug 2011 06:22:09 -0500

user interface is very important feature to make things and website alive and easy to use..

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by oferta simyo

Tue, 10 May 2011 06:14:34 -0500

Nice observations

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by okey oyunu oyna

Wed, 27 Apr 2011 13:12:55 -0500

yes it is true

internette görüntülü olarak okey oyunu oyna, gerçek kisilerle tanis, turnuva heyecanini yasa.

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by nike shoes clearance

Thu, 24 Mar 2011 20:44:22 -0500

give you the method to move songs, video and so on backup to Mac from iPhone. nice tips.

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by Sanford NC Workers Compensation Attorneys

Thu, 10 Mar 2011 14:55:05 -0600

User interface is really important… it will be easy for us to see how its look ;)

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by iPad Video Converter for Mac

Wed, 09 Mar 2011 19:40:51 -0600

very useful information for me! I’ll come here everyday

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by lv

Mon, 07 Mar 2011 23:29:00 -0600

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by Criminal Records

Mon, 14 Feb 2011 15:59:18 -0600

The pages are easy to change. It is mostly obvious where a particular visual element is generated, since most of the “tags” in the template look exactly like the tags in the rendered page.

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by Apartments for rent Bucharest

Thu, 03 Feb 2011 07:54:23 -0600

Making tests independend of changes in look and feel makes them less fragile and thus more valuable

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by TactFit Commando Review

Thu, 03 Feb 2011 07:52:39 -0600

I found it very interesting and enjoyed reading all of it…keep it up, lovely job..Thank you for posting the great content.I was looking for something like this.I found it quiet interesting, hopefully you will keep posting such blogs..Keep sharing

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by electric winch

Mon, 24 Jan 2011 02:01:07 -0600

This article is very usefull for me! I can see that you are putting a lots of efforts into your blog. I will keep watching in your blog, thanks.

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by accounting services

Sun, 16 Jan 2011 11:04:00 -0600

Awesome article!Thanks for ur nice sharing..accounting services

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by ugg australia uk

Wed, 05 Jan 2011 22:58:44 -0600

can be worn with any outfit, be that a glamorous and sexy skirt, a business suit or a casual pair of jeans Any shoe store collection display whether online or otherwise will not be complete without offering their brand This is quite

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by replica watch rado

Wed, 05 Jan 2011 04:30:00 -0600

Hey ,boys and girls,nice to talk with you if you can see my message,and also it’s our fate to share my idea with you.what do you think of it?

"Observations on Test-Driving User Interfaces" by belstaff bag 556

Tue, 07 Dec 2010 03:52:56 -0600

http://www.belstaffdiscount.com/belstaff-bag-s Hey ,boys and girls,nice to talk with you if you can see my message,and also it’s our fate to share my idea with you.what do you think of it?